This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Affirmative Action Essay 12

1086 words - 5 pages

Although it is imperative that minorities have equal opportunity with other Americans, it is not the government’s responsibility to actively pursue and demand private businesses and organizations to adhere to minority quotas. The concept of being treated differently in an effort to achieve equality is entirely paradoxical and thus should not be forced by the government. Affirmative action’s true effect comes not in pulling minorities up but holding businesses and organizations back. Forcing a company to hire a minority with lesser credentials is undemocratic and unfair. If the American dream is the possibility of hard work leading to success no matter one’s race, gender, or social ...view middle of the document...

It is such inconsistencies and short comings that shatter the fragile idealistic concept of affirmative action.
Despite the constant attention and reverence by many to the affirmative action system, in reality it is not nearly as effective as advertised. In the mid 1960’s to the mid 1970’s, poverty among African Americans had nearly been cut in half. Since the implementation of the affirmative action plan in 1975, there has been little change to the percentage of African Americans under the poverty line (Sowell, 45). Since that installation several Supreme Court rulings have upheld the basic concept of affirmative action to varying degrees, but recently they have supported the plan to a lesser extent than in the past. In a recent case, Grutter v Bollinger, the Supreme Court ruled that while race may play a determining role in the decision to admit applicants to colleges, it cannot be the deciding factor, only equally considered along with other characteristics such as academic success and athletic ability (Wohlers, 95). This gradual decline in the trust put into the affirmative action system implies that the government is slowly determining the plan’s short comings.
Many experts agree that the problems with affirmative action are even more significant than overspending and inefficient business. Other countries such as Sri Lanka and India have employed a system similar to affirmative action, and neither experienced the desired results. Instead of a society of equivalence and education, in both instances the end result was a very polarized society, with much of the wealth and education enjoyed by a small percent at the top of society while most people endured poor living conditions and terrible education. In both of these countries a middle class is nearly nonexistent, a trait that points to a pending decline or even collapse of that country. In India the installation of such unequal treatment directly coincided with illegal mob activity, and after the implementation of affirmative action terrible civil wars broke out in Sri Lanka (Avery, 33).
Recent studies and trends have led people to understand that the key to the future success of minorities lies in childhood education, not lowering standards to satisfy quotas. The National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) reports that the average African American high school...

Other Papers Like Affirmative Action - Essay 12

Reverse Discirmination Essay

1460 words - 6 pages keep it under control. References: messerli, j. (2010, august 12). Should Affirmative action policies be eliminated. Retrieved from mondy, r.w. (2010). Human resource management 11th edtion. Pearson .

Affirmative Action Essay

884 words - 4 pages Affirmative Action Angelia Malone MGT 434 August 29, 2011 Jeff Herring

Creating and Affirmative Action Plan

810 words - 4 pages reverse discrimination. Creating an affirmative action plan is a huge undertaking and must be implemented with great care to ensure it’s effectiveness. By examining job analysis, recruiting and human resource policies and constructing them in such a way so they complement affirmative action an effective affirmative action plan can be created. References Eisaguirre, L. (1999). Affirmative action a reference handbook. Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO, Inc. Sample affirmative action program. (n.d.). Retrieved March 12, 2010 from ofccp/regs/compliance/pdf/sampleaap.pdf

Affirmative Action

969 words - 4 pages “A Question of Fairness” Ladies Home Jorunal, March 1996, p 17-20. Boston, Thomas. “Ready, Aim, Fire” Black Enterprise. March 1996, p 24. Chappell, Kevin. “What They Don’t Tell You About Affirmative Action” Ebony August 1995, p 6-12. “Clinton’s Focus on Diversity” U.S. News and World Report. March 20, 1995, p. 42. Cooper, Matthew. “Affirmative Action on Ever

Affirmative Action

913 words - 4 pages Tanner Wallace RHT 101-002 Essay 2: Explaining a Concept Mr. Miller Affirmative Action The United States is not as united as it would like to think. One such program in place that is dividing the nation is Affirmative Action. Ever since it’s original introduction into American public policy, Affirmative Action has stirred up fierce debate. Offering up preferential treatment to those minority groups that have had social oppression

An Analysis of the Supreme Court Case: Fisher V. University of Texas

1808 words - 8 pages :// [ 11 ]. [ 12 ]. Affirmative action is a federal agenda designed to counteract historic discrimination faced by ethnic minorities, women and other underrepresented groups. To foster diversity and compensate for the ways such groups have historically been excluded, institutions with affirmative action programs prioritize the

Affirmative Action and Racial Tension

1815 words - 8 pages possib! ly swing back to where we started(³Going, Going... 12). Some believe animosity will still breed until a happy medium is attained, and until the nation¹s goal is met, some advise affirmative action might effectively exist with a number of strict limitations. There are also those who believe affirmative action has some of the most negative effects. Irvine and Goulden quote Booker T. Washington at the closing of their article as saying, ³No

Affirmative Action

1155 words - 5 pages (1987), in which the defiantly racist Alabama Department of Public Safety refused to promote any black above entry level even after a full 12 years of court orders demanded they did. The Supreme Court justices have been divided in their opinions in affirmative action cases, partially because of opposing political ideologies but also because the issue is simply so complex. The Court has approached most of the cases in a piecemeal fashion, focusing on

Case Study Analysis

913 words - 4 pages =w&asid=add3cb0dbe0680c3f0e2fac17b6d838f Byars, L. L., and Rue, L. W. (2008).  Human Resource Management: A Strategic Function. (9th ed.).  Retrieved from University of Phoenix eBook Collection database. Edley, C.,Jr. (1996, Sep). Affirmative action angst: Contemplating campus policy after hopwood v. texas. Change, 28, 12. Retrieved from Kier, F. J., & Davenport, D. S. (1997

Affirmative Action - 1404 words

1404 words - 6 pages Module 4 Case Discrimination and Affirmative Action Affirmative Action programs started in the 1960’s when President John F. Kennedy signed an Executive Order which required federal contractor’s to “take affirmative action” to ensure that applicant’s are employed without regard to their race, creed, color, or national origin. Lyndon B. Johnson extended that Executive Order to include women in 1967. Under

Affirmative Action-Opinion Paper

1124 words - 5 pages Affirmative action is meant to be an attempt at equality throughout society. It supposedly proposes that each person receive equal opportunities in the classroom as well as the work force. Not only would this apply to minorities but to women as well. Every sector in America would be equal and unprejudiced - or so proponents say. On the other hand, adopting affirmative action would force many employers to replace hard-working employees with those

Related Essays

Affirmative Action Essay 13

702 words - 3 pages Affirmative Action Robert K. Miller, author of The Informed Argument, describes affirmative action as, “an active effort to help members of historically oppressed groups gain admission to American universities and entrance into a diverse range of jobs previously reserved for white males” (145). Miller also states that this was the thinking of the 1970s civil rights movements (144). Things have changed throughout these past 30 years

Affirmative Action Essay 1823 Words

1823 words - 8 pages Admissions: An Alternative To Affirmative Action?,” 1022. [ 11 ]. “Issues in Race and Ethnicity,” 128. [ 12 ]. Long, “Race And College Admissions: An Alternative To Affirmative Action?,” 1025. [ 13 ]. Affirmative Action: Overview.” [ 14 ]. Olivas, "Legal Norms in Law School Admissions: An Essay on Parallel Universes," 114. [ 15 ]. Olivas, "Legal Norms in Law School Admissions: An Essay on Parallel Universes," 114. [ 17 ]. Gale Group, “Affirmative Action,” Affirmative Action Facts and Information, accessed December 5th, 2013, [ 18 ]. Gale Group, “Affirmative Action.”

Affirmative Action In The Workplace Essay

976 words - 4 pages . Read more: Morgan Hamilton offers expert advice and great tips regarding all aspects concerning lifestyles. Learn more at * Affirmative Action - PROS AND CONS, THE ORIGINS OF, LEGAL TREATMENT OF, POLITICAL AND SOCIAL DEBATES, THE FUTURE

Affirmative Action         Some Of Americas Most Historic Amendments And Court

975 words - 4 pages action requirements to benefit women. The end result is what we define affirmative action as today: the set of public policies and initiatives designed to help eliminate past and present discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, or national origin. Walter E. Williams, writer of the essay "Affirmative action can't be mended" develops the thesis that "affirmative action , in the forum of racial preference , has worn out its