Argument Paper For Drone Warfare

1411 words - 6 pages

1 February 2013

Drones For or Against?
First came professional war, then privatized war, then mercenary and outsourced war – all of which made war ever more remote from most Americans. Finally, both literally and figuratively, came remote war itself. People map the evolution of U.S. warfare from the professional war (post-Vietnam era when soldiers are no longer drafted but paid volunteers) to the privatized war (1990s when corporations become more involved in warfare) to the mercenary and outsourced war (post 9/11 era when for-profit industrial complex carries out military and intelligence responsibilities in Iraq, Afghanistan and elsewhere) to the next phase, remote ...view middle of the document...

This analysis will examine arguments for and against the use of drones in warfare, taking into consideration the influence of international law and human rights. The arguments for Drone Warfare many support the use of drones, claiming it puts less American soldiers in harm’s way and kills fewer civilians than the alternative. Most argue that drones are effective militarily. Drones can strike in impassable terrain, fly over enemy territory and need to refuel less than manned jets. Training drone controllers is faster and significantly cheaper than training pilots. Future drones may be more effective than traditional fighter jets as they will be able to avoid radar detection and gain hyper- maneuverability. Drones are considered by some to be an effective anti-terrorism mechanism. They are feared by terrorists more than elite troops because they are nearly invisible and almost completely silent. They have weakened militant groups, such as the Taliban and al Qaeda in Pakistan who have stopped using electronic devices and who no longer gather in large numbers. Some militant leaders even spend their nights outside for safety reasons. The result is battle fatigue and decreased ability to mobilize.
The Obama administration justifies the drone attacks under international law and the U.S. constitution. US Attorney General Eric Holder notes that the U.S. constitution guarantees due process, but not judicial process. Holder claims that the following conditions must be met by a target to be killed by a drone: the target must be “senior operational leader of al-Qaida or associated forces” otherwise known as an “enemy combatant.” The target must be planning at attack against the U.S. and be located in a country that has given the U.S. authority to strike. The target must not be able to be captured at the time the decision is made. Thus, the use of drones falls under the category of “imminent threat.” These preconditions align with the Geneva Convention-based Law of Armed Conflict that requires verification of military targets, precautionary measures to minimize civilian harm and the avoidance of disproportionate collateral damage. Some members of the Pakistani military support the drones, at least privately, because they have benefitted from some of the attacks. For example a 2009 drone attack killed Baitullah Mehsud, leader of a militant alliance who was suspected to behind the 2007 assassination of former Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto. Drones have forced some Taliban officials to leave their homes, a feature that was impossible for the Pakistani military to achieve using traditional methods that often led to the loss of military personnel and unwanted engagement with local villagers. People living in the areas are conflicted. Many favor drone strikes compared to other military operations or less selective bombardments. Thus, compared to the alternative, drones can be considered the lesser evil.
The argument against Drone Warfare, many are...

Other Papers Like Argument Paper for Drone Warfare

Drones Applications Into Logistics Essay

2764 words - 12 pages offices, and are utilized by organizations for reviewing, assessing, and imaging, and their mechanical advancement are driven by dynamic groups of specialists and fans of drone technology. This pressure presents extraordinary difficulties to their incorporation in the as of now existing open, legislative and private foundation. In this report, a couple of these issues to see how automatons could affect the advanced logistics, and provide

Warfare Is Not A Necessity Essay

475 words - 2 pages this essay. The first view talks about an aggressive and competitive human nature who is down to the very basic of needs. Those who take this view Mead points out wish to outlaw war or at least find different ways of competing given that it is part of man’s nature to fight and go to war. The second view that Mead points out is that warfare is inevitable. Those who take this stance feel that there is a struggle for power and possessions unless we

Cyber Warfare

596 words - 3 pages For over a decade, the concept of cyber warfare (computer warfare) has bee embedded i military doctrine. I 2000 the Defece white paper stated a ambition to repond to cyber warfare attacks. The 2007 Defence Update went further by calling for a focus on 'cyber warfare' to protect 'national networks and deny information'. The most recent Defence White Paper in 2009 also announced a 'major enhancement of Defence's cyber warfare capability...to

Does Using Drones to Attack Terrorists Globally Violate Interenational Law?

1584 words - 7 pages unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) and have increased substantially under the Presidency of Barack Obama. Generally the UAVs used are MQ-1 Predator and more recently MQ-9 Reaper firing AGM-114 Hellfire missiles. The drones have become a weapon of choice for the United States in the fight against al-Qaeda. Some media refer to the series of attacks as a "drone war". Pakistan's government publicly condemns these attacks but has secretly shared

Terrorism in Pakistan: Causes and Consequences

3167 words - 13 pages for the sake of peace in the very core of Pakistan. Sometimes it is ascribed with different name like home-grown terrorism, or that it is providing safe heaven to infiltrators but these argument lack solid evidence. Now world is looking at Pakistan form different angle. The repeated attacks on the non-governmental organization’s offices as well as workers, attacks on civilians as well as army and police have changed the scenario in the Pakistan

Contemporary Warfare In The New Guinea Highlands

2496 words - 10 pages an individual conflict escalating into warfare is directly related to the structural distance between conflicting parties.The largest political group to unite in warfare is the tribe, a group of severalthousand individuals. Tribes are segmented into clans whose members see themselves as unifies group. The subclan section ( or one-blood group ) is the first to mobilize for warfare. The potential for expansion of such conflicts depends to a large

Bouncing Ball 1

572 words - 3 pages at their decision? As of recently, drones have been a technology that is talked about in several state and country legislations. Some say that drones are not needed; others see them as an aid for the 21st century. Californian senators, Barbara Boxer1 and Dianne Feinstein2, have voted that drones not be used in California. In August of 2013, a Californian wildfire broke out destroying many homes. During this incident, a drone briefly interfered

Hi My Name Is Julie

1863 words - 8 pages The topic that I chose for my reaserch paper is the limitations that should be applied to the parizi. I chose this topic because I wanted to see how much the pree and media have acces to the celrites. I want to fight for the celberite cause I deserve they need more privercy. My topic is the limitations that should be applied to the paparazzi. I wanted to see how much the press and media have access to the celebrities. Celebrities are just

intelligence

1063 words - 5 pages responsibilities and practices for national and homeland security. Define and Differentiate On paper, CIA and NSA are mostly international intelligence gathering agencies, while other agencies in the Intelligence Community (IC) are domestic agencies.  But they have many overlaps in information sharing and shared jurisdictions in some cases.  As a practical matter, NSA in particular, seems to be playing both sides of the field international and domestic

The History Of Drones

2009 words - 9 pages military arsenal has expanded from 60 to more than 6,000, with President Obama making unprecedented use of these robotic warriors. Drone strikes have taken out some of al-Qaeda’s most notorious figures, including American-born cleric Anwar al-Awlaki”. Bibliography Bone, Elizabeth, and Christopher Bolkcom. "Unmanned Aerial Vehicles: Background and Issues for Congress." Report for Congress (2003): n. pag. Print. This is a report of Congress

With Great Mind Comes Great Work

5252 words - 22 pages and poor working conditions to sell their products in our country. 6. The US should let the European Union bear a greater share of the burden of global securi- ty and encourage them to take greater responsibility for maintaining security in regions troubled by civil unrest, terrorist groups, and regional warfare. 7. American foreign policy makers should not look to the United Nations or any other inter- national organization for consensus on when

Related Essays

The Ethics Of Unmanned Drones Essay

3331 words - 14 pages unmanned drones in the War on Terror. One of the few disadvantages to drone attacks is civilian casualties. It is obvious that drones have taken innocent lives, but the real debate is over how many and if alternative approaches are any better. According to the Bureau of Investigative Journalism, a non-for-profit news organization based in London, nearly 900 non-combatants, including nearly 200 children, were killed by U.S drone strikes in 2011

Drones Technology Essay

1173 words - 5 pages , they cannot connect with citizens for more comprehensive intelligence. Drones are unable to capture surrendering armed workers and unrestricted hardware. Warfare with using technology of drones can usually cause civilian Losses. Drone warfare often causes security injuries in civilian lives & also damage their property. Counterproductive & Disrupting of several places also result of drones attack. Civilian views about technology of

Legal Issues Surrounding Defense Drones Essay

3513 words - 15 pages Introduction The term “drone” covers a wide variety of unmanned aerial vehicles. Drones range in size from one pound to 30,000 pounds. Various components can be added to a drone to increase its capability. Drones can be heat-seeking or capable of detecting certain chemicals, for example. Because of the variety of functions of drones, there is a great deal of interest in both public and private sectors in expanding drone usage. As drone use

The Drone Strikes Again Essay

985 words - 4 pages action being good or bad, what was important was the premeditated idea behind the action, was it right or wrong, unrelated to the consequences. Therefore, if actions are not based on consequences, Kant’s theory would support the argument that using drone tactics to eliminate terrorists is morally unacceptable, for the following reasons: the U.S. military is using drone tactics against terrorist without their consent, and innocent lives are being taken