This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

A Review On Group Based Projects

5094 words - 21 pages

A Review on Group Based Projects
by Andrea Gallo

Poole and Bournemouth College 2012
FdA Business and Management – Year 1
Introduction to Management
Lecturer: Peter Matthews

Table of Contents

Review on Group Based Projects 3
Introduction 3
Theories on Group Development 3
Questions 4
Conclusion 4
Personal Reflection on Group Development 5
Introduction 5
Orientation 5
Conflict 5
Emergence 5
Reinforcement 6
Conclusion 6
Appendix 7
History of Group Dynamics as a Field of Research 7
Theories and Models of Group Development 7
Tuckman's Group Development Model 8
Further Developments 9
Fisher’s Decision Emergence Theory 9
Kolb’s Learning Cycle 11
...view middle of the document...

Group dynamics also focuses on individuals. Its vital element is trust among members so they can express feelings and reactions. (Thomson, 2002). Team dynamics effects are often complex and may affect members performance, satisfaction and group effectiveness.
Tuckman produced one of the most influential theories on group development. Extensive part of his published work was broadly related to educational research and psychology. Although theories showed differences concerning number and names of stages, many researchers adopted either Tuckman's (1965) four stage model - forming, storming, norming and performing or Tuckman and Jensen’s (1977) that added a fifth stage – adjourning (Smith, 2005).
Fisher (1970) also based his research on the conviction that all groups go through similar stages before reaching agreement, sharing a common life cycle. His research defined eight statements, verbal acts that occurred at various times during group’s life cycles. The interaction of these statements formed Fisher’s four phase sequences of decision emergence: orientation, conflict, emergence and reinforcement (Griffin, 2009).
Tuckman’s and Fisher’s four stages are linear and follow a pattern:
* Initial stage of getting acquainted and understanding objectives;
* Formation of grounds and start of divergences;
* Bonding phase, commitment towards a common goal;
* Final stage where group reaches a conclusion.
Though, unlike Tuckman, Fisher built his theory based on facts, rather than speculation, on how groups actually progress, not on how it ought to happen. Furthermore, for Fisher, verbal interaction defined how the group evolved, not the combination of personalities involved in the process (Griffin, 2009). Although Tuckman’s model is more widely used, Fisher seems to be more in touch with reality, hence the model recommended for group tasks.
Questions
In comparison to Fisher’s theory is feasible to analyse the criticism on Tuckman’s theory for denoting a goal rather than a description of reality (Seeger, 1983) and not making clear delimitations, leaving an overlap between the stages (Smith, 2005).
Another question was raised on Tuckman’s research for being based on students, patients undergoing psychotherapy or trainees, bringing up reservation on whether the group behaviours of the subjects were truly reflective of normal group development (Herbert and Trist, 1953).
There is also criticism on the limitation on existing group development theories as they focus on foreseeable, despite perception of the unforeseeable aspects that may impact the task. Unexpected events can strongly influence how teams react, behave or perform (Buchanan and Huczynski, 2010). 
Irrespective to criticisms, knowing what to expect in normal group development allows leaders to anticipate a team’s evolution, plan for conflicts and develop new strategies to keep focus on reaching targets. Moreover, by understanding adversity and...

Other Papers Like A Review on Group Based Projects

A Reflective Essay Based on an Episode of Patient Care

1294 words - 6 pages A reflective essay based on an episode of patient care. rodrigo | December 3, 2012 Introduction This is a reflective essay based on an episode of care that I was directly involved in managing during a community placement. This episode of care will be analysed using up to date references, health care policies and relevant models. Issues and theories relating to leadership qualities and management styles will also be explored, taking into

Superstition: A Credulous Belief Not Based on Reason or Knowledge

1390 words - 6 pages Superstition From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia (Redirected from Superstitious beliefs) Jump to: navigation, search For other uses, see Superstition (disambiguation). Clay hamsa on a wall, believed to protect the inhabitants of the house from harm Superstition is a credulous belief or notion, not based on reason or knowledge. The word is often used pejoratively to refer to folk beliefs deemed irrational, which is appropiate since

A Model Of Service Classification Based On Consumer Needs

3546 words - 15 pages A Model of Service Classification Based on Consumer Needs Service Operations Management Track FARIAS PEREIRA , Suzana Carla Doctoral student at Fundação Getúlio Vargas/EAESP Department of Administration of the Production and Operations CATTINI , Orlando Jr. Professor of Fundação Getúlio Vargas/EAESP Department of Administration of the Production and Operations Abstract Most of the literature and research on services focus on the

Designing a Speed Control System of a Dc Motor Based on Pid Algorithm Using Matlab Simulink

527 words - 3 pages Designing a Speed Control system of a DC motor based on PID algorithm using MATLAB SIMULINK DC motors have variable characteristics and are used extensively in variable-speed drives. DC motor can provide a high starting torque and it is also possible to obtain speed control over wide range. Why do we need a speed motor controller? For example, if we have a DC motor in a robot and we just apply a constant power to each motor on a robot

Mgmt 591 Discussion: Comparing on-Line Class to a Team/Group

734 words - 3 pages Comparison of On-line Class to a Team MGMT 591 Keller In this response I will discuss social loafing, group development and comparing our class to a team or group. Social loafing occurs when people work less hard in groups than they would individually. An effective team/group according to the text is one that achieves a high level of task performance, member satisfaction and team viability. One of the Keller student mottos: "you get out

Summary and Lit Review of a Study on Early Intervention

1377 words - 6 pages to age 3 years; and the effects of the Healthy Steps program, among others. Five of the twenty-eight references were also written by DB Bailey. The study’s references focusing on IEP/ISPs for children with physical disabilities were not within the five year time frame. Methods Bailey et al.’s 2005 study was based on a large and nationally representative sample of families of children with disabilities. Data came from a single forty minute

A Review On How To Prevent Organization Dryrot

717 words - 3 pages A Review of How to Prevent Organizational Dry Rot A Review of How to Prevent Organizational Dry Rot Change has come a way life for most large organizations. As John Gardner described it, “Like people and plants, organizations have a life cycle. They have a green and supple youth, a time of flourishing strength, and a gnarled old age . . . An organization can go from you to old age in two or three decades, or it it may last centuries

A review on Gates of Fire - Steven Pressfield

1195 words - 5 pages A review on Gates of Fire - Steven Pressfield In 480 BC the Persian Empire was once again trying to invade ancient Greece. Under the reign of King Xerxes, an invincible army of a recorded 2 million was marching downwards to enslave all Greeks. An elite force of three hundred Spartans tackled the suicide mission of stalling the Persian wave of doom. They fought in the narrows of Thermopylae and held on for 6 days, ultimately being forced

Should The U.S. Return To A Monetary Policy Based On The Gold Standard?

1575 words - 7 pages wasted little time severing its ties to gold. Britain left the gold standard in 1930's (Davies, 1996). In the early 1970's, a diminishing gold supply and growing deficits caused the U.S. to suspend the gold standard even for international trade. Since then, international trade has been based solely on the dollar and other paper currencies. Today, there are no mainstream economists who call for a return to the gold standard.So why bring it back

Review Of Article "Asymmetric Reactions To Work Group Sex Diversity Among Men And Women" Written By Jennifer A. Chatman And Charles A. O'reilly

1476 words - 6 pages identified that the likelihood of transferring from current work group is greater by women in female-dominated groups than by men in male-dominated groups. This directed them to think which factors indicate the presence/absence of gender diversity. On the basis of a categorization scheme, four categories were made - Homogeneous, Same Sex Dominates, Balanced and Other Sex dominates. In this manner, they hypothesized that factors like Work group

Scientific Review Of A Journal Related To The Discovery Of Arsenic-Based Dna In A Particular Strain Of Bacteria, Published In December 2010

973 words - 4 pages In December 2010, a published article related to the discovery of arsenic-based DNA in a particular strain of bacteria, gave rise to a lot of hype and in many cases, overstated deductions. Although many seem to concur with the conclusions which this research put forward, others have found the procedure used, unreliable and flawed. Such research and discoveries are of utmost importance since they provide better understanding of life, yet the more

Related Essays

A Research Assignment Based On: ‘Laptop Revolution’

1223 words - 5 pages A Research Assignment based on: ‘Laptop Revolution’ by Professor Abdul Bayes (Published in ‘The Daily Star’ on 10th February, 2010) Prepared by: Khosnur Jahan Asmaul Husna Madia Sultana Hasanul Qader Mirza Hasib Kaisar Prepared for: Md. Safayat Hossain Lecturer Department of A & IS University of Dhaka Group Members: | Name | ID no. | 01. | Khosnur Jahan | 13092 | 02. | Asmaul Husna | 13093 | 03. | Madia

A Christian Theory Based On Maslow

632 words - 3 pages intellectual nature. Based on these truths I have patterned my theory after Maslow’s Theory of Self-Actualization. My theory is entitled A Christian Theory of the Order of Mankind’s Spiritual Needs, which I have outlined in steps below. 1. Physiological Needs - Matthew 19:14, NIV. “Jesus said, Let the children come to me and do not hinder them, for the kingdom of heaven belongs to such as these.” Bible believing parents teach and

A Review Paper On Population

538 words - 3 pages A Review Paper on Population Introduction A population is a summation of all the organisms of the same group or species, which live in a particular geographical area, and have the capability of interbreeding. In sociology, population refers to a collection of humans. And overpopulation is an undesirable condition where the number of existing human population exceeds the carrying capacity of Earth. According to Snider & Brimlow (2013

Outline The Fundamental Essentials Of An Action Based On Judicial Review

598 words - 3 pages Outline the fundamental essentials of an action based on judicial review Judicial review is a type of court proceeding in which a judge reviews the lawfulness of a decision or action made by a public body. It is a challenge to the way in which a decision has been made. It is not really concerned with the conclusions of that process, as long as the right procedures have been followed. The types of decision which may fall within the range of