Arche And Apeiron In Early Presocratic Philosophy

956 words - 4 pages

Arche and Apeiron in Early Presocratic Philosophy
Samantha Laster
February 24, 2016
PHI 105
Stephen Jones
Metaphysical speculation began, long before it was so named, among the presocratic Greeks as an enquiry into cosmology and first principles from two utterly disparate perspectives. The first of these, propounded by Herakleitos, noted the incessant flux (panta rhei) which characterises phenomena; the second, advanced by his contemporary Parmenides, taught the doctrine of a single immutable substance. These rivalling perspectives endure to this day: they announce one of the basic themes on which metaphysics since then has strung up an immense set of variations.
Behind both ...view middle of the document...

We may supposed it to have emerged from debate on candidates for the ‘Urstoff’ or primeval substance; and it is perhaps permissible to suppose lively exchanges on the virtues and demerits of sundry elements, culminating in a shock of recognition by Anaximandros that none of these substances, being determinate, qualified and hence failed to satisfy empirical as well as theoretical criteria. The apeiron, initially perhaps merely a device to evade commitment to untenable propositions, proved itself in the long run a truly metaphysical conception with ramifications that have resisted erosion by time. Yet our first duty is to note that it proved indigestible to Greek Philosphy for the aforesaid reasons, to which insistence on form as the fundamental criterion of being must be added. Indeed it is dubious whether the man himself was altogether aware of the problems raised by his conception; and hence the idea of the apeiron — this notion of a formless, homogeneous, all-pervading, incorruptible and morally neutral substance — stood for all Greek philosophy as a signpost at a corner of its domain, pointing to an incognisant reality into which one may not transgress.
This does not, by any means, tarnish the profound genius of the man who proposed it; and it is only fair to mention that modern cosmology is (paradoxically) cut from the same cloth. However, this must be laid to the account of a changed temper of philosophical inquiry.
As to its meaning, we may begin with ‘unlimited’, which cannot be too far off the mark, because peras, its root, means ‘boundary’. But if it were as simple as that, we would not have a metaphysical problem on our hands. When the concept recurs in the work of Anaxagoras, there is a shift towards something more concretely apprehensible, if only by negation:
“By apeira he (Anaxagoras)...

Other Papers Like Arche and Apeiron in Early Presocratic Philosophy

In What Ways Did The Early Nineteenth-Century Reform Movements For Abolition And Women's Rights Illustrate Both The Strengths And The Weaknesses Of Democracy In The Early American Republic?

538 words - 3 pages Stanton began to work together on women's rights and one of the first issues they worked on were property rights for married women. The Married Woman's Property Act had been passed in New York Stat in 1848. However, there were still gross inequities for married women under the law. A married woman could not sell her property or own the wages she had earned. The lack of legal status for married women was an ongoing issue for the early women's rights

Explain the Roles and Responsibilities of the Early Year’s Practitioner in Relation to the Safeguarding, Protection and Welfare of Children. Consider: • Safeguarding Systems - Common Assessment...

1116 words - 5 pages Understand policies and procedures for the safeguarding, protection and welfare of children. Explain the roles and responsibilities of the early year’s practitioner in relation to the safeguarding, protection and welfare of children. Consider: • Safeguarding systems - Common Assessment Framework (CAF), Shared assessment, Team around the child (TAC), • Following procedures for safeguarding children, • Media and online safety. The UK uses

By 1750 the English Colonies on the North American Mainland Had Matured and Changed. What Were the Key Ways in Which the Colonial Societies of This Era (1700-1750) Differed from Those of the Early...

827 words - 4 pages right to vote. The first 13 colonies were formed by religious groups based upon their religions. A part of these religious sects migrated to escape prosecution back in England due their believes. These religious groups like Puritans became fundamentalist and wanted everyone to follow their religious practices in early 17th century. The religious intolerance was wide spread during this time. As immigrants of other religions migrated, the colonial

Force, Right, and Freedom in Jean-Jacques Rousseau’s Philosophy

1265 words - 6 pages In the Social Contract Rousseau discusses the best way to run a state and uses philosophical arguments to argue his case. He also uses the ideas of force, right and freedom to support his argument. He feels we require a civil state, as opposed to living in the state of nature, as ‘it substitutes justice for instinct….and gives his actions a moral quality’ and describes the civil state as having ‘transformed him from


1825 words - 8 pages claim that Greek philosophy, in turn, was influenced by the older wisdom literature and mythological cosmogonies of the ancient Near East. Martin Litchfield West gives qualified assent to this view, stating, "contact with oriental cosmology and theology helped to liberate the early Greek philosophers' imagination; it certainly gave them many suggestive ideas. But they taught themselves to reason. Philosophy as we understand it is a Greek creation

What Is Philosophy According to Socrates?

1074 words - 5 pages good life. Greek philosophy before Socrates is called Pre-Socratic philosophy and the origin of western philosophy can be found early Greek thinkers of the 6th and 7th century BC. The Pre-Socratic philosophers were called physiologoi; physical or natural philosophers and they lived and taught in Asia Minor, Thrace, Sicily and south Italy. The Pre-Socratic philosophy is a philosophy of nature. The Pre-Socratic combined Greek mythology with

Beliefs And Practices

624 words - 3 pages opposites (such as hot and cold) which interact with each other to generate the fullness of creation 3) The greek philosopher Xeophanes (21) – polytheistic ideas that favored one ultimate power. Stated that people made out gods in their own image *sought to use philosophy to explain irrational things in religion – something weird should be taken as symbolically. 4) Aristotle (p21)– Theory of non-contradictions: a thing can be one or another. Not

Xenophanes' Concept Of God

2623 words - 11 pages Xenophanes' Concept of God Xenophanes of the late 6th and early 5th centuries BC should be credited, in opposition to his critics and misinterpreters, with an advanced contribution to the Western philosophy of religion, namely that there is one God. First, he exposes the weaknesses of the Greek pantheon. Then he satirically demonstrates the narcissistic limitations of human conceptions of the nature of the divine. Third, he logically

Materialism 4

3307 words - 14 pages Leibniz (1646–1716). Since then it has been employed to denote any theory that considers all events in the universe to be sufficiently accounted for by the existence and nature of matter. Historians of philosophy often distinguish between different versions of such theories: theoretical materialism, the philosophical doctrine according to which, in contrast to idealism, matter is the only substratum of all existence and all mental or spiritual

Burger King

619 words - 3 pages Burger King SITUATION ANALYSIS Over the past few years, Burger King, the Miami based fast food mega chain, has suffered from a decrease in sales, loss of share value, and a decrease in earnings. Burger King reported earnings of 36 cents per share for the fourth quarter of fiscal 2010, a decrease from 43 cents in the prior year. The company reported that revenue for the quarter was $623 million, which was 1% lower than in the fourth quarter of

Mechanical Philosophy

1587 words - 7 pages Mechanical Philosophy During the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, natural philosophers were starting to reject Aristotelianism and began finding other forms of natural philosophy to study and believe in. One of the popular philosophies in the seventeenth century was mechanical philosophy. “Mechanical Philosophy sought to explain all natural phenomena in the terms of matter and motion without recourse to any kind of action at a distance

Related Essays

Mesopatonmia And Early Society In The New Forming World

1052 words - 5 pages Sumerian elements. Another innovation of Babylonian culture was the invention of astronomy by the scientists were called Chaldaeans. The development started early: we possess a list of systematic observations of Venus written down under king Ammisaduqa. Later, the Babylonians created stellar catalogues and a nearly perfect calendar. In the eighth century, they were able to predict eclipses, which they regarded as evil omens that announced the

Wonder And Anguish In George Grant’s “What Is Philosophy?”

1491 words - 6 pages investigation of the truths and principles of being, knowledge, or conduct (Philosophy, 2012).” The variation in definitions is a result of misguided interpretations and the result of evolving technology. Despite that, Grant states that philosophy is not simply the study of academics nor is it a subject that can be taught as most believe it to be. It is wired in the human mind as an instinctual quest for understanding of the unknown. It “is for

The Relationship Between Sugar And Slavery In The Early Modern Period

4765 words - 20 pages institution of slavery so handsome. The world, history shows us, was these early Europeans oyster. I hope, in this essay, to explain what sugar reveals about a wider world, entailing as it does a lengthy history of colonization, subjugation and slavery.A liking for sweetness became established in European taste preferences at a time when European power, military might and economic initiative were transforming the world. In 1452 sugar production began

The Early Christian Church Played A Significant Role In Unifying Law Making And Legal Procedures

706 words - 3 pages The early Christian church played a significant role in unifying law making and legal procedures. Whilst society remained the same for a short time following the Roman withdrawal from Britain, a more fragmented picture began to develop. By around 425AD separate Christian kingdoms. This led to difficult challenges bringing the country together as a whole, however as written by Baker, J.H (2002) “the unifying force is not a common law but the