Advantages Of Bilingualism Essay

2376 words - 10 pages

EDPROFST 226: Introduction to Bilingualism and Bilingual Immersion Education

Assignment One:

In his book, Language, Power and Pedagogy: bilingual children in the crossfire, Cummins (2000) tells a story of a bilingual Mexican mother who was ordered by a judge to stop speaking Spanish to her daughter during a custody dispute with her husband. The judge’s view was that the mother was ‘abusing’ her daughter by speaking Spanish in their home (p.13). Unfortunately the judge is not alone in his opinion in regards to second language acquisition and bilingualism. Nor is the context of America and the minority language of Spanish different from the New Zealand context in the way that minority ...view middle of the document...

“Being Bilingual”
Bilingualism is difficult to define because ‘bilingualism is an extremely complex phenomenon – one that may vary widely among individuals, and even within individuals with respect to the languages concerned’ (May, Hill, Tiakiwai, 2004, p.8). Early definitions of bilingualism ranged from being able to ‘produce meaningful utterances (however limited) in the other language’ (Haugen, 1953 in May, Hill, Tiakiwai, 2004, p.10) to bilingualism as ‘native like control of two languages’ (Bloomfield, 1935: 56 in May, Hill, Tiakiwai, 2004, p.10). Much of this research looked at bilingualism from a deficit point of view ‘bilingualism was seen as being atypical, while monolingualism was regarded as the norm’ (May, Hill, Tiakiwai, 2004, p.36). More recent research has highlighted different forms of bilingualism including: Passive bilinguals who understand but do not speak another language, Active bilinguals who are speakers, and often, readers and writers (McCaffery, 2010). Bilingual is usually a term that is associated with the ability to be fluent in two languages however the term is used differently depending on the context. In an educational context Gibbons (1991) uses the term bilingual to ‘reflect the reality that second language learners are operating in two language domains’ (p.1) to avoid deficit labelling and focus attention on the ‘potential language skills of these children’ (p.1).

Key theories: SUP vs CUP, Interdependence Hypothesis and Threshold Theory.
Separate Underlying Proficiency or SUP was used to support much of the early research about bilingualism. Baker and Prys Jones (1998 in May, Hill, Tiakiwai, 2004, p.37) explain that is the view of the mind as having two balloons within which languages are stored separately. As well as being separate the balloons also have limited storage capacity and therefore work against one another competing for space. This model is now outdated as recent research (post 1960) revealed that acquisition of a second language increases a child’s knowledge of language, ‘when children continue to develop their abilities in two or more languages throughout their primary school years, they gain deeper understanding of language and how to use it effectively’ (Cummins, 2002:61 in May, Hill, Tiakiwai, 2004, p.37).
Common Underlying Proficiency or CUP also known, as the Iceberg Analogy is a theory introduced by Vygotsky and later developed by Cummins (1980). It separates the two languages on the surface but underneath the languages are joined because they do not function separately from one another. Both languages make a contribution through access and usage through one processing system (May, Hill, Tiakiwai, 2004, p.37). Baker (2001 p.165-166 in May, Hill, Tiakiwai, 2004, p. 37) summarises the CUP model of Bilingualism into six parts including, one integrated source of thought irrespective of the language the person is using. People can store and function in two or more languages with...

Other Papers Like Advantages of Bilingualism

Effects of Bilingualism on the Brain

1076 words - 5 pages Did you know that being proficient in more than one language could help a person focus? Neuroscience has been able to show that learning more than one language can give a person various advantages over people who are only proficient in one language. Studies have shown that people who are proficient in a second language have an increased amount of gray matter in specific areas of the brain associated with language and communication skills

Code Switching Annotated Article Essay

3665 words - 15 pages perfect example of the meaning of the word/s itself. Switching languages can mean a variety of things. As the articles I annotate below indicate, language switching can occur without notice, between dialects of a language, between different languages, and so on. Due to its broadness, it is important to focus on a topic of interest when researching code switching. I decided to focus on the advantages and benefits that Code Switching provides

“Endangered Languages Should Be Saved?” Discuss, Including Both the Advantages and Disadvantages of This Proposal

636 words - 3 pages from academics, politicians, institutions and organisations worldwide. The aim of this essay is to consider some advantages and disadvantages of saving minority languages. The main advantage of saving minority languages is that it allows preserving the intellectual and cultural diversity of the planet. The community itself must want to save its language because every language is a part of the human culture and story. The culture of which it is


1045 words - 5 pages 4. Outline the arguments for and against the policy of multiculturalism. What are the advantages and disadvantages of officially promoting multiculturalism? 4. Outline the arguments for and against the policy of multiculturalism. What are the advantages and disadvantages of officially promoting multiculturalism? Background Multiculturalism in Canada is the ideology that all people have equal opportunities and rights regardless of

The Effect of L1 in Elt

1623 words - 7 pages In the name of God Rahele Title: observation in bilingual classroom Abstract: Bilingualism became a crucial matter and is a very essential subject for research these days. The purpose of this article is to report how much L1 is used by the teacher in classroom? In what cases they use it? and why? I will start my discussion by presenting an introduction, this will followed by the methodology in which I


1186 words - 5 pages school system and to be government funded so all students have an equal education, since Spanish will help students to communicate clearly and bilingualism opens the door to more job opportunities. Education is a long-term process, which involves much more than just the English language. As vital as this trait is, just knowing English will not do much for you unless it is coupled with the knowledge of other subjects. There are a lot of

Child and Adolescent Development essay

3779 words - 16 pages types of bilingual children are the Simultaneous Bilingualism and the Sequential Bilingualism The term balanced bilingualism is used to describe individuals who possess about the same fluency in two languages, while semilingualism refers to those who have deficiencies in both languages compared with monolinguals. There are cog native advantages of Bilingualism. It does not impact on early language milestones like babbling. Also in bilingual homes

Position of English as a Global Language: Political and Cultural Factors

2157 words - 9 pages Singaporean population now consists of approximately 77% Chinese, 14% Malay, and 8% Indian, which consequently shows great diversity in ethnic origin; this diversity creating the need for bilingualism (Fetterley 707). Bilingualism in Singapore shows the extent to which the English language has developed into a world language through cultural and political factors both historically and contemporary. English in Singapore is associated with economic

Clil Assignment

1801 words - 8 pages CLIL is one of the best measures in order to strengthen the learning of a foreign language. It will not only complement the sessions devoted to the formal study of that language, but also it will provide a meaningful learning. 6. Bibliography [1] Coyle, D., Hoo, P. & Marsh, D. (2010). CLIL: Content and Language Integrated Language. Cambridge University Press [2] Cummins, J., Swaim, M. (1986). Bilingualism in Education. Longman [3] Krashen, S.D., Tracy, D. Terrell (1983). The Natural Approach: Language acquisition in the classroom. Alemany Press. Hayward, CA. [4] Short, D. (1993) Assessing integrated language and content instruction, TESOL Quarterly

Assessors Assignment

3894 words - 16 pages Discrimination, Risk Assessment, and Lone Working. 21 Explain the contribution that technology can make to the assessment process. There are advantages in the use of technology for assessment, like more frequent formative and summative assessment, the assessors can be alerted sooner to adapt assessment methods, assessor can spend less time marking. Learners can Self-assess in their ‘own time’ at their pace when they are ready, this would hopefully

Freedom And Responsibility

2141 words - 9 pages Built within the Constitution of the United States are specifically defined freedoms that are guaranteed to all citizens. Conversely, with every constitutional freedom there comes a corresponding responsibility. On September 25, 1789, the state legislature’s twelve proposed amendments were transmitted by congress, the first two dealing with congressional representation and congressional pay. The following numbers three through twelve were

Related Essays

Does Bilingualism Improve Brain Function? Essay

3150 words - 13 pages 20 years have long-established Peal and Lambert's pioneer findings concerning the cognitive advantages of balanced bilinguals. When placed side by side with individuals who speak only one language, individual children that are bilingual show clear leads on the measurements of metalinguistic awareness, symbolic development, concept formation, divergent-thinking skills and field independence. Bilingualism promotes a certain degree of "cognitive

Bilingual Educatio Essay

1305 words - 6 pages native language. Dual bilingual helps children to develop their native language. Children accrue benefits through bilingualism; advantages of bilingual education include; Cognitive advantages, bilingualism is an important factor of cognitive development (Peal and Lambert, 1962), “bilingual children are more responsive at concept formation and posses great mental flexibility.” Research has shown that children

Deafness A A Culture Essay

654 words - 3 pages ways to communicate while integrating English and they are: cued speech, total communication, and bilingualism. Cued speech advantages include distinguishing similar words that look alike from lip reading, easy to learn only talking a twenty hours or so, English speaking parents can bypass useless beginning phrases, and nothing has to be lost in translation. The disadvantages of cued speech include parents need to learn ASL which could take months

Bilingual Essay

2760 words - 12 pages . But early and late bilinguals show similar advantages in executive function if it irrespective duration of habitual use of two languages. After the tests, the results showed that late bilinguals actually performed like early bilinguals, in both lexical access deficits and executive function benefits. These findings also provided support for the hypothesis that cognitive effects associated with bilingualism arise as the result of proficient and