This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Analysing Thematic Opposition In Two Films

1770 words - 8 pages

The debate about political violence and nonviolence is a major theme in the discussion about the struggle for independence in Northern Ireland. This conflict is dramatized in the two films in context in the form of the Ireland Republic army (IRA) where two main characters are portrayed as a protagonist and an antagonist to bring out the theme in the films.
The Wind that Shakes the Barley is a film featured in the nineteenth century, by Ken Loach. Basing its storyline between the years 1920 and 1922, the film is founded on historical events. The film also employs a fictional cast of characters drawn from experiences of real-life participants. The rebellion involved between the Irish people ...view middle of the document...

All these, fit in the Michael Collins film pretty well.
Analysing Thematic Opposition in the two Films: Violence/Non-Violence.
Michael Collins:
Michael Collins film generally displays the importance of giving up violence while offering the effectiveness and legitimacy of violent methods to a certain extent to attain independence from the British invaders. In the film Michael Collins, there are two men, Eamon de Valera and Michael Collins, who are major participants in politics. At the start of the film, the two are on the same side, with similar interests of fighting for Irish freedom. The only disagreements coming up between them at this time seem to be related to their tactics. The first appearance of Michael Collins in uniform makes him easy to recognise as a soldier (Kilfeather, 215). Collins tries to stop British soldiers from hurting one of the ring leaders of the rising James Conolly after their capture which depicts him as a man who does not support violence. However, Eamon stops him telling him to wait for the next time which makes Eamon seem more like a strategist who is pro violence.
It is clear that while Collins is passionate and warm-hearted, he is also willing to resort to violence to defend his beliefs, even if it means doing it in a ruthless manner (Farquharson, Danine, and Sean 199). It is expected that Collins, as a man who has the interests of the Irish Republic at heart and a passionate man for that matter, would not advocate violence. However, as found earlier, at the time Eamon was jailed, Collins was the mastermind for all violence. He committed murders, daylight robberies and general mayhem all in the name of his beliefs.
At the same time, the film intends to capture the theme of nonviolence as an effective way to achieve their Irish independence. Before his death, Collins who is described as good at “bloody mayhem” commits to peace and negotiation only using violence as a last resort. From the film, Collins has ordered some deaths, including some assassinations (Kilfeather, 220). There is a conflict of themes where Collins has to commit so many murders to attain peace for the Irish Republic and later in his life he only resorts to violence after all other methods of resolution fail.
This film explores violent conflict between the rebels from Ireland and the British forces during the Easter Rising which happened in 1916 which led to the loss of the rebels to the British. The film debates on the civil wars in Ireland, casting light on the difficulties that led to the achievement of freedom. The film also connects the past and present relationship, leading to a re-examination of the Irish identity (Farquharson, Danine, and Sean 199).
The Wind That Shakes the Barley
Like in the ‘Michael Collins’ film, ‘The Wind That Shakes the Barley’ film is based on the violent and nonviolent theme with one of the main actors resorting to violence as a means of justifying their cause while the other resorting to peace. The film is...

Other Papers Like Analysing Thematic Opposition in Two Films

Kung Fu Movies Essay

2432 words - 10 pages Kung Fu movies Name: Institution: Course: Tutor: Date of submission: Introduction {introduce kung Fu movies] 0.5 Kung Fu movies are part of a subgenre of martial arts films. They are set in the modern period of futuristic martial arts. Kung Fu has its origins in China, which before being modernized, was popularly known as Wuxia (Greene, 2014). This film genre is an important creation of Hong Kong Cinema. The main difference between Kung

Fight Club and Reservoir Dogs Essay

978 words - 4 pages get Thomas Bonds English 201 Nov. 20, 2013 Fight Club and Reservoir Dogs Fight Club and Reservoir Dogs portray similar themes. The primary characters in both films are disconnected from themselves and therefore have trouble functioning in their own lives. These characters also have differing beliefs on the nature of their own realities and are disconnected from them. Similarly, David Fincher and Quinton Tarantino use thematic and


2606 words - 11 pages by a single oblique case marker kan. However, pronominal DPs demonstrate a further opposition between an ergative/genitive used for possession and for transitive subjects in OV, and a default form used for subjects in SV and for objects in OV, as well as for the complement of the oblique case marker. Unlike Malagasy (see Pearson 2001), the Itawes opposition cannot be reanalysed as a distinction between an enclitic series and a full pronominal

Socialist Realism

2423 words - 10 pages effective products of Socialist Realism. The book, entitled Chapaev, glorified the efforts and persistence of Chapaevs comrades even in the face of overpowering opposition and thereby turned the Bolshevik cause into a heroic mission. The message of the novel was preserved even through the heros death, which occurred during a moment of personal weakness and diversion from socialisms inexorable path. Through the novel, Bolshevik values become a

Qualitative Research Methods

4114 words - 17 pages another form of qualitative research methods. Thematic analysis can help ‘identify, analyse and report patterns (themes) within data. It minimally organises and describes your data set in (rich) detail. However, frequently it goes further than this, and interprets various aspects of the research topic.’ (Braun and Clarke, 2006, p.79).  A Thematic Analysis was conducted (shown in appendix 1) of the provided interview transcript for UWS School of

How to Analyze a Film

2921 words - 12 pages or emotional effect” (Boggs & Petrie, 2008, p. 20). It is in these films that “it is possible to identify a single mood or emotion that prevails throughout the film or to view each segment of the film as a step leading to a single powerful emotional effect” (Boggs & Petrie, p. 20). Some genres that use this thematic element are horror, such as The Shining; suspense thrillers, such as The Strangers; and romantic movies, such as The

What Ways Do Genre Change Over Time

990 words - 4 pages Do film genres change over time? The word genre is derived from the French meaning for "˜type' or "˜kind'. Genre is used as a concept to classify particular styles or types of texts by identifying common elements that are exhibited in films. It is also applied as an analytical device, used within the context of a text to establish typical characteristics and generic features displayed in texts. Genre is a powerful and effective tool

Horror Films

1913 words - 8 pages horror films. At the time Germany was in political turmoil; the rise of Nazism caused many architects and filmmakers to flee from Germany. One was Carl Laemmle who founded Universal Pictures. With him he brought German expressionism which was an artistic movement that was characteristic of German architecture, painting and theatre. In the 1930s Universal Pictures produced a series horror films which established the thematic preoccupations and

Film Noir

1057 words - 5 pages Intro to Film 10/25/11 Film Noir Film Noir is a term first used by some French critics to describe a group of American films made during and after World War II. The term Film Noir means black or dark cinema. Film noir is the classic period saying to have occurred between 1941 and 1958, beginning with John Huston’s The Maltese Falcon and ending with Orson Welle’s Touch of Evil. Film Noir is identified by its constant opposition of

Iranian Cinema

2569 words - 11 pages largely under the age of 25. This commercial Iranian cinema genre is largely unknown in the West, as the films are targeted at local audiences. There are two categories of this type of film: * Films about the victory of the Iranian Revolution of 1979 and the ensuing Iran–Iraq war, filled with strong religious and national motifs. * Formulaic films starring popular actors. With 130 Iranian films looking for a screening each year, cinema


762 words - 4 pages Early film (pre-1900) was dominated by the novelty of showing an event. They were single-shot moments captured on film: a train entering a station, a boat docking, or factory workers leaving work. These short films were called "actuality" films; the term "documentary" was not coined until 1926. Many of the first films, such as those made by Auguste and Louis Lumière, were a minute or less in length, due to technological limitations. Films

Related Essays

Analysis Of Amores Perros

3465 words - 14 pages between classes within Mexico City, whereas, the linear structure of Los Bastardos signifies a day in the life of a Mexican immigrant. El Espinazo Del Diablo’s use of flashbacks and linear story create a sense of mystery and although not classified as a drama, unlike the other two films, is classified as a horror and has noticeable similarities not only on the thematic level of violence but also in that it contains an allegory about more widespread

Quantitative Qualitative Essay

1537 words - 7 pages analysed using the following methods: content analysis, thematic discourse analysis, grounded theory and interpretive phenomenology. Content analysis refers to retrieving and analysing the content of text. The content includes pictures, symbols and words. Text is in written form such as books, films and lyrics (Neuman, 2003). Thematic discourse analysis is the process of categorising relevant data to discover patterns and themes. Grounded

Genre Study Essay

3259 words - 14 pages audience in that they can relate to and understand the text at a deeper level, having seen numerous films with similar conventions. This is particularly useful in terms of supernatural horror films that rely on suspense, enabled by audience expectation, to frighten their viewers (Tudor 450). Such a vague representation of genre is further exacerbated by modern scholars’ contention that genre operates and is defined at three different levels; those of

Global Flexible Barrier Films For Electronics Market Research Report 2016

1004 words - 5 pages account of the Global Flexible Barrier Films for Electronics Industry. Details such as the size, key players, segmentation, SWOT analysis, most influential trends, and business environment of the market are mentioned in this report. Furthermore, this report features tables and figures that render a clear perspective of the Global Flexible Barrier Films for Electronics Industry. The report features an up-to-date data on key companies product