This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

American Exceptionalism Essay

587 words - 3 pages

The question of American exceptionalism will always be a controversial one. In two contrasting essays, professors Ian Tyrrell and Seymour Martin Lipset discuss their views on American exceptionalism. Tyrrell does not believe America to be exceptional and talks mostly about history from all over the world to make his case. Lipset, on the other hand, believes that the United States is exceptional in that it differs from other countries since it began from a revolutionary event. I agree with both Tyrrell and Lipset. While America may exceptional in certain aspects, it is not in others. Lipset definitely has good supporting ideas and facts for his argument. He says, "As I have frequently argued, it is impossible to understand a country without seeing how it varies from others." ...view middle of the document...

I agree with Lipset in this aspect because in my opinion it is important for us to have the freedom to make choices regarding our own religion and other such matters. Lipset also discusses the American Constitution and the Bill of Rights and how they are "designed to protect the citizenry against the abuse of power by the government." I also agree with Lipset on this. American is exceptional in that we have the Bill of Rights and the Constitution to protect our given rights as human beings. We should have the rights that are given to us in both of those documents and in that way America is exceptional. Tyrrell doesn't agree with Lipset in that he does not believe America to be exceptional. His main point throughout the essay is that history has this ideology that American is exceptional, which, in his opinion, is not the case. He says, "The history of the United States cannot be exceptional unless contrasted with other histories that conform to fixed patterns of historical development. I agree with Tyrrel in that history and certain accounts of historical events give us this preconception that America is greatly exceptional. In conclusion, American exceptionalism cannot be narrowed down to a yes or no answer. Some will agree with Lipset and believe that yes America is exceptional because we have religious and personal freedom and have our rights protected and other such reasons. Some will agree with Tyrrell and believe that America is not necessarily exceptional and just believe American exceptionalism is just an idea ingrained in our heads by history and accounts a historical events. Even though we do have all our freedom in America in all these different ways, you cannot infer that the United States is exceptional just based on those ideas.

Other Papers Like American Exceptionalism

Diplomacy, Wilson and Roosevelt Essay

804 words - 4 pages the military and forcing America to expand trade. Roosevelt’s quiet but aggressive ideology to progress trade was most effective, as was Wilson’s reign that limited a foreign policy by tying it to morality. Wilson’s vision embedded the idea of American exceptionalism. American liberal values, established capital development, democracy, and free trade, was Wilson’s ideal visions of America’s gateway to the future. As leaders Roosevelt and Wilson made a profound world order that progressed the United States’ military system and improved and expanded trade.

Secularism Essay

786 words - 4 pages seclusion of a monetary (Kosmin 2). Later, during the Reformation, secularization referred to the seizure and reappropriation of Church property for non-religious use (Kosmin 2). Thus secular began to indicate a separation from the Church or the divine. However, It wasn’t until the 18th century that secularism as a core element of a nation’s political realm developed. The American and the French Revolutions produced the two main “intellectual and

Why Do We Do School?

2593 words - 11 pages statistics. The American society pressures students to become successful and when a child does not possess the “appropriate” means, they construct their own. Now we have drug dealers and prostitutes in these communities trying to achieve the American dream through different means, leading to ignorance and violence in the community, a never ending loop. The second part of the false narrative is exceptionalism. Apparently, American society has a

A Lesson in History: the Revolutionary War

1138 words - 5 pages , American deputies of democracy engaged in the same rhetoric of improvement as their English mother. As Spanos cites, America was "either self-doomed or appealing to the European to save them from themselves by way of imposing his peace on their wasteful strife." So, instead of asking “is it cool to destroy this new land”, linear history implicitly uses the guise of sociology to calculate America's birth and development—society is here and your

The 4 Functions of Management

2435 words - 10 pages every significant task and, in extreme cases, dictate every small step the workers take’. Appendix 6 lists the common features of micromanagement. An excellent article headed ‘Nearly eight in 10 employees are victims of a micromanaging boss. Here's how to cope’ in American Way Magazine provides real life examples of micromanagement; Appendix 7 contains the full article. Ultimately micromanagement is mismanagement, and under it, the manager

Vietnam

2296 words - 10 pages why. Why were the North Vietnamese so resilient? Why did the US make such poor judgment? Why were we really there? What was Vietnam's history prior to our arrival? “History is an organic process, a continuity of related events, inexorable yet not inevitable.” (pg 11) The roots of America's involvement in Vietnam were nurtured by what Professor Daniel Bell has called America's concept of its own “exceptionalism.” George Berkeley, an

History Research Eassay

3437 words - 14 pages of Canadian defense industry important to the security of the United States. The American governments provided financial assistance to Canada for its defense production industries in 1915, 1916 and 1917. It also exempted Canada from various policies imposing coals on steel and coal exports, which indirectly were impacting the production in Canada. These measures marked the beginning of the policy of exceptionalism, which became the hallmark of

The Problems Of Southern California

1851 words - 8 pages victims in the poor communities never received any compensation at all. Davis writes, “Defended in 1993 by the largest army of firefighters in American history, wealthy Malibu homeowners benefited as well as from an extraordinary range of insurance, landuse, and disaster relief subsidies…If enormous resources have been allocated…to fight irresistible forces of nature on the Malibu coast, then scandalously little attention has been paid to the

Foreign Subsidiary Investment Plan Case: Multinational Capital Budgeting China & Australia

5529 words - 23 pages an American–European business environment; favorable time zone; economic and political stability; attractive, safe and friendly environment; an Asian-oriented, culturally diverse and multilingual society. Australia also has a business-friendly regulatory environment. According to the World Bank, Australia is the fastest place in the world in which to start a business, with regulatory procedures taking just two days. The OECD has also identified

The Crisis of Crimea and Ukraine

3916 words - 16 pages address the current conflict in Crimea and Ukraine. They also showcase that, given the tools available to him, President Obama is utilizing them as appropriately and effectively as Reagan and Clinton did, and his actions do not differ from his predecessors. Today, conservatives see Reaganism in foreign policy as placing no boundaries on American military strength; indeed, they see a foreign policy rooted in American exceptionalism. But President

Basics Of Economic Geography

2785 words - 12 pages Christaller and August Lösch) as the roots of economic geography. Their goal was to develop optimal location patterns for the most efficient functioning of farms, factories and cities, given geographical endowments and acces-sibility (e.g. transport costs). Location modelling subsequently crossed the Atlantic, where it was incorporated into North American economic geog-raphy and became an important foundation of regional science, thanks to Walter

Related Essays

Neoliberalism Essay

1304 words - 6 pages To what extent does the term ‘American exceptionalism’ necessarily imply U.S. superiority? Red Reference Blue Title Purple reword to be better Come back to with evidence or etc ( real example) (also a scholar arguing for and one against with my opining in the end little conculsion) “American Execptionalism” is theoretically classified as America being qualitatively different () from other countries. Therefore in terms of America’s

“Benito Cereno” And Manifest Destiny By Allan Moore Emery, Review

935 words - 4 pages rhetorical camouflage for a largely political enterprise (54). Another interesting political instance, according to the author, is when Delano attempts to buy Babo. Emery calls this attempt “embarrassing”, clearly positioning himself as opposing the doctrine of American exceptionalism. This attempted exchange of goods may be seen as a mission to extend America’s democracy in the Western hemisphere. However, Emery immediately points out that Delano

Affirmative Essay

788 words - 4 pages AFFIRMITIVE “We’ve got to do a better job of getting across that America is freedom, freedom of speech, freedom of religion, freedom of enterprise, and freedom is special and rare. It’s fragile, it needs production.” Because I believe in the words of Ronald Reagan, I must affirm the resolution. US foreign policy ought to be guided by American Exceptionalism. V: American Supremacy C: American Exceptionalism Before we begin this debate

To Be American Essay

1804 words - 8 pages dispute.             The use of the term “myth” is itself a clue that America’s exceptionalism has limits. Myths have been powerful forces throughout history and in all communities. Whether or not a myth becomes an element of national identity depends on the current beliefs and practices of a particular country. The American mythical idea in fact derives from the European Enlightenment (“English or French or whatever”). The ideas of John Locke