This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Animal Abuse Essay

3804 words - 16 pages

Animal Rights
Introduction

Ethics and morality have consistently been topics of concern in our society. Concerns about ethics and morality also extend to matters associated with the treatment of animals. The purpose of this discussion is to summarize and critique several different theories associated with the ethical treatment of animals. The discussion will focus on the treatment of animals as it relates to hunting and trapping animals, eating animals, using animals for research, and the manner in which domestic and wild animals are treated. The research will summarize and critique several theories including anthropocentrism, Animal liberation, Strong Animal Rights Theory, ...view middle of the document...

This theory also argues that if animals are treated kindly it is not for the benefit of the animal but the human being. The problem with this theory is that it does not suppose that logical human beings would have an obligation to treat animals kindly. This would be the case because logical human beings understand that animals are helpless and therefore need protection. This theory is also problematic because it does not thoroughly or succinctly explain the consequences to human being when other living things are not treated with some sort of respect or reverence. It does not consider the impact that the ill treatment of animals would ultimately have on the environment.
Animal Liberation
The theory of Animal liberation posits that non-human animals should be given the same consideration as humans as it relates to their right to live and be free of torment. Peter Singer is one of the major supporters of this theory. Singer asserted that suffering was suffering regardless of whom or what the recipient of the suffering was. Singer also asserted that
“The principle of equality (or equal consideration of interests) is the crux of Singer's argument. It holds that all sentient creatures (he draws the "line" at the phylogenetic level of oysters) have the same stake in their own existence ("interests"). Singer argued that this principle leads to the conclusion that there is no basis for elevating the interests of one species, Homo sapiens, above any other. Differences in intelligence, race, and gender are not valid criteria to exploit other humans; to Singer, a creature's species is equally irrelevant. He claimed that "From an ethical point of view, we all stand on an equal footing -- whether we stand on two feet, or four, or none at all" ( Singer, 1985 , p.6; Herzog, 1990)

With these things being understood equal weight must be given to the suffering of any living thing (Callicot). According to Callicot those that practice this theory are usually vegetarians and are usually extremely adamant concerning their position.
Animal liberation is problematic because it makes no distinction between the needs of most non-human animals and human beings. However the primary theorist responsible for cultivating this philosophy does concede that the phylogenetic level of oysters are not to be considered. This view is logical at some external level, but when one truly evaluates this theory it becomes too broad and does not seem to recognize the importance of deferring to human logic as it relates to the ethical treatment of living beings. It also seems to ignore the fact that non-human animals do not have the logic to consider how human beings are being treated. As such if humans allow them to wild animals could perceive human beings as weak and began treating human beings as nothing more than prey.
Biocentric Egalitarianism
Biocentric Egalitarianism also known as reverence for life, asserts that all living things are sacred and of...

Other Papers Like Animal Abuse

Harsher Punishment for Perpatrators in Animal Cruelty Crimes

3267 words - 14 pages 01 December 2010 Harsher punishments for perpetrators in animal cruelty crimes Why can a perpetrator abuse and torture animals and get no punishment for it? At the most these perpetrators get fine or probation. Even worse they are a loud to have animals in their possession after a few years. To know that someone can beat to death or mutilate a poor defenseless animal and get away with it sickens me. It

Animal Rights Essay

2484 words - 10 pages , unprotected animals. Animal research it is cruel and inhumane, but it is also sometimes inaccurate. The second reason why animal research should not be allowed is because it is not always accurate. According to Bernard Rollen in his book, "Animal Abuse and Human Morality", scientists in the 1960’s concluded from many animal experiments that the inhaled tobacco smoke did not cause lung cancer. We all know that this is totally not true, and that smoking is

Animal Cruelty

1528 words - 7 pages BACK GROUND OF THE STUDY There are many different reasons why individuals abuse animals. Animal cruelty covers a wide range of actions (or lack of action), so one blanket answer simply isn't possible. Each type of abuse has displayed certain patterns of behavior that we can use to help understand more about why people commit the crimes we encounter today. Animal cruelty is often broken down into two main categories: active and passive, also

Justice for Mary

567 words - 3 pages Dawn Willock CRIM 101 Justice for Mary/Current Event Paper Ivy Tech Community College Willie Whitfield November 5, 2012 Sean Janas, a twenty year old woman from Wausau, Wisconsin, was charged with felony mistreatment of animals, giving poison to the animal, a misdemeanor and obstruction. The Associated Press reported that “Janas kept a diary with entries describing her intense hatred for Mary…the diary also detailed the abuse Janas

Animal Experiments

877 words - 4 pages based in the US that supplies drug development services and animal testing facilities. PETA is a non-profit organisation, and the largest animal rights organisation in the world, with over 3 million members and supporters. They campaign against animal research, with the slogan "Animals are not ours to eat, wear, experiment on, use for entertainment, or abuse in any other way."This slogan is ethically correct; animals are living, thinking creatures

Animal Rights or Wrongs

864 words - 4 pages Welfare is the lesser of the two. It follows the simple belief that animals should be cared for but can be used for research, food, recreational use, as long as they treated humanly. They also feel people should be punished for any abusive behaviors towards the animal, but usually results in a fine and the animal taken from them. Abuse can touch all animals, not just cats and dogs, but elephants, manatees and others. PETA is the most well

The Debate Of Animal Testing In Laboratories

2431 words - 10 pages dates back to the beginning of time, it was not until the 1970s and 1980s that more extreme animal rights organizations evolved. One of the most active and influential of these today is PETA, which stands for People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals. Founded in 1980, PETA, like many other groups, educates the public about animal abuse and believes in the right of all animals to be treated with respect. PETA has taken defense for the ALF

The Right Choice for Animal Experiments

2318 words - 10 pages The animals use in medical experimentation has had been one of the most divisive issues since the seventeenth century. Edward Augustus Freeman, one of the most distinguished of recent English historians stated, “The awful wrongs and sufferings forced upon the innocent, faithful animal race form the blackest chapter in the whole world’s history” (Freeman). In the United States, it is estimated that twenty to seventy million animals suffer and

Why Animal Testing Should Be Prohibited

1194 words - 5 pages Why Animal Testing should be Prohibited Alexandria McConnell 6/4/2015 ENG/130 Maureen Chisholm It is estimated that about 26 million animals are being used every year in the US for scientific and commercial research. They are used for many different things such as medical developments, the safety of products, and many other health care and cosmetic uses. While there are some laws in place that prevent the abuse of animals in these

Should Animal Experimentation Be Banned?

697 words - 3 pages been discovered in the human because of mouse-human genome comparisons”(Russell, 2002) shows that to continue studies, animals, like mice, will still be mainstays in laboratory. Opponents of animal experimentation insist on stopping it. They say that animal abuse is cruel because they also suffer when poisoned or infected with diseases (Perry, 1990). Unfair as it may sound; but cure should be found soon; otherwise, it will obviously take

Fable Essay Animal Farm

634 words - 3 pages it is the best course of action for those they rule. Animal Farm was written for almost sixty years now and it still impacts the way people think mentally. Animal Farm warns of blind faith, the abuse of power, and propaganda. The story mostly tells readers how a revolution of farm animals emerged against a cruel master. They were all revolting against the unethical, greediness and a power hungry master. There is something we refer to toxic

Related Essays

Animal Abuse Essay

1511 words - 7 pages Joana Socarras ENC1101 Professor Gray November 20, 2013 Do we really love animals? The truth behind animal research and testing Animal research and testing has been a huge controversial topic in the U.S. For many years, lots of organizations like PETA have created movements to eliminate this completely but without very much success. Personally, I can’t find any positives to animal research and testing but the majority of the U.S

Animal Cruelty And Abuse Essay

1026 words - 5 pages it yourself. It no longer has any use for you anymore. The relationship is worthless. About sixty four percent of U.S. households have pets. Every year there are over sixty thousand greyhounds that are needlessly killed every year. Sixteen percent of animal cruelty involve cats every year. Im going to further educate you of different types of animal abuse and why people abuse their pets. There are two different types of animal abuse, active

Animals Deserve Rights Not Abuse Essay

1779 words - 8 pages Animals Deserve Rights Not Abuse Animals have been seen as a lower species for decades. They have little to no rights and are sometimes treated inhumanely. No rights are given to them, so when they are abused there is little to no consequences. Hit an animal, make them live in dirty environments, forgot to feed them, leave them in the hot temperatures with no water, or torture them and the consequences are minor compared to the

Ethical Treatment Of Animals Essay

1053 words - 5 pages moments of life. III. Body paragraph #2 - Topic Sentence #2 Although the definition varies by state, generally, Animal cruelty occurs when someone intentionally injures or harms an animal or when a person willfully deprives an animal of food, water or necessary medical care. A. Supporting Evidence All U.S. states have animal cruelty laws, and 47 states treat some forms of abuse as felonies. The most common type of animal cruelty is neglect