Animal Ethics Essay

1749 words - 7 pages

Animal Ethics
1480
(Title)
The use of animal research studies has posed an ethical dilemma for the medical community. As the movement of for animal rights entered mainstream awareness, increased scrutiny was placed on medical research studies involving live animals. The debate has sparked strong arguments from both supporters and abolitionists. Peter Singer, often credited as the pioneer of animal rights, delivers a profound document in favor of equality of animals. Carl Cohen provided a retort during the necessity of animal research for scientific advancement. However, with all of the technological advances of the 21st century, one must question if an antiquated method has overstayed ...view middle of the document...

Each individual possesses varying degrees of intelligence and moral understanding, thus the criteria for justifying the basic principle of equality must lie elsewhere. Singer embraces the utilitarian notion that “the interests of every being affected by an action are to be taken into account and given the same weight as the like interests of any other being”. (CITE) Thus, if animals are affected by human decisions, their interests deserve consideration.
Singer reinforces this view by emphasizing the reasons why equality cannot be based on personal attributes such as what a person is like, their skin color, or sex. For if equality is to be based on arbitrary characteristics, then sexism and racism would be a valid means of determining equality or rather inequality. Thus, if a difference in the intellectual abilities of humans does not allow one to exploit the other, then this justification cannot be used when it comes to nonhuman beings. To base this distinction solely on the fact that some beings are human and other nonhuman is to embrace speciesism, a clear preferences for one’s own species to the detriment of others (CITE).
However, Singer is not without his critics. Carl Cohen argues against Singer touting the morality behind the preservation of human life. Cohen tackles the two main reasons touted by those seeking to abolish animal research. He first addresses the notion that animal research is an infringement on the rights of animals. Cohen replies to those concerned with animal rights by explaining what attributes are necessary for one to possess rights. According to Cohen, “rights arise, and can be intelligibly defended, only among beings who actually do, or can, make moral claims against one another”(CITE). Consequently, there are certain human attributes, such as free will, human reasoning, and the intuitive knowledge of what is right, that makes human beings the only possessors of rights. Cohen argues that as animals lack any sense of moral judgment and are unable to make moral claims, they do not have the intrinsic rights bestowed upon human beings. Cohen goes on to say that simply because animals are alive does not mean that they have a right to life.
Fault has been found with Cohen’s argument with respect to the rights of babies, young children, and the mentally disabled. If it is a lack of moral understanding that disallows animal’s rights, do these groups of humans have rights? Cohen defends his position by stating that, as a part of the human community, the notion of rights is extended to these individuals; simply because they are not fully developed, does not mean that they are no longer a part of the human community (CITE). As such, the rights of the community are extended to all of its members. Cohen embraces the concept of speciesism. He believes the suffering of humans outweighs the suffering of other nonhuman species. He asserts that human beings have a moral obligation to limit the suffering of...

Other Papers Like Animal Ethics

Ethics in Psychological Essay

1100 words - 5 pages in research, the use of animals in studies of research, and human care. My paper will focus on the use of animals as an issue of classical ethics in a psychological research. It will explain the benefit ratio as well as the concept of risk in using animal for experiments and determine what influence does the use of animal in research has on a psychological research. The sue of animals has given knowledge that can usually be used in

Animal Testing Essay

1510 words - 7 pages Humans have used animals for different uses. They have been used for food, clothing farm work and a variety of other uses. So using them to test new medical advances is different. Animal testing for medical purpose help saves lives and future generations. Animal testing should be continued for the use within the medical field. The ancient Greeks believed that animals were created by the gods to be used however people wish. The Bible says

Military Detainees And Physician Ethics

421 words - 2 pages Military Detainees and Physician Ethics Submitted by Wendy Andersen Prepared for Denise Haynes ME1420 Medical Law and Ethics UMA November 11, 2013 CERTIFICATE OF AUTHORSHIP: I certify that I am the author.  I have cited all sources from which I used data, ideas, or words, either quoted directly or paraphrased.  I also certify that this paper was prepared by me specifically for this course. ME1420 Medical Law and Ethics

Animal Experiments

877 words - 4 pages . However, if there is another method of conducting the testing that is equally or more effective, then that should replace using an animal. Bibliography http://www.bbc.co.uk/ethics/animals/using/experiments_1.shtml http://www.livescience.com/ http://levmm1.wordpress.com/2011/03/23/organizations-against-animal-testing/ http://www.peta.org/

Animal Testing: Pros and Cons

3605 words - 15 pages , questions have been raised about the ethics surround animal testing. As a result several regulations have been put in place to evaluate and control the animals being used for testing purposes. These regulations hope to ensure that such research is carried out in a humanely and ethical manner. (Testing on Animals: A Patient’s Perspective) Acceptance of such experimentations is subject to a lot of argumentation. As the statistics indicate animal

Animal Testing

1214 words - 5 pages effect. And it is weak. It has no grounds on which it can continuo except the fact that people don’t know and turn a blind eye. Works Cited Andre, Claire and Manuel Velasquez. “Of Cures and Creatures Great and Small.” Santa Clara University The Jesuit University of Silicon Valley. Santa Clara University The Jesuit University of Silicon Valley, Web. 30/1/14. . “Killing Animal and

The Merit of the Lion King

994 words - 4 pages his quarry from becoming aware of his presence, it is hard for an animal to experience duress when they aren’t even aware of a predators presence in the first place (Hunter Ethics and Safety). Pain is an unfortunate aspect of hunting , however before I go any further I would like to ask the reader this, what do you think is the eventual fate of every animal? The answer is usually eaten-alive by a non-human predator, death by starvation, disease

Research Proposal

802 words - 4 pages Yvonne Prutilpac English 102-056 Charity Ginerich Research Proposal The topic that I would like to research for the final research paper is the issue of ethics in regards to registering a pet to be a service animal. I am arguing that it is morally acceptable to get your pet registered as a service animal even when there are no known disabilities of the owner. I have some experience with this topic because I have a dog that I recently got

Ethics For Anthropologists And Social Scientists

535 words - 3 pages Ethics, in Anthropological research, outline what is right and what is wrong in the motives and actual behavior of the anthropologists (Looking at us, 2010 p.46). The well-being of all participants, human or animal, should be the anthropologists top priority. The anthropologist should work toward conservation of all knowledge gained by their research, and their research should be a benefit to all involved. All participants should have a

The Right Choice for Animal Experiments

2318 words - 10 pages The animals use in medical experimentation has had been one of the most divisive issues since the seventeenth century. Edward Augustus Freeman, one of the most distinguished of recent English historians stated, “The awful wrongs and sufferings forced upon the innocent, faithful animal race form the blackest chapter in the whole world’s history” (Freeman). In the United States, it is estimated that twenty to seventy million animals suffer and

Animal Testing: a Reasonable Stance

3020 words - 13 pages also in reasoning. The side for animal testing is reasoning on the means of science and research used to develop new medical treatment, while the side against animal testing is reasoning on the means of ethics and rights for animals. Taking into examination of the “pro” side of animal testing pertaining to medical progression as well as the “con” side of animal testing concerning the welfare of the animals, I have formulated what I recognize to be

Related Essays

Ethical Analysis Of News Issue

2350 words - 10 pages Ethical Analysis of News Issue: Animal Rights Clearly define the ethical issue and provide a brief explanation as to why it is important. (4 marks) To many people, the concept of animal rights is absurd and long drawn. However, animal activism has increased in the recent past with formation of such organizations as PETA (People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals) that seek to incorporate ethics when addressing issues related to

Animal Rights Essay

2484 words - 10 pages eliminate it completely. Even with the technology we have today many scientists still believe that animal experimentation is necessary in order to achieve breakthroughs. There have been numerous developments in the scientific community using animals, but then again, studies have proven some serious flaws. When the ethics of vivisection (animal experimentation) are challenged, the question arises, "Which is more important: your child's life, or a rats

Bioethics: Modern Science And Ethics Essay

2352 words - 10 pages to define “ethics” is that “moral principles that govern a person's or group's behavior” (American English in Oxford Dictionary). Bioethics is a pretty young interdisciplinary study, which is considered with ethical questions related to the relationships among human beings, animals, and environments in the late twentieth century. Based on this, bioethics derived three main subdisciplines, which are medical ethics, animal ethics, and

The Relationship Between Religious Values And Ethical Values

1194 words - 5 pages task of examining the moral standards that regulate right and wrong conduct; and "applied ethics" examines controversies such as abortion, infanticide, animal abuse, environmental concerns, homosexuality and capital punishment. To behave ethically is to behave in a manner consistent with what is right or moral. Ethics is simply the principles used by people that control their conduct. Religion is a system of thoughts, feelings, and approach that