This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Antitrust Law Essay

5520 words - 23 pages

Antitrust law is the law of competition, and it is perhaps the least understood law of all. This article provides an overview and explanation of the essential principals of antitrust law, along with comments on certain recurring themes and recent developments in the voluminous case law by which the courts have struggled to give meaning and practical effect to the principal antitrust statutes.
What Is Antitrust Law? Broadly speaking, antitrust laws seek to promote fair competition on the merits and to protect consumers and wronged competitor businesses from anti-competitive business practices — practices undertaken in effort to undermine competitive commercial behavior in a given market or ...view middle of the document...

Allow me the following example to illustrate the point more vividly. If I own a restaurant in San Diego, and if I maliciously set fire to two other restaurants because I resent their flourishing success, I have clearly broken the law: I can be prosecuted criminally for arson and sued by the wronged, destroyed restaurants for intentional malfeasance, tortious interference, and very likely other civil wrongs. But my act, however evil, causes no harm to the thriving restaurant scene in San Diego. I have done nothing that even remotely upsets “competition on the merits” for restaurant dining in San Diego.
But suppose that my restaurant and the two other restaurants are all located on a remote island in the far away Pacific. If I burn them to the ground, then my restaurant alone will be the one restaurant remaining for the residents of this otherwise idyllic island. Suppose that I start charging them $50 for a plate of eggs and potatoes, quipping that “if they don’t like my service, they can eat at some other restaurant — oh, I forgot, there are no other restaurants!” My act of arson, if done under such circumstances, has likely caused harm to competition on the merits for restaurant services on this island.
Let’s suppose further that this remote Pacific Island is a territory of the United States and is therefore subject to U.S. antitrust law. When I am sued for redress under these laws, my clever antitrust attorneys will argue that, whatever else I might have done, I have not harmed competition on the merits because if I try to raise my prices for my restaurant services, others will soon establish competing restaurants to sell to customers who are disenchanted with my prices. This is the stuff of antitrust law, not mere arson and malicious misconduct. In this case, I would likely lose and be forced to pay three times the value of the harm that my misconduct has caused to competitors and customers alike, assuming the customers started a class action and my two ruined competitors also brought their own suit for lost profits. This is because a successful plaintiff in an antitrust case is entitled to treble damages and attorney’s fees and often can also obtain injunctive relief.
Suppose that I set the fire in San Diego, but I have done so because my restaurant and the two others are the only ones in the area that serve a rare delicacy cuisine known to its aficionados as “Fuji-style cooking”. In such a case my erstwhile competitors might sue me under the antitrust laws for causing antirust harm in the market for “Fuji-style cooking in the San Diego region”.
In other words, antitrust law is the law of competition, and it exists to resist harm done to an entire market, not harm done merely to a particular business or consumer.
The antitrust laws are set forth in various federal statutes, most notably the Sherman Act and the Clayton Act. There are also copycat statutes in virtually every state.  The federal statutes use conspicuously general language...

Other Papers Like Antitrust Law

Antitrust Laws Are Ineffective Essay

3930 words - 16 pages behind the laws is that trusts and monopolies will stagnate markets and prevent others from engaging in healthy market competition. A monopoly is defined as a situation in which a single company owns all or nearly all of the market for a given type of product or service. (Investorwords, 2010) Antitrust law legislation started with the Sherman Act that was passed in 1890. The intent of the law was put in place to challenge the unchecked growth of

Anti Trust Laws Essay

736 words - 3 pages new and current business to enter into the market place; there would be no fear that they would be pushed out of the market either by price-fixing or collusion. These antitrust laws allowed the normal flow of business to continue. By normal flow of business I mean the law of diminishing returns as well the economies and diseconomies of scale. That is not to say that the antitrust laws were without fail. There were many issues and impacts that

Egt1 Task 3

577 words - 3 pages A. There are four key sections of the federal legislation; known as the Antitrust laws that corresponds to the monopoly structure and conduct within the basic law. These laws are: the Federal Trade Commission Act, 1914, Clayton Act, 1914, Sherman Act, 1890, and the Celler-Kefauver Act, 1950. The Sherman Act is, “The Federal antitrust law of 1890 that makes a monopoly planned to restrain trade criminal offenses” (McConnell G-26). The Clayton Act

Micro Study

1068 words - 5 pages 1. What are barriers to entry, and how do they limit potentially new competition from entering the market? 2. The purpose of Antitrust Laws are to: The antitrust law is not intended to protect any particular company but to protect access to and competition in the market so that consumers have access to best prices and products. Some companies will fail and that's okay! 1) Preserve a free market 2) Promote competition 3) Prohibit unfair

Antitrust Practices And Market Power

565 words - 3 pages Dentsply International and Market Power Ashley Davis DeVry University Dentsply International and Market Power The Congress passed antitrust laws in effort to protect competition in the market, as well as consumers whom are the ultimate recipients in the market (Novak, 2007). The case that will be discussed in this paper will be a company that was found guilty of violating section 2 of the Sherman Act, which focuses on people that are

White Collar Crimes and Price Fixing

1640 words - 7 pages Antitrust Act 2."US CODE: Title 15, 1. Trusts, etc., in restraint of trade illegal; penalty". Law.cornell.edu. Retrieved 2012-10-25. 3. Sutherland, Edwin Hardin (1949). White Collar Crime. New York: Dryden Press. 4. U.S. Department of Justice, Federal Bureau of Investigation (2012). National Incident-Based Reporting System: Data Collection Guidelines. Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office. 5. www.fbi.gov/.../westland-woman-sentenced-to-prison-in-embezzlement- scheme 6. Singer and Lafond, Criminal Law, 4th ed. (Aspen 2007) 7. R. Posner, Anti-Trust Law (1976); R. Bork, The Antitrust Paradox (1978).

Business Ethics

1117 words - 5 pages ingredients at a higher cost simply because they do not have enough volume. In this case the Federal Trade Commission has stepped in to protect the smaller pharmaceutical companies insisting this could be a violation of antitrust law (FTC, 2011). Reporting that the large company obtained an exclusive contract or license for a singular ingredient. In the case the FTC argued that this raised the costs of the drug ingredients which of course

Ge Antitrust

2831 words - 12 pages see that one regulator agreed to this merger and another wasn’t fine with it. Normally both of regulator and in this case there was a discrepancy between EU and US potion on antitrust regulation. To explain why they hadn’t the same position on this case can be explain by diverse reason. * A different economic philosophy: The origins of antitrust law are in many ways connected to an economic philosophy favoring competition but this is not

Leg 100 Assignment

1446 words - 6 pages shall be required to be considered by organization in current situation. Regarding sales laws, the laws regarding fair trade practices will be applicable on organization in current situation. (Harlow & Ostas, 2011). Recommendations for Minimization of Law Suits The laws which are required to be considered by Citizens National Bank include antitrust laws, laws related to banks and working of the customers and laws made by Federal Reserve and

Microsoft vs Netscape

5066 words - 21 pages al. v. Microsoft Corporation, No. 98-1233. On November 5, 1999 and April 3, 2000, after more than a year of proceedings, the Federal District Court issued Findings of Fact (84 F. Supp. 2d 9) and Conclusions of Law (87 F. Supp. 2d 30) determining that Microsoft’s anticompetitive campaign against Netscape violated sections 1 and 2 of the Sherman Act, along with several state antitrust statutes, including D.C. Code §§28-4502, 4503. The Federal

Why Price Fixing Should Remain Unlawful

1148 words - 5 pages In today’s economy it is generally said that supply and demand determine prices on goods and services. In order for this to be true the free market cannot be interfered with. The New York Times article, “Taiwan Company Fined $500 Million for Price-Fixing,” highlights some of the issues that can arise when it comes to price fixing. In this essay I will explain what the antitrust law says regarding price-fixing agreements, and what impact these

Related Essays

Discussion 3 Essay

575 words - 3 pages From the scenario, differentiate between the concepts of criminal law, antitrust, and health care as they apply to U.S. health law in the 21st Century. Conceptualize the primary ways in which these laws apply to U.S. health care administrators. In order to properly analyze between the concepts of criminal law, antitrust law, and the health care law I had to fully understand them individually. Worldwide, the criminal law is what protects and

Case Study

814 words - 4 pages its products or services (U.S. Department of Justice, 2013). Consumers benefit from the lower prices and better products or services so that they can receive the best care possible. There are three major antitrust laws: The Sherman Antitrust Act, The Clayton Act, and The Federal Trade Commission Act. The Sherman Antitrust Act began in 1890 as the principal law that expressed the national commitment to a free market economy in which competition

Antitrust Laws For Fair And Competitive Business

708 words - 3 pages (particularly The Sherman Act) provide general guidelines for business practices, but not all of them define specific rules that a business must follow. There are too many situations that may arise for each one to be addressed. Therefore, when a business is accused of breaking an antitrust law, the outcome must be determined by the courts, leaving the results open to subjective interpretation given the circumstances. Because these laws are general

Anittrust Laws Essay

1743 words - 7 pages quality products or services is done through aggressive competition. To maintain this dynamic economy the United States Congress established and passed the first antitrust law. This law was named the Sherman Act of 1890. Two other antitrust laws have been passed since. In 1914 the Federal Trade Commission Act was created by the Federal Trade Commission and the Clayton Act. These laws are still in effect. The antitrust laws were created to