This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Americanization And Canadian Culture Essay

1283 words - 6 pages

Americanization and Canadian Culture

Gaëtan Tremblay is a professor at the University in Quebec in Montreal. As a concerned Quebecois, He wrote an article which discusses the Americanization of Canada, in particular Quebec. Tremblay seems to have a strong stand point about the future of Quebec. Using statistical and literary evidence, primary and secondary sources, he attempts to support his argument that Quebec is a victim of American cultural colonization. Tremblay fears that Canadian culture is going to disappear as a result of the Canadian-American Free Trade Agreement.

Tremblay started his article with what broadcasting is considered to be in Canada which is “an instrument of ...view middle of the document...

The exert does not directly imply that the United States cares less

about its culture because they are considering deregulation of radio broadcasting. The American Culture may not be threatened by deregulation the same way as the Canadian culture. But since he started his essay by mentioning how broadcasting “must” contribute to the development of Canadian culture, he is implying that the American culture has the same concept. The American culture may not be severely effected by deregulation just as the Canadian culture, so Tremblay’s argument may not be valid. To some readers who did not notice the bias, this argument may be considered very strong and convincing.

The second part of Gaëtan Tremblay’s article, he focuses on the content of Quebec Television, and more precisely, the francophones. Through the observations he made on a table which presents data on the content of francophone Quebecois networks, he stateed that a large share of all programs are Canadian which has increased in seven years which is all thanks to the CRTC regulation;

“The first observation: nearly two-thirds of all program broadcast by the Quebecois networks are of Canadian origin…Second Observation: the share of Canadian products increased by 4 percentage points over the course of the seven years between 1982 and 1989. Observation three: overall situation is not that bad.”

He was implying that without this regulation of broadcasting, Canadian content would decrease and American content would take over. Tremblay brusheed on the point that the language barrier and viewer preference may have an influence on the reason why Canadian content would increase. These factors are actually quite important in francophone networks because the demand on American content may not be as strong whether or not there was regulation.

The article then contained a number of tables which are hard to read and are not analyzed properly by Tremblay. The tables, although they contained valuable primary data, a reader may find it excessive, confusing and a burden to evaluate which might make his article weaker. First Tremblay discussed general programming in French-language television stations then he jumps into a specific medium which is drama programming. He evaluated drama programming very precisely. He effectively presented data about Canadian performance which has decreased significantly and has been replaced by foreign content. After jumping from the precise topic of drama programming produced locally by francophone Quebecois television stations, he moved on to compare it with film of French and English language.

His argument on drama programming was effective and detailed but he directed all his focus on only drama programming and gave extremely little attention to other entertainment categories. For example, Canadian content in drama programming has decrease but in other areas, such as music and radio could have increased which could balance it out. By mentioning only one...

Other Papers Like Americanization And Canadian Culture

Canadian Literautre Essay

1779 words - 8 pages sentence, change wording. the need to focus on our own Canadian culture despite being surrounded by other cultures, the need to promote and establish our own writers, and the need to encourage younger Canadian authors. Based on the points listed in the Introduction, this paragraph should focus on “Focusing on our own Canadian Culture” Students in Ontario taking English should only study Canadian literature because we are completely swamped by the

Grade 12 Ontario Students Studying Canadian Literature(U1A6)

681 words - 3 pages culture and despite being surrounded by many other cultures, the need to promote and establish our own writers is there, as well as the need to encourage younger Canadian authors. Students in Ontario taking English should only study Canadian literature because we are completely swamped and overrun by the American culture that is exposed to us on a daily basis. This has always been a Canadian tradition because we have always been a branch plant or

Canada vs the United States

981 words - 4 pages Growing up in Canada and growing up in the United States for children these days is totally different from how it used to be. The idea of Canadian identity is an issue that not many people think about, and that most people take for granted. What you may not know, is that some of these differences in our mannerisms and culture could effect our society so much that we could go from 10 provinces and 3 territories to 4 provinces and 3

The New Left: Most Influential School Of Thought

1449 words - 6 pages conflict (New Left Notes). In "Who Is An American?" Eric Foner speaks of the way in which national politics and economic life helped to clearly define ethnic and racial differences. This in turn lead stimulated the creation of a "more homogenous national culture" through Americanization (Foner 187). In his article, Foner criticizes political figures because of their racist attitudes. The Progressive desire to improve the "quality" of democratic


1291 words - 6 pages Sydney Hirschman English 101 Due July 18th 2012 Words:1254 Robert Fuentes Americanization For many years, the United Sates has been attracting immigrants from a variety of different races, countries and religions to come and live in a land full of freedom and opportunity. These immigrants are slowly but surely turning America into a culture melting pot, giving it the most diversity people have seen in a lifetime. Although it is a

The Rise Of Canadian Military Professionalism In World War 1

792 words - 4 pages author explains that the key ingredients to success that are described as “good habits” and a “good organizational culture” , were not fully in place and prevented the CEF from reaching its maximum operational effectiveness. Dickson is intrigued with the CEF in that there was an element that made them unique to both their Allied and Axis counterparts allowing them to reach this “elite” plateau, as the “Canadian Expeditionary Force (CEF) shared


2023 words - 9 pages distributed amongst the football club and the workers. However others argue that what the workers earn is enough for them to survive and make a living in their country once purchasing power parity is considered. Also it is argued that it is better that they earn something instead of nothing at all. Americanization is another social cost of globalisation whereby American culture is exported abroad and has eroded other cultural beliefs. Electronic and

How Globalization Effects France

2410 words - 10 pages . Historically, France has opposed globalization and this disdain started gaining ground during the early 1990s as Europe was becoming integrated. The French feared globalization because they wanted to preserve their own rich culture, and because they saw globalization as another form of americanization and wanted no part of that. An example of this would be in 1999 when “a forty-six-year-old sheep farmer named José Bové was arrested for dismantling

Identity, Olympics, and the Canadian Myth (1st Year Cultural Studies Paper)

1131 words - 5 pages I'm A Stranger Here Myself: Identity, Olympics, and the Canadian Myth In this essay I am going to look at Olympic line of products, and what they represent about identity and consumer culture. For the purposes of this essay, I focus only on the knitted Cowichan sweater (Please see Appendix A), and the red wool mittens (Please see Appendix B), since these are the things that have come to define “campus cool” and the Canadian Olympic identity

Policy Formulation: Settlement House Movement

538 words - 3 pages collectively in an interdependent community. It was this call to duty in which the establishment of “settlement houses” were born and produced. These houses were manufactured in poor urban parts of the country where they had settlement house volunteers who would live; share their culture, knowledge, and education as well as helping to improve the poverty line of their low income neighbors. These volunteers and residents; officiated effective

Saudi Arabian Polygamists: A Canadian Social Issue

2103 words - 9 pages polygamists and non-polygamists. Polygamous marriages challenge the typical family units around which Canadian society is currently organized (Kaufman, 2005) which can make non-polygamists skeptical of their lifestyle choice. The best strategies for research would be to hear and give credence to the sister wives regarding their own experiences as polygamous wives. The vitality of women’s experiences to understanding tradition and culture is

Related Essays

The Americanization Of Canada Essay

2737 words - 11 pages flowing over the boarder are examined and if any toxins or pollutants are observed, the IAQAB simply advises the governments of what action to take (Our Great Lakes). In an environmental setting, Canadian laws are becoming merged with American laws. This form of Americanization is beneficial to both countries. A second form of political culture, media, is primarily produced and controlled by the United States, even though the majority of

The Uncertain Future Of Quebec Culture

1465 words - 6 pages necessary with each passing day. However, Tremblay has ignored the fact that Quebec culture is already protected in part by the Canadian constitution. From the beginning, the Canadian federation has provided guarantees, for the Quebec language and culture. “The Constitution Act, 1867 contained specific provisions designed to protect Quebec 's distinct culture and language” (Nicholson, 2003) Canada has always given guarantees to protect the Quebec

Studying Canadian Literature Essay

671 words - 3 pages promote and establish our own writers, and the need to encourage younger Canadian authors. Students in Ontario taking English should only study Canadian literature because we are completely swamped by the American culture around us. This is a Canadian tradition because we have always been a “branch plant” of another country starting with England and France meaning that our own culture has never had the chance to develop since we have always been

Globalization, Mass Media And Culture Essay

4196 words - 17 pages Cultural Theory and Popular Culture Globalization, Mass Media and Culture Table of Contents Globalization, Mass Media and Culture 1 Table of Contents 2 Introduction 3 Modern culture, ideology 4 Globalization 5 Americanization 6 Mass Media and their Impact 7 Globalization, mass media and culture 8 Mass media and globalization 9 Globalization and culture 10 Conclusion 12 My opinion 13 Recommendations 14 List of