This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Application Of The Normative Ethical Theories On Case 1.2

1567 words - 7 pages

Application of the Normative Ethical Theories on Case 1.2

In this paper two chosen moral theories are being applied and analyzed on the provided case where John Smith, M.D., is a psychiatrist with a private practice. He has been extremely successful in helping child-abusing parents with his effective therapies but systematically refuses to report child-abuse cases to the authorities. This confidentiality has resulted into more abusive parents who were afraid of being reported to authorities and has avoided taking their child to the physicians (1). The leading idea here is to analyze the case on the basis of two ethical theories; Rule Utilitarianism and Kantian Ethics. Also to ...view middle of the document...

However there are some moral obligations of every profession to maintain in the society for the benefit of the client and the community he lives in. Such cases where the confidentiality of the client affects the person and the community he lives in should be reported. My belief is that Dr. Smith should report his client’s abusive nature to the authorities and maintain the same information in their file for future counseling. My sincere belief is that by rigorously adhering to the patient confidentially agreement, Dr. Smith is aiding in harming these children. These children who are abused could have grave health issues that are left untreated because of the abuse inflicted by their parents.

Analyze the Case based on both the Ethical Issues
Applying Rule Utilitarianism
The Rule Utilitarian Ethic is a kind of Utilitarianism which emphasis on rules as the core essence according to its name. In this ethic rules play a crucial role over pleasure. Rule Utilitarianism believe that rules brings goodness and thus gives happiness if followed (2). Rule Utilitarianism is motivated by rules, behaviors and moral values that bring human happiness. Rule utilitarianism states that: An act is right when it follows a valid moral rule whose regular observance produces at least as much happiness as other applicable valid moral rules would produce. Rule’s observance increases human happiness over period of time irrespective of its consequences (3). This rules applies in this case because this case specifically mentions the issue of confidentiality. The general rule of the patient doctor agreement is to maintain confidentiality. This rule can be said to maximize benefit because it protects people from being harmed or taken advantage of through the misuse of their information. The psychiatrist’s action of not reporting these abusive patients is correct because it is in agreement with this rule about confidentiality.
Applying Kantian Ethics
Kantian ethics emphasize on one’s moral duty to do right things irrespective of the consequences that evaluates a person’s ethical behavior and his character. These ethics are deontological, and based completely on the moral rules and duties regardless of the consequences or results (5). Kant's first formulation of the Categorical Imperative, the Formula of Universal Law runs: Act only according to that maxim by which you can at the same time will that it should become a universal law (G 421/39). According to Kant’s Universal Law an individual action is considered acceptable if it remains consistent or acceptable when it is universalized. (6). In this case it seems that Dr. Smith believes that by rigorously adhering to his client patient confidentiality, he is able to help precisely those people who are most likely to injure their children. His intentions of protecting both clients and their children appears to be genuine, because he believes in his treatment and he believes that by protecting his clients confidentiality,...

Other Papers Like Application of the Normative Ethical Theories on Case 1.2

The TARES Test Of Ethical Advertising On Fast Food Companies

1394 words - 6 pages advertisers for targeting children, and advertisers blame the problem on parents because they are in control of what their kids eat and do not eat.Ethical Issues Involved in the AdvertisingThe examples of fast food advertisements revolve around the same ethical question: are there certain types of audiences who deserve special protection from advertising messages? In keeping with thousands of years of ethical thinking, U.S. law has answered this

Theories of the Firm Essay

1000 words - 4 pages Theories of the Firm To understand firm heterogeneity within industries and its relations to competitive advantage, reviewing some of the most influential theories of the firm is important. Starting with Coase (1937), academic research in economics and management has nurtured a long tradition of trying to unveil the “essence of the firm.” Some scholars believe that discovering the true nature of the firm permits understanding real- world

Theories of the Family

1326 words - 6 pages Individuals in a Diverse Society February 20, 2013 Theories of the Family Structural Functionalism -Functionalist believe that everything and everybody in society has a role (a function) that makes society to run smoothly -It is a macro theory It focuses on institutions and structures existing in the society as whole Key Terms Function: The different parts of each society contributes positively to the operation or functioning of the

Theories of the Family

812 words - 4 pages Sociological theories are usually thought of as statements of how and why particular facts about the social world are related. The conclusions drawn from empirical observation and testing help individuals and society to be improved in the ways they lead their lives. This essay is going to explain three mostly commonly mentioned sociological theories of the family which are Functionalism, Marxism and Feminism. | Functionalists believe that each

Excellence In Patient Care Depends Upon: The Application Of Sound Ethical Principles, Good Communication And The Understanding, Participation In And Utilisation Of Research Findings

2674 words - 11 pages character of the provider. To provide excellence in patient care depends upon: the application of sound ethical principles, good communication and the understanding of, participation in and utilisation of research findings. These are the main attributes but there are many other factors that go into making a service, which gives the patients the best possible care therefore aiding in a successful treatment and full recovery.Ethical principles are

Application of Various Case Studies to Real-World Organizational Behavior

1814 words - 8 pages Application of various case studies to real-world organizational behavior. Introduction The case: “Rhonda Clark: Taking Charge at Smith Foundation” (McShane & Von Glinow, pg. 319) is a vignette about the hiring of Clark as the CEO of the Smith Foundation. The Board that hired her is somewhat dysfunctional. She faces many challenges in dealing with the board. Clark has to use her influence, abilities, networking and power to maneuver the

Application of Person-centered Therapy to Meng's Case

825 words - 4 pages -solving skills. (a) The Power Animal Technique: Internalizing a Positive Symbol of Strength This technique (by Deborah A. Hickey) requires the client to choose an animal from a large variety that is most appealing to him. The client will then be asked to make a mask with the animal face on it, and finally the therapist will ask the client to imagine what the animal might do in certain situations and how it might solve a specific problem. By

The Sociological Theories of Healthcare

824 words - 4 pages social behavior and human groups (R. Schaefer, 2011, p. 5). It focuses on social relationships, how those relationships influence people’s behavior, and how societies, the sum total of those relationships, develop and change (R. Schaefer, 2011, p. 5). This helps form many theories of the development of the functionalist, conflict, and interactionist views of healthcare. A functionalist perspective is a sociological approach that emphasizes the way in

Explain the Ethical Teachings of Jesus with Special Reference to the Sermon on the Mount

1808 words - 8 pages Explain the ethical teachings of Jesus with special reference to the Sermon on the mount. Jesus of Nazareth was born a Jew. He was raised in the Jewish faith, as both his parents were Jewish, and some theologians would argue that Jesus never taught anything that was against the Jewish faith, and was just another new thinking Rabbi. The understand Jesus’ teachings, however, it is fundamental to have a comprehension of the Jewish way of like, and

Application of Hr in the Global Environment

1503 words - 7 pages Application of HR in the Global Environment Analyze Personnel Needs to Support Globalization Efforts Marie Getty Cornet Northcentral University Abstract In these days of age Globalization plays a major role in businesses. More and more companies are conducting businesses overseas because of many factors such as competition between companies, low cost, demand, faster services and they also represent the main factors that had contributed

College Application to the University of Michigan

539 words - 3 pages From the time I was able to realize what a university was, all I heard from my mother's side of the family was about the University of Michigan and the great heritage it has. Many a Saturday afternoon my grandfather would devote to me, by sitting me down in front of the television and reminiscing about the University of Michigan while halftime occurred during a Michigan Wolverines football game. Later, as I grew older and universities took on

Related Essays

Application Of Theories Essay

770 words - 4 pages Christina Bowman American Intercontinental University Unit 4 Individual Project BUSN300 – Lower Division Capstone July 1, 2012 Abstract This paper will talk about two theories that companies uses, the first one is employee empowerment culture, also known as the motivation theory. The second one is the theory of penetration pricing.   Application of Theories Introduction The paper will define the use of two theories that

Ethical Application Of Biometrics Essay

921 words - 4 pages The Proper and Ethical Application of Biometrics IFSM 201 – A Practical Introduction to Computers and Communications As the advancement of technology continues to flourish within the modern age, so too have the capabilities and ruthlessness of predators looking to exploit the weaknesses of some for their own personal gains. In order to safeguard and protect the privacies of technological users, technology has also adapted its growth to

Examination Of Ethical Theories Essay

861 words - 4 pages Examination of Ethical Theories ETH/316 August 5, 2013 Examination of Ethical Theories There are seven general ethical categories used in defining the ethical values and morals people follow. Each category has different subsections and expectations for a person’s behavior. A person’s morals and ethical beliefs develop from a mixture of values from these various theories; therefore he or she does not necessarily fit snugly into one

The Ethical Analysis On The Issues Of Whistle Blowing

1831 words - 8 pages not about preaching virtue rather, its objective is to increase your ability as engineers to responsibly confront moral issues raised by technological activity. THE SCOPE OF ENGINEERING ETHICS Moral Reasoning & Ethical Theories Engineering as Social Experimentation The Engineers Responsibility for safety Scope of Engineering Ethics Responsibility to Employees Engineers and Managers, Consultants and headers Global Issues