A Review Of The Literature: Plea Bargaining And Ethics In The Criminal Justice System

1939 words - 8 pages

|
A Review of the Literature: Plea Bargaining and Ethics in the Criminal Justice System |
|
|

Plea bargaining is a significant portion of today’s criminal justice system. As Chief Justice Burger stated, “The disposition of criminal charges by agreement between the prosecutor and the accused, sometimes loosely called ‘plea bargaining,’ is an essential component of the administration of justice. Properly administered, it is to be encouraged” (Santobello v. New York, 1971). The practice of plea bargaining has generated thoughtful ethical debate with effective arguments on both sides. Prior to offering an opinion, an understanding and comparison of the points of view ...view middle of the document...

With implicit plea bargains, no compromise of leniency is assured by the prosecutor. This classification of plea bargaining merely suggests the possibility of leniency if there is a plea of guilty by the defendant (Bibas, 2011).
Reducing a sentence is included in charge bargaining, sentence bargaining, and count bargaining. Once the defense accepts the option of charge bargaining, they will propose a sentence reduction to the prosecution and/or magistrate in return for a guilty plea. Charge bargaining can produce extremely volatile public and political responses (Devers, 2011). If a defendant is initially charged with a felonious act, the acceptance of charge bargaining could result in a lowering of charges to a lesser misdemeanor offense. Sentence bargaining involves the trade of a guilty plea with the assurance of the prosecutor to request a lighter or alternative sentence, however, this agreement is not guaranteed. It is the presiding judge’s choice, after a thorough review of all the circumstances and facts, to approve or deny the request (Klein, 2006).
Encompassing both positive and negative features, sentence bargaining has the propensity to be seen as controversial (Smith, 1987). For instance, a defendant who is indicted for a capital offense, with the possibility of a death sentence, accepts a plea bargain that lessens their penalty to life in prison with the opportunity for parole (Scheidegger, 2009). This resulting plea can be interpreted by many as morally corrupt and a miscarriage of the judicial system to the victims and a reward to the criminal for simply acknowledging their guilt. Notwithstanding its adverse characteristic, sentence bargaining is an exceedingly significant portion of the system (Covey, 2013). This method of bargaining is advantageous in cases where the prosecution does not have a solid case to assure a conviction, or in the absence of sufficient evidence to meet the requirements for a death penalty case. The supporting argument is the use of sentence bargaining in capital cases guarantees the conviction and punishment of the defendant.
A suspect facing multiple charges could be offered an agreement designated as count bargaining. Particularly, a proposal is prepared to decrease the quantity of charges, customarily by dismissal if the offender agrees to plead guilty to the reduced charges. For example, an arrestee, indicted for several counts of possession of a controlled substance, is presented with a reduction to just one count in exchange for pleading guilty. This choice of bargaining results in a deceptive criminal history accompanied by a greatly abbreviated penalty (Bushway & Redlich, 2012). Count bargaining’s solitary benefit is its simplification of the case presented to the court.
This controversial topic embraces effective arguments by both of those who support and those who oppose the usage of plea bargaining (McConville, 1998). There are several urgings in...

Other Papers Like A Review of the Literature: Plea Bargaining and Ethics in the Criminal Justice System

Analysis of Racial Profiling in the Criminal Justice System

3273 words - 14 pages Analysis of Racial Profiling In the Criminal Justice System Police officers today face many challenges. Some concerns include dangers or safety concerns related to being a police officer, questions of the use of force and the public’s perception of officers being corrupt. Additionally, with cases of deaths and accusations that have come to the forefront about police throughout the United Stated, questions about police racial profiling have

Overview of the Criminal Justice System

838 words - 4 pages judge has the final say in any proceeding or ruling”. Conclusion In conclusion, there are many roles that bring the criminal justice system together. Without it there would be no justice for the victims of crime. The world would be one, big and lawless place. The police officers are just the beginning of this system but they work with a whole slew of other individuals that keep the system moving smoothly. No matter what part

Foundations of the Criminal Justice System

1272 words - 6 pages Criminal Justice System Shelby Goodwin Professor Debra Shiftlett-Picardi Foundations of the Criminal Justice System Search Warrant Issue Process and Fourth Amendment Requirements The Search Warrant is known as an order being written and issued from the officials of the court. The warrant bestows the officer full authority to find a person at a particular place while looking for particular objects and to take possession if objects

Failures Of The American Criminal Justice System

1936 words - 8 pages crime, while law abiding citizens find their taxpayer dollars being drained on an ineffective prison system. The segregation and injustice occurring in American prisons needs to come to a halt. In order to pursue the goals of Lady Justice and Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., less criminal offenders need to be imprisoned while more need to be placed in programs that will help them get on the right track. Many prisoners are in jail for minor and

Ethics in Criminal Justice

912 words - 4 pages Ethical Dilemma Andrew Cantrell CJA/324 Larry Avallone January 20, 2014   Abstract Ethical decisions and the way that the police department handle situations is an extreme issue. When an officer in the department is witness to brutality or unethical behavior it is their duty report the incident to the proper person within the department. Unethical Decision Made In July of 2007, Christopher Dorner was a police officer for Los

Ethics of Criminal Justice

1225 words - 5 pages Arrigo, p. 146) Intrinsic and instrumental goods share the same ultimate goal however, the difference between the two are visible. Intrinsic goods are things that bring happiness within us, as for instrumental goods are the things that are materialistic, and other categories such as honesty, and legal rights. For instant, the example of legal rights used in Ethics, Crime, and Criminal Justice by Christopher R. Williams on page 147 states, “It may

Ethics And Leadership In Criminal Justice

953 words - 4 pages Ethics and Leadership in Criminal Justice 1 Final Exam 1. Universal responsibility. I’d like to start out by defining the two.1. Universal-means of or pertaining to the universe, all nature, or all existing things. 2.Responsibility-to make one's actions and task their own, the willing acceptance of the consequences of my actions. Individuals, Institutions, Governments and

Racial Profiling in the U.S. Criminal Justice System

1045 words - 5 pages criminal justice system is a replication of racial profiling of the slavery era. Today, the black people are often viewed as suspects of drug possession among other crimes, which culminate in arrest, trial and conviction not necessarily on fair grounds. This claim is backed by several research findings on the prejudiced nature of the U.S. Criminal justice system in relation to minority groups. Hartley (2009) found that there are racial and ethnic

Cja384 Ethics in Criminal Justice

582 words - 3 pages the ability to properly address these issues. Benefits of Training (officers/community) A clear understanding of the ethical expectations of law enforcement officers will help the criminal justice system run smoothly because the responsibilities of officers will be known. There are serious conflicts and stressful scenarios that officers face in the criminal justice profession and a code of ethics will show them how to handle themselves in these

Victimology and Criminal Justice System

2211 words - 9 pages his or her lives, and the offender has the opportunity to explain his or her reasons for committing the crime against the victim” (Williams & Arrigo, p 269, 2008). “One of the failures of the criminal justice system in the United States is that the needs of victim have been traditionally ignored. When someone is charged with committing a crime the plaintiff isn’t the victim. The plaintiff is the state. The crime is against “the state.” The

Criminal Justice Ethics

625 words - 3 pages Criminal Justice Ethics Paper Ethics - 232 September 28, 2013 Criminal Justice Ethics Paper A few months ago, a woman was brutally raped, beaten and left for dead. Since the attack she remains in a coma. This case has risen to national prominence as an example of how today’s youth no longer respects fundamental social values, television and video game violence has desensitized young men to the consequences of crimes such as assault and

Related Essays

The Myth Of A Racist Criminal Justice System

581 words - 3 pages The Myth of a Racist Criminal Justice System By William Wilbanks The name of the book that I read was The Myth of a Racist Criminal Justice System by William Wilbanks and was published in 1987. It talks about the myths of having a racist criminal justice system. In this book the author does not believe that that the criminal justice system is racial but believes at times there is racial prejudice and discrimination within the

Racism In The Criminal Justice System

4004 words - 17 pages locking difference in our criminal justice system and setting minorities to fail in a world built around white privilege. The criminal justice system is a starting point to instilling human rights back into society. To create equality in the criminal justice system, laws need to be reformed to incorporate proportionality and fairness in punishment and equal sentencing among races, elimination of mandatory minimum sentences, eliminating or narrowing

Human Rights And The Criminal Justice System

3443 words - 14 pages relationship means that the trust that was placed in it has been broken. (Oxford English Dictionary, 2005 a) In contemporary society, we elected a government. With the power given to it the government and its agencies maintain law and order. In other words they ensure that this bond of trust is not broken. When this bond is broken society becomes a victim and the Criminal justice system has been given the power to deal with the offender if necessary

Criminology And The Criminal Justice System

1111 words - 5 pages Criminology and the Criminal Justice System Jackulin, Cyrus Sec/340 October, 1, 2012 Criminology and the Criminal Justice System No matter where you live in the world the city or the country crime always happens from murder, rape, robbery, arson, assault, auto theft, and burglary. People try their hardest to try and find an area where they cannot deal with crime you can’t find a place. Either were you live crime goes up or down