This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Article Rebuttal Essay

666 words - 3 pages

​The essay I reviewed is titled “Western Culture Promotes Divorces” written by Sundeep Shukla as a competitive essay for his examination into the Civil Service India. A Federal Public Service Commission was set up under the Government of India Act in 1935. Under this act, provision was also made for the formation of Union Public Service Commissions (UPSC) at the regional levels. The Indian Civil Service is considered the backbone of India and holds many responsibilities and respect in the eyes of their Nation. Prospective candidates submit competitive essays and complete interviews in order to be recruited as a member of service to fill corporate and government jobs.
​After reading Shukla’s point of view on the Western Culture being responsible for the increased divorce rate in India, I was dismayed to think that this person is considered a qualifying candidate to serve as a possible government official in India. Shukla stated “People are selfish and are too lazy to work on ...view middle of the document...

Earlier in the article, Shukla opened with explaining arrangement marriages in India and how many strive to reach the historical tradition of being matched up with their life partner. He noted that even though arranged marriages for profit or exchange was outlawed in 1961, the society and culture still maintains these acts without letting authorities know about it.
​Shukla concludes with the statement that “Divorce rates can be reduced by changing the way people think and bringing them [Indians] out from the impact of Western Culture”. I believe internationally that rates of divorce have increased due to equality expectations from women. Now that many cultures worldwide are going into the 21 century, they are realizing that women are equal parts to men and must share in the same responsibility as well as the same standards of earning respect and admiration.
After reading a news article in the BBC South Asia News, Author Mark Dummett interviewed several divorcees in India claiming that they blame the new and the old expectations that are held in marriage, along with the growth of their own culture. Interviewee Mohit stated that troubles in the marriage started with disapproving parents and were finalized when his wife walked out. Mohit stated “Today the Indian male is a very complex entity. We want our wives to be really progressive or modern, which is why we married them in the first place. But at the same time, we still want our wives to cook food for us and be there when we get home.” He admitted that he found it too hard to accept that his wife had her own career, and that it wasn’t him.
Shukla’s article titled “Western Culture Promotes Divorces” does not include the perspective of the Indian people or even proof that Western Culture has a direct impact on India’s divorce rates. He simply stated his opinion and placed blame without providing any logical reasoning.

​​

References
Shukla, S. (n.d.). Western Culture Promotes Divorces. Civil Service India. Retrieved from http://www.civilserviceindia.com/subject/Essay/western-culture-promotes-divorces1.html
Dummett, M,. (2010, December). Not so happily ever after as Indian divorce rate doubles. BBC News South Asia, (),. Retrieved from http://www.civilserviceindia.com/subject/Essay/western-culture-promotes-divorces1.html

Other Papers Like Article Rebuttal

Bcom 275 Week 3 Article Rebuttal

782 words - 4 pages Article Rebuttal Kao Saechao BCOM/275 February 9th, 2015 Dr. Sharla Walker Article Rebuttal Vaccination in children has been a touchy topic for today’s society. Do I vaccinate my child and risk life-changing diseases or do I not vaccinate my child and run the risk of other children catching diseases? On one hand, there are parents who decide not to vaccinate their children for the fear of long-term diseases such as Autism

Article Rebuttal Essay

693 words - 3 pages Should the Federal Affirmative Action Program be abandoned? Should the Federal Affirmative Action Program be abandoned? Yes, the federal affirmative action program should be abandoned. Affirmative action is controversial because many people believe it encourages special treatment of certain groups and encourages so-called reverse discrimination. When we became citizens of this nation we received a warranty. We were guaranteed the right

Article Rebuttal

699 words - 3 pages article considering that I am first of all a young lady, and I am a college student who goes on dates as well. This article as stated by many cannot draw any certain conclusions mainly because of how difficult it would be to gather the necessary people to participate in the research. A researcher could very well gather certain participants who are willing to participate but the actual people who have been involved in sexual aggression and/or date

Bcom 275 Week 3

603 words - 3 pages ARTICLE REBUTTAL – GUN CONTROL 1 Article Rebuttal – Gun Control Xxxxxx Xxxxx BCOM 275 20 Mar 14 Ceasar I Elpidio Article Rebuttal – Gun Control For this assignment I chose an article titled “Data suggest guns do in fact kill people” (M.S., Sep 2013). The author of the article tries to use data to show a correlation between the prevalence of firearms with the amount of homicides committed by them. To support his

Artical Rebuttal

544 words - 3 pages Article Rebuttal BCOM 275 January 23, 2012 Abstract Article Name: Why Abortion is right even if it’s wrong: Author: Richard X. Thripp Article Rebuttal The author, Richard X. Thripp, begins the article by stating “going down a hypothetical path where abortion is ethical and just, despite knowing it isn’t” ( para1). I do not agree with this statement because I believe women should have the right to decide having an abortion or not. Do

Acc 555 Wk 5 Midterm Exam - All Possible Questions

1225 words - 5 pages guidelines. BCOM 275 week 3 Individual Assignment Article Rebuttal Locate an article on a controversial subject where the author makes an argument you do not agree with. Write a 350- to 700-word rebuttal to the article using valid arguments and supporting data. In the rebuttal, offer an analysis in which you do the following: • Analyze the reliability, credibility, and validity of the data used by the author. • Identify any logical

Bcom 275 Entire Class Individual and Team Assignments and Dqs Bcom 275 (Business Communications & Critical Thinking)

1225 words - 5 pages consistent with APA guidelines.   BCOM 275 week 3 Individual Assignment Article Rebuttal Locate an article on a controversial subject where the author makes an argument you do not agree with.   Write a 350- to 700-word rebuttal to the article using valid arguments and supporting data. In the rebuttal, offer an analysis in which you do the following:   • Analyze the reliability, credibility, and validity of the data used by the author

Articel Rebuttal

863 words - 4 pages Article Rebuttal Becky Waldron BCOM/275 Kenneth White June 5, 2012 Article Rebuttal According to Carl Hiaaseen of the Miami Herald, drug testing welfare applicants is a failing program that only pays off for the drug screening companies and this policy was designed to single out the individuals living in poverty. The new law, which was passed on March 31, 2011, requires all welfare applicants to submit to a drug test before benefits

Rubuttal Of School Uniforms

345 words - 2 pages Article Rebuttal Amanda Gapski BCOM/275 October 1, 2012 Kim Hinton This is an article that is in favor of school uniforms. It claims that uniforms offer safety in the environment and helps stop competition about clothes (Boutelle, 2007). It does offer some good, albeit rhetorical, claims for uniforms. It lays claim that uniforms offer “uniformity” so that children are easier to keep track of in on field trips and allows administration

Articual Rebuttal

833 words - 4 pages Article Rebuttal XBCOM/275 Tynia M. Landry 03/14/2014 Article Rebuttal In this paper the subject discussed concerns the 2008 introduction of California Proposition 8. It will contest the statements made by the author and provide meaningful information that will rebut the misleading assertions documented in the article. Statement 1 According to Laura Brill, the author of the article – It’s time for Prop. 8 opponents to re-engage

Leaglization of Marijuana

579 words - 3 pages Article Rebuttal: Legalization of Marijuana BCOM/275 November 1, 2011 Dave Moses This term paper is to examine an article based on an argument to legalize marijuana. In this article the author looks at the benefits of legalizing marijuana. One of the first items that is examined in the article is the taxation that the government could place on marijuana if it were to be legalized. The author examines when the marijuana tax act and how

Related Essays

Article Rebuttal Essay

751 words - 4 pages Article Rebuttal BCOM/275 1/27/2014 Article Rebuttal “A well-regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms, shall not be infringed” (U.S. Const., am 2). Since the ratification of the Bill of Rights, including the Second Amendment in 1791, our right to bear arms has been under attack. This article rebuttal will focus on an USA Today article titled “Epidemic: Guns

Article Rebuttal Essay 609 Words

609 words - 3 pages ARTICLE REBUTTAL Rachel Bailey BCOM/275 September 10, 2013 Vialet Rayne The article that I decided to dispute is about a victim who has to pay child support to the aggressor. According to the article, a 15 year-old boy who was raped by a 34 year-old women is now being subpoenaed to pay child support. Thirty-four year-old, Linda Kazinsky, repeatedly raped the now 19 year-old Jeremy Steen on a weekly basis for 3 years. After Steen alerted

Bcom 275 Article Rebuttal Essay

530 words - 3 pages Article Rebuttal Christine MacRae BCOM 275 February 23, 2015 Lloyd Krieger Article Rebuttal According to an article found on the Natural News website, vaccines are one of the primary contributing factors related to increased rates of autism. (Adams, 2014) The article goes on to provide supporting quotes from various authors on the subject. Of those supporting quotes, some claim that a preservative called thimerosal found in vaccines

Final Article Rebuttal Essay

882 words - 4 pages Gay Marriages Kimberly Sousa BUSCOM/275 Version 2 May 9, 2013 Kevin McCoyd Article Rebuttal The paper will have the contents of an article I decided to do for reasons that will be revealed in the conclusion. The topic is from the New York Daily News Gay Marriage the title is “Five arguments against gay marriage: Society must brace for corrosive change.” The author talks about many areas of concerns throughout the article. One is