This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Abstract Ideas: Locke Vs. Berkeley Essay

954 words - 4 pages

In the following paper I will present and analyze John Locke's position on the nature of general terms. I will do so by breaking down his position and then through the criticisms presented by George Berkeley will unveil more about the nature of general terms.In Locke's An Essay Concerning Human Understanding he discusses the nature of general terms. For this, Locke defines a general term as that which is used as sorter, putting entities into groups or categories such as that which refer to shape, or color. This definition is clearer when it is juxtaposed with a singular term, which is defined as a term that refers to a particular entity such as a proper name. Locke believes that general ...view middle of the document...

Because of this nature of individual existence, general terms do not purport to anything in the world.Understanding of this concept is made clearer once Locke's notion of what an idea is is understood. For Locke, an idea is a notion or term of that which the mind can be employed to think with. Words stand for ideas in the minds of speakers / language users.Although this seems strange because words do not stand for ideas, but rather they stand for things in world, this is the position Locke holds. Further, being an empiricist Locke believes that ideas are copies of sense perceptions, or impressions of a sense experience. This faculty comes in the form of pictures or linguistics. From this definition of ideas coupled with his account of general terms, it seems to show how general terms have come to acquire meaning.Berkeley's criticism of Locke deals with Locke's idea of the abstraction of particular qualities from individuals, which leads to general ideas and ultimately general terms. Berkeley argues that Locke's account of abstract ideas is indeterminate, inconsistent and incoherent. He states that on Locke's picture, when one is sorting individuals into groups, after he has a data set, he looks for similarities and differences and than separates out those non-relevant qualities and what is left is the general idea of 'man'. However, an image of such a 'man' is indeterminate, for it is impossible to form an image of a man that is not determinate. For any man that one can imagine must be black or white, short or tall, young or...

Other Papers Like Abstract Ideas: Locke Vs. Berkeley

Philosophy Essay

1784 words - 8 pages . Prominent rationalists, including Descartes, Spinoza and Leibniz, argue that one must rely on reason as a purely deductive process to attain justified truths about reality (Cottingham 1988). In contrast, empiricists, including Locke, Berkeley and Hume, argue that knowledge is derived from the role of experience and sense data to formulate ideas. The question of what is the ideal foundation of knowledge is still debatable to date. I will argue that the

Knowledge Through Experience Essay

1083 words - 5 pages tablet”. This idea was further developed by philosophers such as Avicenna, who explained that the tabula rasa is something that is formed through education, and that knowledge can be obtained through “empirical familiarity” with just random objects around the world and is usually developed with a logical method of reasoning in which observing could lead to propositional statements which when put together could possibly lead to even more abstract

Nature vs Nurture

1631 words - 7 pages the late 1700s, the nature vs. nurture debate began to heat up between philosophers. Internalists (nature) and empiricists (nurture) wrote literature back and forth trying to prove their beliefs and disprove the other theories. Two philosophers, G.W. Leibniz and John Locke, were the main representatives of their respected explanations. Leibniz promoted the externalism point of view. Cowie states, "...Leibniz's position on this issue is, of course

Introduction to Philosophy: Beliefs and Truth for a Person

589 words - 3 pages that a person gains truth from experience. 2. When a person is born, they know nothing, but as they move throughout life, they gain knowledge and seek the truth. 3. George Berkeley- believed experience was source of knowledge but only perceptions are experienced and people only experience ideas. 4. Material things just clusters of ideas and people never have direct experience with things themselves. Things exist continually. III. Reality

Cognistic Theory of Learning

2266 words - 10 pages pioneers theorists like John Locke, David Hume, and James Mill. John Locke is amongst the most eminent. The idea of classical associationism introduced pairing stimulation with thoughts or ideas in order for animals or humans to learn from their environment. Behaviorism is the link that is needed for the association between mental states and perceptual experiences or stimulations. Behaviorism was the school of psychology that sought after explaining


684 words - 3 pages Frankenstein interest you most as you read it; for example you might be particularly drawn to the monster’s development, the relationship between Victor and Walton, Victor and the monster, the role of women, the nature vs. nurture debate, the importance of companionship, or the role of nature in the book. Here are some topic ideas that you may choose if you would like to connect the novel to outside sources: 1) Psychology/Identity formation

Allstate Insurance Company

1072 words - 5 pages “Allstate Insurance Company” Ersin CELIK Dr. Hammad ELBEDOUR BUS 520 Leadership and Organizational 10/11/2011 ABSTRACT In this assignment, First of all, I try to appraise Allstate’s goal setting progress to figure out whether or not Allstate has an effective goal-setting program. Secondly, I mentioned

Natural Rights Movement

2182 words - 9 pages state of society, they cannot, by any compact, deprive their posterity; namely, the enjoyment of life and liberty, with the means of acquiring and possessing property, and pursuing and obtaining happiness and safety. “ In 1776, another fellow Virginian, Thomas Jefferson, greatly influenced by John Locke and his theory of rights, would incorporate these ideas in the Declaration of Independence. Jefferson wrote that, “ We hold these

Socialism vs Capitalism

2183 words - 9 pages increased individualism, which became a characteristic of the modern societies. Socialism Vs. Capitalism Over the years, there were many forms of the social organization, but the main ones are collectivism and individualism. According to the author Bradley Thomson (1993), collectivism in the twentieth century has taken many forms; one of them was socialism. He also states that the only social system that is common with individualism is

Adult Learning Theory

1805 words - 8 pages , reflections give rise to new ideas or modification of existing abstract concepts and finally AE learners apply this experience to the world around them (Kolb 1984, pp.30). Knowles’ andragogical model incorporates five assumptions where adult learners (1) possess independent and self- directed learning attitudes, (2) have work-related experience providing a rich resource for learning, (3) have learning needs closely related to social roles, (4) are

NovověKá Filozofie

2128 words - 9 pages 20 Novověká filozofie * 17.století v Evropě- dva hlavní myšlenkové směry racionalismus a empirismus * Racionalismus * máme vrozené ideje, poznáváme je rozumem * není možné poznání díky smyslům * ,,myslím, tedy jsem“ * Descartes, Spinoza, Leibniz * Empirismus * přicházíme na svět jako ,,tabula rasa“, bez jakýchkoliv předchozích vjemů- vše poznáváme na základě našich smyslů * Anglie- Locke, Hume

Related Essays

Philosophy Paper

1450 words - 6 pages own ideas and thoughts. We are the perceiver and we are all perceptions of God. (Schott) Berkeley argued against materialism because he denied the fact that matter could exist on its own but our ideas of the material object make the object exist. John Locke said that we experience the world through primary and secondary qualities. Our primary qualities are our perceptions and our secondary qualities are the physical properties in the object

Economical Philosophy Essay

1679 words - 7 pages Yaw Ankobiah Essay Assignment 4/17/15 POLS 251 Professor Clarke Word Count: 1,597 The Ideals of Commerce of Aristotle vs. John Locke Aristotle and John Locke are two of the more prominent philosophers of their respective time periods when historically analyzing political philosophy. Each philosopher has many written sources of their beliefs and ideals, many of which go against the ‘norms’ of the societies of their time period. Second

A History Of Modern Psychology Essay

930 words - 4 pages mind’s powers are supreme according to Descartes. He believed that the body could have an influence on the mind; however, the mind is superior to the body. ("Understanding Learners", n.d.). John Locke founded the study of human knowledge and its acquisition. Locke rejected the concept of innate ideas. Locke believed that all of human knowledge comes from the world and the experiences that people have. John Locke believed that the interaction

John Locke Essay

1511 words - 7 pages that all aspects of it can be grasped through mathematical and logical principles, and not simply through sensory experience. The most famous rationalists were Descartes and Spinoza. Empiricism is a philosophical perspective to counter the rationalism of the 17th century. Empiricists were philosophers who felt that everything in our mind comes from our experience through the senses. They heavily critiqued the rationalists. Locke, Berkeley and Hume