Midterm Extra Credit
Why is theory relevant to archeological practice or, to put it another way, why is common sense not enough, according to the author (Johnson) of your theory textbook?
Theory is relevant to archeological practice because as archeologists we need to justify what we do, we need to evaluate one interpretation of the past against another, to decide which is the stronger, we must be explicit in what we do as archeologists, and finally we don’t ‘need’ theory we all use theory whether we like it or not. What Johnson means by this numerous list of why theory is relevant is that archeology is very important and should not be ignored, we as humans should know what happened in ...view middle of the document...
What is the difference between “formal” and “relational” analogies?
Formal analogies lay simply on the notion that is some elements of the two situations are similar, others must be also. And in contrast; relational analogies rest on a cultural or natural connection between the two contexts as with the direct historical method, where connections based on cultural continuity can be suggested.
What are the five criticisms of the functionalism of processual thinking that Johnson outlines?
Number one is a flaw at the heart of functional explanation. If we explain something by reference to its function in keeping a total system going, this does not explain where it came from historically. Like Royalty for example, who appointed them? Did the common people come together and decide someone needs to take charge? Or did the royals just give them the response they always give “God put us in charge.” Number two processual arguments depend on functional linkages, But there links are always open to doubt in specific terms. There may be alternative strategies available to individuals and cultures that are not considered. For example a classic functional linkages is that made between increasingly marginal environments and agricultural intensification. As an environment becomes more difficult to live in human groups will elaborate and intensify their efforts to cultivate food. Number...