This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Abortion And Utilitarianism Essay

713 words - 3 pages

Abortion is a widely controversial topic, which can be viewed from many different perspectives and moral theories. I will primarily concentrate on Judith Thomson’s view of defending abortion and provide further insight on her stance as it pertains to Sarah’s case. As well, I will also approach Sarah’ case from Susan Sherwin’s perspective and input aspects of my own opinions to support Sherwin’s argument.
Judith Thomson claims in her article that women should have the right to choose to having an abortion under the assumption that personhood begins at the moment of conception (Thomson, 152). Common arguments for abortion come from the idea that personhood does not begin right at ...view middle of the document...

She would have to sacrifice majority of her academic career if she were to proceed with the pregnancy. Moreover, with respect to care ethics, Sarah is potentially jeopardizing her relationship with her boyfriend if the pregnancy is not terminated since they have not deliberated about having a marriage or raising a family (Warren, 147).
According to Sherwin, it would be morally adequate for Sarah to terminate her pregnancy. This situation plays perfectly into Sherwin’s argument that ready access to abortion supports women’s independence by allowing Sarah to continue with her doctorate degree, as well as continuing to work as a teaching assistant without having to be interrupted in her educational career. I would also argue that in terms of the utilitarianism perspective, Sarah and her boyfriend would be at the greatest benefit if she terminates her pregnancy because it would allow them to finish their educational career, and would not have to be interrupted in their future profession to bring a child into their lives.
Furthermore, utilitarianism would support the couple’s decision to have the pregnancy...

Other Papers Like Abortion and Utilitarianism

Abortion Is Seriously Wrong Essay

1640 words - 7 pages or unhealthy women, and for women who may have been molested or raped. Abortion shouldn’t be used as a form of contraception, nor should women’s lives be sacrificed to bear an infant before morally ready to commit. If a woman is raped, and the outcome incurs pregnancy, then abortion is an alternate form of controlling the unwanted pregnancy. Abortion should stand as only the woman’s choice, never as a decision adverse to Pro-Life activists. Pro

Ethics in Business Essay

629 words - 3 pages , utilitarianism, and deontological theories. How a person reacts to a situation will be based on a particular ethical theory. Virtue ethics places less focus on the act, but on the agent. If a person subscribes to the virtue ethics theory, they will be acting in a good and moral manner like being honest. Virtue ethic oriented people also believe that not only should a person act morally in their dealings, but actively correct negative behaviors

Jeremy Bentham

1115 words - 5 pages Bentham’s utilitarianism (30 Marks) Throughout this essay I will be explaining the aspects of Jeremy Bentham’s theory of utilitarianism. We can divide his theory into three parts; 1. Motivation- this was Bentham’s view on what drove human beings, and what goodness and badness really meant. 2. Utility- This was from the Latin word ‘Utilis’ meaning ‘useful’. This was his moral rule. 3. Hedonic Calculus- This is Bentham’s system

Explain How a Follower of Natural Law Theory Might Approach the Issue Surrounding Abortion

2242 words - 9 pages a) Explain how a follower of Natural Law theory might approach the issue surrounding abortion. The Natural Law Theory has developed over time since the era of the ancient Greeks, and it is not necessarily based on one single theory. Natural law is the belief that God has created the universe to work in certain ways. The structure of Natural Law is not accidental; it is deliberate and has important implications to the human race (this can

Pro Live vs. Pro Choice

686 words - 3 pages The choice between life and loss has been a battle on this earth for quite some time. Many will say that life is initiated at conception rather than when a baby receives first breath at birth. These people are usually pro-choice when it comes to abortion. It is usually perceived by them that to destroy an embryo, fetus or zygote is the equivalent of killing a living being. From this ethical utilitarianism standpoint any annihilation is

Natural Law Religious Studies

865 words - 4 pages consequentialist theories such as Situation Ethics or Utilitarianism which give them a greater sense of moral autonomy, rather than Natural Law’s absolutist, deontological approach. For example, abortion is almost always wrong in Natural Law, unless the mother’s life is in danger (double effect), then the Catholic Church will allow abortion to take place. Another example that is wrong under Natural Law is the use of condoms, condoms are forbidden by the


1245 words - 5 pages and therefore are only expressions of emotion. However, there are a few problems with Ayer's argument. Just because something is morally justifiable, such as abortion, doesn't mean that we passionately support its practice as he suggests in ‘Hurrah-boo theory' as well as this, this argument is self-refuting. It claims that "Any genuine truth claim must be able to be tested by sense experience." But this claim itself can't be tested by sense

Ethical and Dilemma Iss in Professions

997 words - 4 pages Travis Marcel April 20, 2013 Eth & Legal Iss in Professions Prof. Ethical dilemmas or moral dilemmas are certain situations where there are two decisions to be made, neither which fairly resolves the situation in an ethically acceptable fashion. In some cases, the society and the personal ethical guidelines can provide us with no satisfactory outcome from the chooser. When put in these ethical dilemmas it’s assumed that the chooser

“Virtue Ethics Is Of Little Use When Dealing With Practical Ethics.” Discuss

1557 words - 7 pages suggests that the idea of Eudaimonia which does not depend on any God. Anscombe also suggested that Kantian ethics and Utilitarianism do not depend on God, but they are still act based. Anscombe thought that act based ethics do not make sense because it ignores a belief that people no longer hold and therefore virtue ethics is better when dealing with practical ethics. Also according to the principle of autonomy it neglects the community aspect of

Ethics of Euthanasia

1574 words - 7 pages paradigm, and use them interchangeably. The objective of this paper is to outline two ethical theories, utilitarianism and Kantianism, in regards to the concept of euthanasia and bring about the questions of morality that are still in debate. Initially, I would like to address the current ethical dilemma within the United States, and bring up the questions of morality that are being discussed. One of the greatest controversies surrounding the issue

Corporate Contributions to Political Campaigns

3047 words - 13 pages abortion for the time they are in office and the company can continue to turn a profit selling their product. The utilitarianism point of view I believe is the best view point on this subject because with any logical view on the elections anyone can see that the corporation in America provide a lot of the support towards a certain style of politics whether it be conservative or liberal. The news corporations have to be the biggest political

Related Essays

Utilitarianism Essay

1347 words - 6 pages Utilitarianism’ such as having an abortion because of financial pressures, family member’s needs and work can all be justified under the ‘Hedonic calculus’ In conclusion, Preference Utilitarianism is a more personal form of Utilitarianism, which contrasts with ‘Act and Rule Utilitarianism’. For example an act Utilitarian judges right and wrong according to the maximisation of pleasure and minimisation of pain, a Rule Utilitarian judges right or wrong

Abortion Essay

1769 words - 8 pages considered in regards to an abortion, so the have no say in whether a women can have an abortion , but half of the baby is equally the fathers and therefor the father the father should have a say. As a result many men are left unhappy for example Kevin Wilson physically attacked his ex girlfriend by kicking her pregnant stomach to kill the unborn child as he has no rights. The Quality of Life also links to Utilitarianism, described by original

How Fair Is The Judgment That Bentham’s Utilitarianism Is A ‘Pig Philosophy’ Or ‘Swine Ethic.’ (10 Marks)

611 words - 3 pages pleasure for the greatest number of people. This is degrading humans viewing them as animals that focus mainly on the needs of the majority whether even if the minority is morally approved. An example of this will be abortion. Bentham’s theory will support the act of abortion. According to his theory the majority will receive pleasure through the abortion of an unborn. The pregnant women might have conceived the unborn by an accident. If the woman and

Ethics Of Abortion Essay

1945 words - 8 pages is right when and only when the mother’s life is at risk. And others think that there is a range of different circumstances that make abortion morally acceptable. In this paper I will present the issue of abortion, explain the three classical theories of utilitarianism, deontology and virtue ethics on how to solve the issue and contrast this response with the perspective brought to the issue of abortion by ethical egoism. I will also present you