This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

An Article Review Of Koen Van Eijk And John Lievens's "Cultural Omnivorousness As A Combination Of Highbrow, Pop, And Folk Elements"

1398 words - 6 pages

The Omnivore Debate: An Article Review

van Eijk, Koen and John Lievens. 2008. “Cultural Omnivorousness as a Combination of Highbrow, Pop, and Folk Elements: The Relation Between Taste Patterns and Attitudes Concerning Social Integration.” Poetics 36. 217-242.

While most scholars acknowledge the elusiveness that the term “culture” invokes, perhaps even more tenuous is the understanding of preferential taste of particular aspects of culture (i.e., taste in music, art, etc.). Certainly if it were easy enough to ask a group of people, “What do you like? And why do you like it?” there would be little—or at least, far less—debate on the subject; however, this is, of course, not the case. ...view middle of the document...

It is this that, rather than enhancing the reading, detracts from it overall.
Contrary to what one would expect, the authors’ well-versed familiarity with their subject weakens the text by eliminating most, if not all, accessibility to outsiders with fresh or new perspectives. Van Eijk and Lievens are so comfortable with their study that they assume anyone reading their work is actually already a cultural scholar. Without the context of their previous works as well as that of other scholar’s works, one would easily be lost in the density of the text. I find this to be incredibly unfortunate as it is nigh impossible to share the contents of this article with friends, family, or colleagues who have no prior knowledge of the cultural omnivore debate or van Eijk’s and Lievens’s previous works, and thus this knowledge will likely remain confined to a particular group of scholars.
However, accessibility of information is not van Eijk’s and Lievens’s purpose in writing this piece. Rather, the duo’s intention is to “move the discussion about the cultural omnivore ahead” by differentiating different types of omnivores and by estimating “taste patterns...and attitudes concerning social integration” (2008: 218). The two scholars attempt to accomplish this by first breaking up taste patterns (what one likes or prefers) into three separate “cultural schemes” or culture-oriented categories: highbrow, pop, and folk, and, as such, an individual can then be defined as a culture omnivore when his or her taste pattern includes interests from more than one culture scheme (218). With the culture omnivore operationalized, van Eijk and Lievens move to discern the role that omnivorous cultural consumption plays in social integration and the maintenance of social networks. The authors focus on six attitudes related to social integration to infer the social implications that result from individuals falling into one or many combinations of the aforementioned culture schemes. The six attitudes are explained in full on page 225, but in short are listed as: utilitarian individualism, solidarity, social disorientation, social isolation, expressive individualism, and communitarianism.
To be sure, van Eijk and Lievens believe that by focusing on the people’s attitudes of others and society based on taste pattern and culture scheme categorization, they can better explore the different social implications that result from being a specific type of omnivore (i.e., one who likes pop-highbrow rather than highbrow-folk, etc.). They describe this quite aptly as on page 219 as follows: “different ways of being a cultural omnivore are expected to have different social implications, or reflect different attitudes”. Moreover, with the attitudes defined, the two authors go on to describe culture schemes. These are categorized as highbrow, folk, and pop, or high culture scheme, trivial scheme, and excitement scheme respectively (219) and are further defined as follows:
...

Other Papers Like An Article Review of Koen Van Eijk and John Lievens's "Cultural Omnivorousness as a Combination of Highbrow, Pop, and Folk Elements"

Position of English as a Global Language: Political and Cultural Factors

2157 words - 9 pages Position of English as a Global Language: Political and Cultural Factors English has achieved a global significance that no other language has ever been able to do so, in such a scale. A language earns its global status when it culturally and politically dominant across the continents. Also, it is notable that the most salient feature of a global language is not how many people use it, rather how strongly the people who speak this language is

Article Review And Analysis

934 words - 4 pages will discuss three articles that discuss personality tests, transformational leadership, and assessments.Article OneArticle one is on personality and how it is measured in organizational research. This article is framed as a series of seven questions. The seven questions address personality and multidimensional models of performance, personality taxonomies and the five-factor model, the effects of situations on personality-performance

Brilliant Lies By David Williamson Shows That Sexual Harassment Is A Twisted Combination Of Sex And Power

938 words - 4 pages Brilliant Lies by David Williamson shows that sexual harassment is a twisted combination of sex and power. Susy Conner uses sex to gain power, Gary Fitzgerald uses power to gain sex and Brian Conner was too drunk to realise his abuse of both power and sexual harassment. All of these characters wanted something and they all thought they knew how to get it by using either sex or power, or a little of each.Susy has always relied on her looks and

Review of Article

727 words - 3 pages Article Review HCS 430 July 29, 2013 Melissa Borrelli Article Review Introduction: In this article The Concept of Addiction in Law and Regulatory Policy Related to Pain Management This appears in criminal and in crimes the author of this article Aaron M. Gilson MS, MSSW PhD argues that in order for a physician to declare a person a drug addict compulsive behavior must also be noted. This paper will be analyzing Gilson’s

Life and Art of Van Gogh

1217 words - 5 pages the passers-by see only a wisp of smoke." The extent of his mental health affected his paintings and it wasn’t until after his death that his paintings were recognized as influential. Modern critics proclaim that through his work, one can see an artist deeply frustrated by the inactivity and incoherence due to his mental health status. One of the biggest misunderstandings of Van Gogh as an artist arises from the collection of letters

Review Your Role, Responsibilities and Boundaries as a Teacher in Terms of the Teacher/Training Cycle

1536 words - 7 pages Review your role, responsibilities and boundaries as a teacher in terms of the teaching/training cycle. One of the main and traditional responsibilities of a teacher is to ensure that all the students gain any qualification or skill they have come to achieve. In order to achieve that, a number of steps must be taken. In this cycle the learner is central and all revolves around him. Paramount are the needs of the learner. In order to achieve

Terms of Combination

863 words - 4 pages Terms of Combination A. Merger Motives for Merger * Creating value (that is, mergers with these motives have the potential to add value): * Synergy (Note: 1 + 1 > 2) * Economies of scale * Cross-product selling * Growth * External growth (may be less risky than organic growth) * Increasing market power * Horizontal or vertical integration to increase strength in the

The Cues Program: A Review Of A Nursing Journal Article

738 words - 3 pages The Cues Program: A Review of a Nursing Journal Article Rachel M NURS The Cues Program: A Review of a Nursing Journal Article Infants born weighing less than 1,500 g are called very low birth weight (VLBW) infants. These infants are usually preterm and often require hospitalization in a neonatal intensive care unit (NICU.) VLBW infants are at higher risk of developmental problems so there has been an emphasis on developing programs

Review Of Article "Asymmetric Reactions To Work Group Sex Diversity Among Men And Women" Written By Jennifer A. Chatman And Charles A. O'reilly

1476 words - 6 pages Introduction:The article explores how work group sex composition influences men and women and how this affects firm - performance. Past researches indicated that demographic similarities yielded improved financial performance (Byrne, 1971) yet the recent findings estimate that women expressed a greater likelihood of gender diversity than men. This paper is the first to explain why variations in work group sex composition might affect men and

Qualitative And Quantitive Article Review

2829 words - 12 pages Quantitive and Qualitative Article Review Kristi Schneider Walden University NURS-4000 Res/Scholarshp Evid-based Prac2016 3-20-2016 Quantitive and Qualitative Article Review Quantitive and qualitative studies in research are an important aspect of the nursing profession. Researching and reviewing quantitive and qualitative articles is a process of systematic examination of materials to enhance, validate and learn new knowledge

Analysis Of An Article

1304 words - 6 pages Analysis of an Article The broadsheet newspaper article titled “Muslim Schoolgirls risk careers for their symbolic headscarves”, written by Amelia Gentleman reacts to the new law in France prohibiting the wearing of religious symbols. This article highlights the calamity faced by Samia and her sister in having to choose between a symbol of huge significance (the headscarf) and something as equally vital as their

Related Essays

Comparison Of Folk And Rap Essay

1126 words - 5 pages John Denver, an American songwriter, once said, "Music does bring people together. It allows us to experience the same emotions. People everywhere are the same in heart and spirit. No matter what language we speak, what color we are, the form of our politics or the expression of our love and our faith, music proves: We are the same.” Folk and rap music are both very popular genres and each has a considerable amount of fans. Folk and rap music

Social, Cultural, Historical Elements Of A Taste Of Honey

2468 words - 10 pages Social, Cultural, historical elements of A Taste of Honey Introduction: `A Taste of Honey’ highlights many issues which would have been easily understood for audiences in the 1950s. Many issues are raised in which the audience can relate to. Delaney’s intention was to make the play realistic, as therefore it is highly influenced by Stavislavski’s “kitchen sink” theatre (genre). When the play was written, society was very different

Elements Of The Absurd And Contradictory Comparing Kenji Kawakami And Fiona Hall, Using The Four Frames As A Guide

1523 words - 7 pages there is a social meaning behind every Chindogu. Kawakami raised an interesting point when he told London's The Independent last year, "I think my inventions show us how stupid the Japanese and Western World's obsession is with making life as easy as we can through new inventions." From this we can conceive that Kawakami's inventions make fun of the technological world and its passion on making everything easy and simple. One example is the

Isolation And Emily Grierson: A Deadly Combination

952 words - 4 pages times in his writing. In the book The Major Years, Melvin Backman states that Faulkner was reaching for a more decent life and more decent people in the midst of evil. He was reaching for love, innocence, simplicity, and strength, but he also knew that these things were being hidden by reality. 'With Faulkner, as with all men, the personal condition underlay and shaped his view of the human condition' (Backman, p.183).The critic goes on to note that