This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Appellate Brief Legal Essay

4026 words - 17 pages


No. 11-0369



MAGGIE LIZER, Individually and in her Official Capacity as Assistant United States
Attorney, Southern District of New York,



Counsel for Appellant
2072 5th Ave. Suite 43
New York, NY 10292


TABLE OF CONTENTS ……………………………………………………………….....i
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES ……………………………………………………………..ii
QUESTION PRESENTED ……………………………………………………………….1
STATEMENT ...view middle of the document...

9, 10
Pappas v. Giuliani, 290 F.3d 143 (2nd Cir. 2002) …………………………………….9, 12


1. Under the First Amendment, is a blog created by a government employee, which contains matters of public concern and does not cause a disruption to the workplace, entitled to constitutional protection?


This Court is being asked to reverse a United States District Court for the Southern District of New York decision that Appellant’s blog was not entitled to constitutional protection under the First Amendment. At issue here is: (1) whether or not the Appellant’s blog addressed matters of public concern and (2) whether the blog could outweigh concerns of the Appellant’s employer about its impact on the office’s operations and functions.
Bob Loblaw, a certified paralegal, was employed with the United States Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of New York for over three years. R. 3. This office is the largest and most active in the nation. R. 8. The main office consists of approximately 610 employees, of which 210 are Assistant U.S. Attorneys with the remaining consisting of administration, paralegals, security, translators, both civil and criminal investigators and case managers. Id. Loblaw’s colleagues considered him to be a reliable and valuable employee. R. 9. His employments evaluations were always excellent. Id. Attorneys in the office often specifically requested that Loblaw complete complex projects including drafting motions and briefs. R. 4, 9.
In December 2009, Loblaw created a blog titled “Judging for the Banana Stand.” R. 4. Loblaw testified that a blog is a website that provides a forum for an exchange of ideas where people post things and other people comment on items that other people post or they just post their own stuff. Id.
Loblaw invited friends and acquaintances to participate on the blog who could, upon receipt of the invitation, choose whether to participate by setting up a username and profile. R. 5, 6. The blog was viewable by anyone who found it on the Internet, but the only people who could post on the blog were those who Loblaw invited. R. 5. As “master-blogger,” Loblaw edited some of the proposed postings and refused to publish others. Id. Among those who participated in Loblaw’s blog included a former Assistant U.S. Attorney and a clerk for one of the judges in the Southern District of New York. R. 6.
While blogging, Loblaw used the name BluthLaw. Id. It is common practice to assume a name and identity for purposes of blogging. Id. In fact, every participant on Mr. Loblaw’s blog created a username to protected their identity so that they could feel free to express their views. Id. BluthLaw was supposed to be a twenty-six year old woman who attended a prestigious law school and clerked for a U.S. Circuit Court Judge. Id. Under...

Other Papers Like Appellate Brief - Legal

Business Research Essay

932 words - 4 pages LEGAL RESEARCH – is the process of finding the laws, rules and regulations that govern activities in human society. It involves both the law and rules which are enforced by the State and the commentaries which explain or analyze these rules. It is also defined as the investigation for information necessary to support legal decision making. It includes each step of a process that begins with analyzing the facts of a problem and concludes with

Appeals Process Essay

1314 words - 6 pages necessary because it shapes laws on legal issues. “An appeal is a request to a higher (appellate) court for that court to review and change the decision of a lower court” (NOLO, 2015, p.1). Both the prosecution and the defense can always appeal a court’s decision on various motions including those that wish to exclude evidence in certain situations. The defendant can also appeal the court if there are legal grounds to do so. An appeal

Aviation Law Module One

1903 words - 8 pages Manual. Title 49 of the CFR. Where can a researcher find federal aviation statutes? Code of Federal Regulations, title 14. What are the steps in a civil trial? Pretrial, the trial, Pleadings and Jury deliberation, and the appellate process. What are the steps in a criminal prosecution? Arrest, initial appearance, Preliminary hearing, arraignment. What are the steps in an appeal? Notice of appeal, appellate brief, oral arguments

Search of Status

1279 words - 6 pages . • Demonstrate, through role playing and/or cases, ethical problem-solving in course content specific situations. The overall purpose of this course is to provide students with a basic understanding of the areas of law that primarily impact business transactions and organizations. Specifically, the course is designed to enable students to: • Demonstrate an understanding of the operations of the U.S. legal system

Legal System

3911 words - 16 pages ‘Operation of the Legal System’ (Chapter Two), to simply outline the jurisdictions of the Local, District and Supreme Courts as well as the appellate jurisdiction. It clearly summarised this information in a table. However, the validity of this information had to be checked, for example the civil jurisdiction of the Local Court has changed from $40 000 to $60 000. ▪ Brassil B, Brassil D 2000, Excel Preliminary Legal Studies, Pascal Press

Book Review - Business Law Battle Plan

2193 words - 9 pages PART I Business Law Battle Plan by Marjorie Jobe, J.D. provides strategies and steps necessary to protect entrepreneurs from the risk of litigation which has become commonplace in the United States legal system . The author claims that today’s American legal system is broken, abused by bad lawyers and corrupt prosecutors whereby no business owners are safe no matter how insignificant the business is or even if it is innocent. The author

Judicial Reforms in India

4227 words - 17 pages legal services to the weaker sections of the society on the basis of equal opportunity. 4) NATIONAL TAX TRIBUNAL Having realized the need for uniformity, certainty in the administration of taxation laws and on the recommendation of the Chokshi Committee the National Tax Tribunal Act, 2005 was enacted on 21st December, 2005 for lying/hearing appeals, instead of High Courts, against the orders passed by the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal and the Central

Roman Law

2755 words - 12 pages -law countries, like the United States, enact statutes and even comprehensive codes, such as the Uniform Commercial Code, while civil-law countries have laws that have been developed by the courts and not enacted through legislation. Roman law itself contained these conflicting impulses of codification and judicial interpretation.”1 3. Summary This article deals with a brief history of Roman law and it’s incidence on present legal systems

Advance Ruling

1841 words - 8 pages [such] non-resident, And such determination shall include the determination of any question of law or of fact specified in the application; (iii) A determination or decision by the Authority in respect of an issue relating to computation of total income which is pending before any income-tax authority or the Appellate Tribunal and such determination or decision shall include the determination or decision of any question of

Law 531 Final Exam Correct Answers

2447 words - 10 pages royalty for the use of the invention by the infringer. Want to see the complete Individual Assignment Check..?? Click LAW 531 Week 6 IRAC Brief 25. A contract in which one or more parties have the legal right to cancel their obligations under the contract is called a(n): a) valid contract b) void contract c) unenforceable contract d) voidable contract 26. An essential element of a tort is that the alleged defamatory statement must be

Law 531 Final Exam Correct Answers

2447 words - 10 pages royalty for the use of the invention by the infringer. Want to see the complete Individual Assignment Check..?? Click LAW 531 Week 6 IRAC Brief 25. A contract in which one or more parties have the legal right to cancel their obligations under the contract is called a(n): a) valid contract b) void contract c) unenforceable contract d) voidable contract 26. An essential element of a tort is that the alleged defamatory statement must be

Related Essays


1982 words - 8 pages . • Drafted motion for reconsideration of visitation order and appellate brief. Office of the State Appellate Defender, Chicago, IL Intern, Summer 2010 • Performed legal research and wrote appellate brief seeking sentence reduction. Law Related Education, Chicago, IL Volunteer, Fall 2007 • Taught class on the legal system to youth in the Cook County Juvenile Temporary Detention Center. YMCA, Northbrook, IL Day Camp Counselor

Political Science 6311 Essay

828 words - 4 pages Landmark case of (Leeper v Arlington class action suit. The Court ruled that Home schooling in Texas was legal and Texas Supreme Court Confirmed the Appellate ruling. Justices of Texas 1836-1986: University of Texas School of Law: Tarlton Law Library, Center for legal Research. I had the pleasure of meeting him personally with my three attorneys in his chambers in Austin. It was concerning a case I had filed against me back in the early 1970’s

How To Brief A Case Essay

943 words - 4 pages HOW TO BRIEF A CASE I. Distinctions A. B. II. A case brief is a dissection of a judicial opinion -- it contains a written summary of the basic components of that decision. Persuasive briefs (trial and appellate) are the formal documents a lawyer files with a court in support of his or her client’s position. Functions of case briefing A. Case briefing helps you acquire the skills of case analysis and legal reasoning

Juvenile Justice System Essay

1230 words - 5 pages justice systems across the country (Center for Children's Law and Policy, 2011). The process of filing an appeal in juvenile court is governed by each states individual law, but the general process is similar in each state. The first task is to identify the appropriate appellate court. The second step is to notify the court of the intention to file an appeal and writing an appellate brief explaining the reasons for appealing the initial