This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Artistic Form In King Lear Essay

1382 words - 6 pages

Artistic Form in King LearKing Lear has remained one of Shakespeare's best works, and one of the best tragedies of all time, since the beginning of the 17th century; however, some early critics believe that certain elements of the story do not satisfy the criteria for a proper tragedy. The two plot elements under speculation are the subplot and the catastrophic ending. The primary focus of the story is set on the elderly King Lear, whose pride and greed blinds him, causing him to banish his only pure daughter, Cordelia, along with his most loyal subject, Kent. He bestows his power and land upon his ungrateful daughters Regan and Goneril, who immediately plot to strip him of the remainder of ...view middle of the document...

He also reasoned that the audience would like a happy ending where justice and virtue prevailed. His reworking of the tale complies with the strict Neoclassical formula that was expected at the time. Tate's predictions proved correct when his altered version overshadowed the original for over a century. (Tate 344-45) (SC2 92)During the 18th Century, the controversy over the ending of King Lear continues as well as new controversy over Tate's rewritten ending. Critic Joseph Addison criticizes Tate's adaptation, claiming that it didn't have "half [the original's] beauty." He discredits the idea that virtue being victorious over corruption is obligatory in a tragedy and says that poetic justice has no foundation in nature or reason. Addison also argues that Shakespeare's work cannot be evaluated within classical guidelines. (Addison) Critic George Coleman later adds to the idea that a genius such as Shakespeare should be exempt from these guidelines. However most critics during the time period disagree with this approach, favoring Tate's rectification. They believe that the play should be assessed based on Neoclassical standards, and failure to adhere to the standards is viewed as "Ignorance of Mechanical Rules and the Constitution of his Story." (Theobald 72) It is generally agreed by these critics that the deaths of Lear and Cordelia contradict the "natural ideas of justice." (Johnson 705) The appropriateness of the Gloucester subplot is also questioned by Neoclassical standards because it is not immediately relevant to the primary plot of the story.Over the next century, Addison's perspective of the play becomes more widely accepted. The Romantic Movement brought about this change in the way the story of King Lear would be viewed structurally. The strict Neoclassical guidelines would be pushed aside by the less systematic Romantic interpretation. August Wilhelm Schlegel, a leader in the new Romantic interpretation, contests the notion that King Lear lacks dramatic form. He, along with other Romantic critics such as Charles Lamb, believes that the death of King Lear is essential and unavoidable on the grounds that "after surviving so many sufferings, Lear can only die." (Schlegel 413) Schlegel goes on to say that Cordelia must die in order to bring a just end to Lear. A majority of the play is based on Lear's suffering, and this principal theme would be lost in a happy ending. It is later argued that not only was such a catastrophic end necessary, but that even the virtuous characters brought death upon themselves, Lear and Gloucester by mistrusting their bonds between their children and Cordelia by refusing to humor Lear in the first scene, and responding with harshness even in his elder state. (Ulrici 203) The previously contested Gloucester subplot is also justified as it "contributes to the intrigue or denouement." (Schlegel 412) The subplot is further validated...

Other Papers Like Artistic Form In King Lear

Humanity's Fate in King Lear Essay

1924 words - 8 pages what could happen to humankind. He is responsible for his society. He is a representation of our own fate. The fate of humanity will be discussed in King Lear, by William Shakespeare. In this moving play, our tragic hero was King Lear. Our tragic hero must also have a tragic flaw. Lear's tragic flaw was his vanity. Lear is so full of himself that he doesn't realize the truth. First of all, Lear wants to divide his kingdom up into three parts

Self-Perception In Shakespeare's King Lear Essay

1088 words - 5 pages demands of Oswald, "Who am I," to which Oswald plainly replies, "My lady's father," (I. iv. 80-81). By replying in this manner, Oswald disrespects Lear by not recognizing him as the king but as simply another master in the household. Disobedience such as this cannot be regarded as anything but a sin. Finally, and throughout the rest of the play, his Fool disrespects Lear. Although the Fool is trying to help Lear to solve the mysteries that form the

Belief In "King Lear" William Shakespear

1465 words - 6 pages the play that these things do come to pass, not because of the movements of the planets, but because of the flaws in human nature.By constructing the parallel stories of Albany and Edmund, Gloucester and King Lear, Shakespeare creates a powerful play of deliverance. The contrasting characters of the play form a universal reality and exemplifies the cycle of human nature; indulgence, repentance, and restoration. Spiritual blindness leads Albany

Ways Shakespeare Presents Madness in King Lear

687 words - 3 pages Another way Shakespeare presents change in Lear’s identity is through the use of mental derangement. At the beginning of the play he is sane but mad. We can see this through Lear’s absurd decisions to decide the next rulers of the country with a ‘love test’. The self-inflated dignity of Lear. Has caused him to place the future of 8th century England in jeopardy in exchange for a mere few praises to affirm his status as king. A king is

Blindness In King Lear And Oedipus

957 words - 4 pages Interprets blindness in king lear/oedipus very good, pleasure to readTragedy is defined in Websters New Collegiate Dictionary as: 1) a medieval narrative poem or tale typically describing the downfall of a great man, 2) a serious drama typically describing a conflict between the protagonist and a superior force (as destiny) and having a sorrowful or disastrous conclusion that excites pity or terror. The play of King Lear is one of William

Filial Ingratitude In Shakespeare's King Lear

681 words - 3 pages Filial Ingratitude in Shakespeare's King Lear        In Shakespeare's King Lear, the main plot, which is focused around the error of King Lear, is mirrored by the subplot, which is based on the Earl of Gloucester's mistake. The main plot parallels the subplot in order to reiterate one of the main themes of the play, filial ingratitude.  At first, both Gloucester & Lear are unaware that their disloyal offspring are taking advantage of

Fools and Foolishness in King Lear

1726 words - 7 pages and places. By far the theme that best allowed the furthering of this superb contrast between Victorian England and Lear's own defined world is Shakespeare's discussion of fools and their foolishness This discussion allows Shakespeare to not only more fully portray human nature, but also seems to illicit a sort of Socratic introspection into the nature of society's own ignorance as well. One type of fool that Shakespeare involves in King Lear

The Importance Of A Parent Child Bond In King Lear

1147 words - 5 pages The Importance of a Parent Child Bond in King LearThe strongest, truest love is that a parent and child share. Unconditional and forever, it incorporates every division of love. Although, the bond between parent and child can be held together with great strength, either, can hold a persona or can disguise a certain aspect of their character. Seemingly, in King Lear it is quite evident that parents may not truly know what their child is capable

King Lear And Catcher In The Rye Comparison

350 words - 2 pages One point of similarity between these two texts, which works on the level of plot and theme, is a walk through a proverbial wilderness wherein the protagonist suffers, discovers truths about himself, and ultimately is humbled by his experiences.  Holden Caulfield takes a three day journey through New York City, fending for himself and suffering from an exposure to both nature and society. King Lear follows a very similar course in the play as

In What Ways Can ‘King Lear’ Be Read as a Tale of Forgiveness over Grudges?

1268 words - 6 pages In what ways can ‘King Lear’ be read as a tale of forgiveness over grudges? Shakespeare’s ‘King Lear’ is a play filled with tragedy and misfortunes, all at the cause of power and greed. However, despite the cruel nature of many of the characters, namely Lear, a sense of truth and forgiveness is demonstrated at the very end of ‘King Lear’. Forgiveness can be defined as a conscious, deliberate decision to release feelings of resentment or

How Does Shakespeare Explore the Theme of Justice in King Lear?

1954 words - 8 pages the illusion he created through forced order and face the forces that exist beyond his control. Lear dies having been able to recognise true love where, in contrast, Gloucester’s physical blindness prevents him from doing so, therein lies the role of Divine Justice in ‘King Lear’. Another form of justice found in ‘King Lear’ is Social Justice: whilst indicating Shakespeare's links to Humanism and the ongoing contemporary bourgeois-democratic

Related Essays

Justice In King Lear Essay

1547 words - 7 pages King Lear: Ideological Progression and Changing View of Justice The study of justice in King Lear is the study of the pitiable infirmity of man; Bradley makes the observation that “there never was vainer labour than that of critics who try to make out that the persons in King Lear meet with justice or their desserts” – at least not in any sense of a strict requital or such an adjustment of merit and prosperity as utopian morality would

Redemption In King Lear Essay

673 words - 3 pages exists, and in this reply to her father she is allowing him to be redeemed. He went from being a selfish tyrant to a loving father, and although the play ends with Cordelia’s tragic death and it ends in sadness, the final image of the play is more about Lear’s redemption than the sadness, as this redemption of the main character allows the audience to forgive him. This forgiveness from the audience is what makes “King Lear” stand out among other tragedies.

Justice In King Lear Essay

1217 words - 5 pages Vassallo Claire English Tutorial – King Lear At the end of King Lear the evil characters die a violent death, but so do the good ones. What does the play say about human and divine justice, or its absence? There are many evident themes in Shakespeare’s play, ‘King Lear’, but perhaps one of the most prevalent relates to the theme of justice. ‘King Lear’ is a brutal play, filled with human cruelty and awful disasters. The play’s

Severe Mercy In King Lear Essay

3267 words - 14 pages Severe Mercy in King Lear        The best thing about King Lear is that the deeper you dig, the more meat you find. It seems straightforward enough, except that every now and then something leaps out of the dialogue that severs the veil of coherent reality to strike sharp blows at the eternal Within. Even with a minimum of thought, few, I think, when considering King Lear, could emerge unshaken. There are shining archetypes of pain and