This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Arctic Deer Live On Islands In Canada's Arctic Regions. They Search For Food By Moving Over Ice From Island To Island During The Course Of The Year. Their Habitat Is Limited To Areas Warm Enough To Sustain The Plants On

652 words - 3 pages

The argument above attributes the decline in the population of deer residing on arctic islands in Canada to global warming. However in the current form this argument is flawed and incomplete. It can be stated as true only if it provides certain evidence in the form of reliable data, statistics and research.

The first major piece of evidence that could strengthen this argument is the confirmation of the decline in the deer population by a source more reliable than 'local hunters'. It is possible that the hunters might have not been able to gauge the trends of these 'migrating' deer accurately, and the deer may have been in some other regions of the island than predicted by these hunters. Would there be a report by a group of biologists studying these deer, stating that the population of these deer is on a decline, could the argument have carried some weightage. In fact it would be reinforced if data citing ...view middle of the document...

Second, that the decline is not because of any other reason. Inordinate hunting, decline in the general health of deer due to a disease spreading amongst them causing increased deaths, lack of proper grazing areas, some calamity in the past years such as a glacier, which in the recent past caused the death of large herds of deer, all these are potential causes for the decline of deer and the argument needs to refute these.

Once the ambiguity of the authors claim has been resolved, the argument needs to show how global warming has affected these deer. It needs to show whether the path followed by these deer through the year is being affected by global warming. It could be the ice melting in the region in the regions along which these deer travel and, it could be specifically melting before they get a chance to cross onto the other islands. Studies should be conducted to show where the deer reside if they cannot migrate from island to island. It needs to show that the food for these deer is insufficient in the region where they are forced to stay.
Additionally, the exact reason for the decline of deer needs to be stated. Is it due to lack of food leading to deaths due to starvation, or is it that the environment has become unfavorable due to global warming. The death, for all we know, could be due to large numbers of deer localizing in a particular are, now that they cannot migrate leading to territorial fights, or deprivation of food causing lack in vitality and affecting the number of infants born, and the survival of these infants. Thus, further specification of the cause of death beyond just stating the general environmental problem of 'global warming', may provide some credibility to the argument.

In summary, the conclusion to the argument is not logical since there is no evidence to support the claims in the argument.The argument may well be true but is not believable, until it gives evidence to fill the large gaps in the argument. Only if it can prove every statement with evidence which may be along the lines of those mentioned above, can it be said to be a solid argument.

Other Papers Like Arctic Deer Live on Islands in Canada's Arctic Regions. They Search for Food by Moving over Ice from Island to Island During the Course of the Year. Their Habitat Is Limited to Areas Warm Enough to Sustain the Plants on

What is your opinion on the idea that it is better to live today than it was to live in the nineteenth century?

531 words - 3 pages done was directly proportional to ones' energy. This problem has as well be curbed by the introduction of machines, making work much more easier.Introduction of television and computers has brought about awareness in all fields. Unlike in the old days where people from one geographical area couldn't know what was happening in the other parts one is able to know all the happenings of a different place without having to travel. Introduction of

Difficulties of Moving from One Culture to Another. Using Presents Form My Aunts in Pakistan, and Search for My Tongue

1188 words - 5 pages stopping her from being part of Pakistan. She is an outsider and belongs to no culture, she has not adjusted to moving from one place to another and feels sad and alone. Search for my Tongue shows the difficulties of moving from one culture to another through the variation of language and how hard it is to have to speak two languages and remember them; however the poet in the end comes to terms with this and has settled in the new culture, by

Agathis Macrophylla: The Kauri Reserve On The Island Of Erromango

1321 words - 6 pages form, and self-pruning characteristics. As a result they are considered to be among the most promising seed sources in the Agathis genus for use in plantation development. Some of the earliest ecological records of A. macrophylla occurred in the 1930’s on Espiritu Santo and Erromango island. These surveys referred to large, scattered, emergent Kauri in elevated forests west of the main island ridges. In 1975 A. E. Beveridge noted that Erromango

Singapore Tradenet: Beyond Tradenet to the Intelligent Island

1121 words - 5 pages past can be used for building a new information infrastructure for the future? I would recommend a thorough and deep analysis on what is desired, what resources do you have available and how to use those resources efficiently? Why do I say this? Because in the 1960’s when Singapore started attracting investors towards establishing their technologic infrastructures there, they did not even studied their possibilities and how they could offer

Escape From The Desert Island

587 words - 3 pages bombarded me with, I decided to take a tour of the island, and search for a possible means of escape. 'OH SHI-!' I stopped myself short of a curse, and looked down at my aching toe. I painfully leaned over and examined the ground around my feet, discovering a 1922 Sears catalogue. Exhausted and hungry, I reached for a coconut from the only tree. I leaned against the palm tree eating the coconut and leafing through the ancient catalogue. Thinking aloud

The Confederate War Effort 'Why Were The Confederate States Able To Sustain Their War Effort Until The End Of 1862?'

824 words - 4 pages were defending their own homes. An example of this is how E. Lee was so determined to defend Richmond, and 'never let it fall'. Southern morale didn't only affect the soldiers in battle, however, as civilians in the South were very much involved in the war effort, whereas in the North they merely continued on with their own lives.Another advantage for the South was that their military leaders were much more experienced, especially since the

The Effects of Homelessness in Children on Their Ability to Be Successful in Their Adult Life

1285 words - 6 pages effects being a child without a home might have on the ability of those children to be successful in their adult lives. Literature Review: When considering reasons for developmental delays in skills among homeless children, there are many areas that should be reviewed. First of all, let us talk about what might constitute as a “developmental delay in skills”. According the Molnar, Rath, and Klein, when they studied the impact of homelessness on

What Is The Benefit And Challenges In Moving From Single Last Click Attribution To Multi-Channel Attribution Modelling

7741 words - 31 pages , marketers have to consider factors, which are important to their business and the conversion paths, and further layer in these factors by adding respective custom credit rules to create a customised attribution model. After introducing the basic background of MCAM in marketing analytics, it is essential for marketers to understand the benefits and challenges in moving from   12   last-click to multichannel attribution model. The

Describe the Evolutionary Developments That Enabled the Successful Colonisation of Terrestrial Habitat by the Early Plants

1312 words - 6 pages and the embryo. In water gametes swim freely in the water without drying and the resulting zygote can float in the water. On land both gametes and the zygote will dry if not protected. The early plants adapted by developing a multicellular antheridia and archegonia for the production of gametes. The sperm is the only mobile gamete and it waits until there is enough dew or raindrops to splash it onto the archegonia where it swims to the ovum and

Conclusions Drawn From My Experiment On The Effect Of Enzyme Concentration On The Time Taken For A Reaction To Occur

755 words - 4 pages my results stuck pretty well to our curve of best fit.My results indicate a negative correlation because of the fact that the amount of enzyme added will have an effect on reaction time. At 1% urease the reaction took 1782 seconds and at 2% urease the reaction took 795 seconds. The reason for this decrease is because of the increased concentration in urease solution there will be more active sites for the urea to react with in 2% urease. The more

The right to food is the right of every person

1178 words - 5 pages The right to food is the right of every person. Every individual must have regular access to sufficient, nutritionally adequate and culturally acceptable food for an active and healthy life. At present, this is a major development in-challenge in India. We cannot feel proud of our achievements in different areas until this basic need of each individual is met. About 21 per cent of the population was undernourished in 1997. In 1999, over 53 per

Related Essays

Five Year Strategic Plan For Baderman Island Resort

691 words - 3 pages basis (McConnell, Brue, & Flynn, 2009). According to McConnell, Brue, and Flynn recent efforts made by the fed have helped banks maintain their reserve ratio despite reserve reductions in the wake of mortgage loan defaults. However, commercial lending institutions’ continued reluctance to loan is choking the size of the monetary multiplier leaving a smaller money supply available than the fed desires from its expansionary monetary policy

Arctic Survival – From Success To Failure

1723 words - 7 pages Arctic Survival – From Success to Failure Contrary to the outcome exhibited by most other groups during the Arctic Survival exercise, our team score (34) was lower than my individual score (64). This is not to suggest that group collaboration is detrimental; in fact, our outcome was unique among the class and of great surprise to the professor and entire class section. To be sure, pooling resources, elaboration of material, and support and

Snowy Owls Of The Arctic Essay

1333 words - 6 pages .). This decline in food source is due to climate change which allowed the arctic region to warm causing a decline in local population of snowy owls (Gilg, Sittler, & Hanski, 2009). Snowy owls tend to be like other owls in that they are monogamous and mate for life. They are fiercely protective of their nests and breeding area. They will go so far as to attack wolves if they believe them to be a threat (“Snowy Owl”, 2012). This extreme protection

Discuss The Establishment And Development Of The Chesapeake/Virigina Colonies From The Mid 1650s To 1763. How Did They Compare To Those In The Spanish And French Areas?

1204 words - 5 pages wealthy to fend for themselves as far as labor on their crops was concerned. The importation of African slaves greatly increased the population after 1698 when the Crown dropped the monopoly causing even more merchants to participate. In 1660 there were 900 blacks in Chesapeake, two decades later there were 4,300 and by 1720 one fifth of the population was black. Virginia had specific laws that determined the differences between white servants and