This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

African American Vernacular English Code Switching In School

547 words - 3 pages

Senator Jones,

I am writing to you to discuss the current bill that would like to ban using the method of “code-switching” from the “home language” of AAE (African American Vernacular English) speakers. I have read a study conducted by a Umass professor regarding this issue, and I have read the bill thoroughly. My recommendation to you is to vote against the bill, and I have some very good reasons for it. Banning the AAE instruction will do more harm then good. Although the bill proposes some good reasons for needing to speak mainstream English, it misses a few key points. They claim that linguistic skills like writing and reading are necessary to an individuals success. They don’t realize however, that AAE is a structured language following rules and patterns. The ...view middle of the document...

Their foundation in AAE would make normal English instruction worthless. Since AAE follows rules, “code-switching” is a totally viable option. The proponents are saying that teaching these children differently is equivalent to slavery. Teaching them normally, and not using this effective method is more like slavery since they wont actually learn to speak properly. You would be preventing them the ability to learn mainstream English. Professor Green points out that what most people think is an unsuccessful attempt at speaking mainstream English, is an AEE speaker using a different version of English completely. The further we study the patterns and rules of AAE, the easier it will be to help switch the speakers into the mainstream mold that the creators of this bill want.

Saying that the proponents of this bill want what’s best for the AAE speakers is just plain wrong. They have not done their research. If they had, they would know that AAE is not simply a failed attempt at speaking English. They would understand that to switch someone from AAE to mainstream English is no easy task, and passing this bill would make it all but impossible. If we want to move forward and actually help people succeed, not just pretend to help them, we must not allow this bill to pass. If it passes, AAE speakers will be hung out to dry. They will have no way of learning proper English, and any attempt at teaching it to them will most likely fail. Don’t let a poorly researched, opinionated bill cause irreparable damage to linguistic advancement in our state. The current teaching methods of AAE to mainstream English are working perfectly fine, and improving with time. If this bill passes, we will set ourselves back in time, and abolish the only successful method there is!

Other Papers Like African American Vernacular English Code Switching in School

By 1750 the English Colonies on the North American Mainland Had Matured and Changed. What Were the Key Ways in Which the Colonial Societies of This Era (1700-1750) Differed from Those of the Early...

827 words - 4 pages tobacco, rice, indigo and corn to England. In return all colonies imported manufactured goods from England for common use at home. The business and farming depended on apprentices and slave labors. The demand of low cost labor increased in African American slave population in agricultural Southern states and more immigrants settled in other colonies. The colonies looked more like British cities and British made goods were in good demand thus

Why Creation Should Not Be Taught In School This Is A Outline For Why Evolution And Not Creation Should Be Taught In American Public Schools

1253 words - 6 pages creation with evolution was unconstitutional"(Ruse, p. 2).2. Also, in Webster v. New Lenox (1990) "the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that school boards have the right to prohibit teaching creationism because such lessons would constitute religious advocacy and, hence, such restrictions do not constitute an infringement on a teacher's free speech rights"(Ruse, p. 2).B. The First Amendment from the Bill of Rights states freedom of religion.1

North American Civilization

2268 words - 10 pages speakers in urban areas of the North are changing the pronunciation of vowels in a systematic way? For instance, some speakers in Buffalo, Cleveland, Detroit and Chicago pronounce bat so that it sounds like bet and bet so that it sounds like but. Linguists call these patterned alterations the Northern Cities Vowel Shift. * Which features of African American Vernacular English (AAVE) grammar are used by middle-class white teen-agers who admire

Written Task 1 Part 1

1358 words - 6 pages . Dear Board, I am a student, from Castle Mont high school Oakland. I am a hard working student, but I still cannot manage to compete with the other white students in my grade, the teacher thinks I am illiterate, but its not my fault that I am a black teenager and can only understand AAVE (African American Vernacular English). Recently while going through the news, trying to get more familiar with Standard English I came across an article

Why People Code Switch

2463 words - 10 pages express a certain feeling or attitude as well as to persuade the audience and grab their attention. Why do People Code-switch 10 References Abalhassan, K. M., & Al Shalawi, H. G. (2000). Code-switching Behavior of Arab Speakers of English as a Second Language in the United States*. Intercultural Communication Studies, X(1), 179-188. Al-Khatib, H. (2003). Language Alternation among Arabic and English Youth Bilinguals: Reflecting or

Identity and Varieties of English

2163 words - 9 pages McNair-Knox (1994) arranged a series of interviews with an African-American teenager to examine the speech style of switching between standard American English (AE) and African American Vernacular English (AAVE). The teenager was interviewed by both African-American and White interviewers for some years. Rickford and McNair-Knox found that the frequency of AAVE features in her speech was significantly higher in the interviews with the African

The Lesson

952 words - 4 pages background and pride by using the same dialect that she used growing up in Harlem, New York. According to Bambara, she spoke African American Vernacular English (AAVE), a trait that imparts to Sylvia. African American Vernacular English adds realism and humor to Sylvia's narrative because it describes her ethnicity without directly expressing what it is. It is common for African-American writers to use AAVE to emphasize their political and social

Assessing Curriculum Theory

1736 words - 7 pages exclusion of using the correct subject/verb agreement and including the word “done” to show some type of action (Craig, Zang, Hensel & Quinn, 2009). Many students learn to code switch when they leave their home and enter school. Code switching or dialect shifting consists of using Standard American English instead of the cultural African American English away from the home setting. A study to evaluate the differences among African

Code Switching Annotated Article

3665 words - 15 pages . (2004). Spanish/English Codeswitching in a written corpus. Philadelphia: John Benjamins Publishing Co. Callahan’s first chapter, “Codeswitching: Form and function”, is an excellent basic introduction to code switching. It is very useful for anyone interested in starting to learn about the subject. She talks about borrowing and code switching in languages, and the debates around those issues. The differences between metaphorical, situational

Vernacular English

2000 words - 8 pages Rhetoric II 3/31/06 EBONICS: LANGUAGE OR DIALECT? Ebonics is often defined as a vernacular form of the English language. This highly controversial title also known as African American Vernacular English (AAVE) by Encyclopedia Britannica, reflects the dialect of American English spoken by a large portion of the African American population. Many scholars hold that the term Ebonics developed from contacts between nonstandard

Code Switching And Modern Language Mixing

1519 words - 7 pages -bilingual speakers. In fact, it often occurs among speakers with high levels of proficiency in two or more languages. (Curzan 386) The traditional common example of code-switching is in a conversation between two speakers who speak the same two languages. In the United States, the relevant languages are usually English and Spanish. A sentence might begin in English and end in Spanish, or it may be entirely in Spanish except for one English word

Related Essays

Hiv In Black African American Essay

2789 words - 12 pages HIV in the African American Population HIV in the African American Population The year was 1981, and the first discovered cases of PCP, Pneumocystis Cabrini pneumonia was discovered in five young males who did not fit the norm for being diagnosed with this disease. In 1983, the isolation of a T lymph tropic retrovirus was found. In January 1983, the CDC reported a new disease which could be sexually transmitted both homosexually and

Breast Cancer In African American Women

1460 words - 6 pages Breast Cancer in African American Women HCA 430: Special Population Jennine Kinsey Daisha Smith October 8, 2012 “Cancer is the second most common cause of death in the U.S. only exceed by heart disease and the number one killer of persons before the age of 75” (Turnock, B., 2007, p.28). Vulnerable populations can range from homeless, alcohol and substance abuses, or chronically or mentally ill and disabled that has a number of health

African American Poverty Rates Highest In Four Years

399 words - 2 pages 26.6 درصد رشد داشته است. البته نرخ فقر برای کودکان اسپانیایی تبار، شاهد افزایشی 35 درصدی بوده است. African-American Poverty Rates Highest In Four years Written by Sentinel News Service, For a fourth year in a row, the African-American poverty rate more than doubled that of non-Hispanic white Americans, according to 2010 data released today by the U.S. Census Bureau. At 27.4 percent, the African-American poverty rate also nearly doubled the

Analysis Of Literary Devices Used In The Book Of Zora Hurston, An African A Merican Book Title: Dust Tracks On A Road: An Autobiography (1942)

567 words - 3 pages Living in the South during 1942, Zora Hurston gives the reader a first-person point of view of her valued yet constricted childhood as an African-American. By using diction from a young girl's perspective and her manipulation of point of view, Zora enriches our sense of her childhood. Most importantly, the time period of a belligerent WWII foreshadows Zora's conflict to try to break free from authority and her audacity to speak her mind.From the