This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Article Review Of ‘Distorted Retrospective Eyewitness Reports

570 words - 3 pages

Length: 546 words (1.6 double-spaced pages)

Experimental Psychology
Article review of ‘Distorted Retrospective Eyewitness Reports as Functions of Feedback and Delay’ by Gary L. Wells, Elizabeth A. Olson, and Steve D. Charman.
Iowa State University
Journal of Experimental Psychology
This article was mainly about eye witnesses and the many errors they make in recalling a situation or describing a culprit whether they are asked immediately or after a period of time.
In this study, witnesses viewed a crime video and attempted to identify the culprit from a group line-up that did not actually have the culprit present. 253 mistaken-identification eyewitnesses were randomly given confirming, disconfirming, or no feedback regarding their description of the culprit or the culprit’s identification. The feedback process was either immediate or delayed for 48 hours, and measures were also immediate or delayed for ...view middle of the document...

They suggest that postidentification feedback from the lineup administrator has strong effects on how the eye witness remembers the original event and on how the eyewitness recalls the identification decision. They call this the Postidentification Feedback Effect. This Effect influences both the retrospective reports of confidence and the eyewitnesses’ retrospective reports of how good their view of the culprit was, how much attention they paid to the culprit, how long they took to identify the culprit and so on. According to the writers, any psychological interpretations of the postidentification feedback effect must take into account the broad range of effects on retrospective reports of the witnessing
experience rather than merely the effect on retrospective confidence.
There have also been recent studies that have replicated and extended the Postidentification Feedback Effect in various ways. According to one study, “the Postidentification Feedback Effect is reduced by having eyewitnesses think privately about their certainty, the view they had, and so on, prior to giving them feedback (Wells & Bradfield, 1999). In addition, the Postidentification Feedback Effect also applies to eyewitnesses who make accurate identifications, although the effect is stronger for those who make inaccurate identifications (Bradfield, Wells, & Olson, 2002). Recent experiments also indicate that the Postidentification Feedback Effect works for nonidentifications (e.g., “not there” responses) as well as for identifications (Semmler, Brewer, & Wells, 2002)”.
The Postidentification Feedback Effect is very important because of the confidence and certainty of the eye witness. Those who were confident and paid close attention to the culprit at the time of witnessing might be accurate witnesses or inaccurate witnesses who were given confirming feedback. There are also theoretical reasons to believe that the postidentification feedback effect may be even stronger when feedback
is delayed than when it is not delayed. Different studies have been done to show this.

Other Papers Like Article Review of ‘Distorted Retrospective Eyewitness Reports

An Article Review of Koen Van Eijk and John Lievens's "Cultural Omnivorousness as a Combination of Highbrow, Pop, and Folk Elements"

1398 words - 6 pages The Omnivore Debate: An Article Review van Eijk, Koen and John Lievens. 2008. “Cultural Omnivorousness as a Combination of Highbrow, Pop, and Folk Elements: The Relation Between Taste Patterns and Attitudes Concerning Social Integration.” Poetics 36. 217-242. While most scholars acknowledge the elusiveness that the term “culture” invokes, perhaps even more tenuous is the understanding of preferential taste of particular aspects of culture

Review of Article: “Statin Use and Risk of Cerebral Aneurysm Rupture: a Hospital-Based Case-Control Study in Japan, ” Y. Yoshimura, Y. Murakami, Et Al

5167 words - 21 pages Review of article: “Statin Use and Risk of Cerebral Aneurysm Rupture: A Hospital-based Case-control Study in Japan,” Y. Yoshimura, Y. Murakami, et al. Design and Data Collection The presented study is a case-control study design, meaning it is based on measuring the associations between statin administration and the likely rupture of a cerebral aneurysm in purposefully selected indicator and control populations. The foundation of the study

Article Review : “Objectivity and the Development of Negro Studies, ” in Melville J. Herskovits and the Racial Politics of Knowledge

524 words - 3 pages Jerry Gershenhorn, “Objectivity and the Development of Negro Studies,” in Melville J. Herskovits and the Racial Politics of Knowledge (Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 2000): 123-167 “Objectivity and the Development of Negro Studies” in Melville J. Herskovits and the racial Politics of Knowledge by Jerry Gershenhorn discusses the impact of Melville Herskovits and his ideas on racial politics. Herskovits’s work primarily focused

Article Review: “If I Killed You, I’D Get The Kids: Women’S Survival And Protection Work With Child Custody And Access In The Context Of Woman Abuse”

1186 words - 5 pages INTRODUCTION The main aim of the “If I Killed You, I’d Get the Kids: Women’s Survival and Protection Work with Child Custody and Access in the Context of Woman Abuse” article, was to propose, “how women work to negotiate formal systems in relation to child custody and access in the context of woman abuse” (Varcoe & Irwin, 2004, p. 78). Academic and community researchers, including a social action group, collaboratively conducted the entire

Review Of Article "Asymmetric Reactions To Work Group Sex Diversity Among Men And Women" Written By Jennifer A. Chatman And Charles A. O'reilly

1476 words - 6 pages Introduction:The article explores how work group sex composition influences men and women and how this affects firm - performance. Past researches indicated that demographic similarities yielded improved financial performance (Byrne, 1971) yet the recent findings estimate that women expressed a greater likelihood of gender diversity than men. This paper is the first to explain why variations in work group sex composition might affect men and

Children's Reliablity In Court

2175 words - 9 pages suggestion, and the delay between a crime and providing an eyewitness statement are some factors that can influence the reliability of these reports. Eyewitness reports provided by children can be reliable if given within a reasonable time frame, and that the presented questions are not suggestive. Also, that the eyewitness reports are provided by older children (9 to 12 years old), their reports tend to be more reliable than those of younger

Let’s Abandon or Strictly Regulate Eyewitnesses Testimony in Criminal Trials

3927 words - 16 pages exhumed all over the world because of new DNA advances and fingerprinting techniques that can disprove prior eyewitness testimony. As new forms of identification techniques become available, we will continue to hear about prior injustices due to eyewitness testimony in criminal cases. Most judges and lawyers will agree that eyewitness accounts are often distorted by most people’s inability to remember what really happened. False eyewitness

Cpa Re[Prt Memorandum

2147 words - 9 pages independent in fact and appearance when providing auditing and other attestation services. Section ET 56 – Article V – Due Care A member should observe the profession's technical and ethical standards, strive continually to improve competence and the quality of services, and discharge professional responsibility to the best of the member's ability. Audit vs. Review There are significant differences between the objectives of an audit of financial


563 words - 3 pages we have scrum meetings and sprints should be schedule. SPRINT RETROSPECTIVE and SPRINT REVIEW/DEMO. Retrospective: Challenges faced. Next sprint solutions . Sprint review: development should demo in front of the clients and should be accepted. If not next sprint. Next class review and kind test. Design: User frndly - Archtect/senior developer. High level- Syst design; Architec Design, modular design, Interface design low level design

Crimal Justice

572 words - 3 pages I completely and 100 percent agree with everything that the article says and its deeper meaning. Personally, I have always thought to myself while watching “Law and Order”, what would happen if someone during the eyewitness accounts really didn’t know who the culprit was. If he or she made a mistake in choosing who did the crime. At this point these people could be sending innocent people into jail for a crime that they did not commit or

Reading Research Literature #1

1290 words - 6 pages , kept memos on the experience and took notes on key points that needed further clarification. 1) What characteristics does this study possess that are qualitative in nature? Review Chapter 2. 2) There are many definitions of qualitative research, including, “Qualitative researchers are interested in understanding the meaning people have constructed, that is, how people make sense of their world and the experiences they have

Related Essays

Review Of Article

727 words - 3 pages Article Review HCS 430 July 29, 2013 Melissa Borrelli Article Review Introduction: In this article The Concept of Addiction in Law and Regulatory Policy Related to Pain Management This appears in criminal and in crimes the author of this article Aaron M. Gilson MS, MSSW PhD argues that in order for a physician to declare a person a drug addict compulsive behavior must also be noted. This paper will be analyzing Gilson’s

Treatment Of Canine Atopic Dermatitis Article Review

410 words - 2 pages Treatment of Canine Atopic Dermatitis Article Review In the article, Olivry et al. (2010) provides various response on treating atopic dermatitis in dogs. Suggestions on specific intervention are provided based on evidence gathered at the time the author was writing an article. Most of the arguments are based on clinical trials that registered significant results. However, some of recommended intervention contained in the articles lacks enough

The Cues Program: A Review Of A Nursing Journal Article

738 words - 3 pages The Cues Program: A Review of a Nursing Journal Article Rachel M NURS The Cues Program: A Review of a Nursing Journal Article Infants born weighing less than 1,500 g are called very low birth weight (VLBW) infants. These infants are usually preterm and often require hospitalization in a neonatal intensive care unit (NICU.) VLBW infants are at higher risk of developmental problems so there has been an emphasis on developing programs

Article Review Of "A Better Way To Tax Us Businesses"

799 words - 4 pages “A Better Way to Tax U.S. Businesses” is a persuasive article written by Mihir Desai. Three principles are proposed that could “improve the competitive position of the United States and the living standards of Americans” (p.2). It is important for tax structures to mirror the world economy, which is characterized by declining tax rates. Corporate tax reform should be implemented separately from fundamental tax reform and should be for the most