This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

A Question Of Ethics: Egg Harvesting For Stem Cell Research

953 words - 4 pages

Jacob Byers
Prof. Carver
29 Sept. 2013
A Question of Ethics: Egg Harvesting for Stem Cell Research

Stem cell research brings to mind cloning, treatments for disease, and other positive things. What you don’t think about are the women affected through the harvesting of the embryotic eggs required to conduct this research. Dr. Diane Beeson’s article “Egg Harvesting for Stem Cell Research: Medical Risks and Ethical Problems” illustrates the issues of short and long-term effects of ovarian stimulation, risks to offspring, and the exploitation of women. She uses this information to develop an argument against the use of unauthorized and unstudied drugs and the misleading language ...view middle of the document...

We get a look into several studies linking ovarian cancer to ovarian stimulation. Dr. Beeson explains that follow-ups from cases in the 1960’s were in such a narrow time frame that the women who first used drugs approved in that era while in their late 20’s and 30’s have only recently reached the age when hormonally related cancers are common. Extending the length of a follow-up to nearly 20 years has yielded evidence of a possible association between the drug use and uterine cancer (Beeson and Lippman). Dr. Beeson uses credible data and resources making her argument stronger as she explains the more serious effects of egg harvesting.
Her play on emotions begins with data pulled from reports illustrating the negative effects on offspring. These effects include growth retardation and an increase in rib abnormalities. She issues out a plea that the answers to the questions concerning these findings should be answered before more women are exposed to ovarian stimulation solely for research purposes (Beeson and Lippman).
Dr. Beeson also delves into the issue of conflicts of interest. She says that economic pressures encourage researchers and research advocates to overlook or play down risks to egg providers (Beeson and Lippman). An example would be the physician harvesting the eggs also being involved in the research. In these cases women are left vulnerable to the pressures to provide eggs, especially when payment of any kind is offered (Beeson and Lippman). She illustrates a scandal involving American researchers and a Korean scientist named Hwang Woo-suk in which Hwang lied about the results of his research studies. He used well over 2000 eggs without creating a viable clone. It was also revealed that payment, coercion and lying were used to acquire the eggs first reported to have been eagerly donated by participating women (Beeson and Lippman). She also states...

Other Papers Like A Question of Ethics: Egg Harvesting for Stem Cell Research

Stem Cell Research Essay

1438 words - 6 pages . Thomas Berg in his article “It Is Not Ethical to Pay Women to Donate Eggs for Research Cloning” said poor women who are in need of money would be enticed to cell their eggs without knowing the health risks associated with harvesting procedure (1). On May 12, 2009 colleagues on the ethics committee of New York’s Empire State Stem Cell Board voted to recommend to the state that women will get paid $10,000 per retrieval to use their eggs in research

Stem Cell Research Essay

1625 words - 7 pages Stem cells are a large focus of study in today's biomedical world. They are also a large focus in the world of ethics, politics and religion. It seems that for every statement praising the progress of stem cell research, there is an equally disturbing report proclaiming the lack of ethics demonstrated by such research. Stem cells have proven to have an endless possibility for medical advancement, however, at the same time, the method by which

Stem Cell Research

1403 words - 6 pages ethical evidence. Stem Cell Research has a lot of misinformation and deception going on in the process that accounts for the stem cell debate, This is probably the worst problem in this whole debate, the perpetuation ( innocent or not is the question) that has misleading statements which obscure many of the real facts . What is usually lacking from press reports are a few adjectives that will clarify the situation

Stem Cell Research Paper

1392 words - 6 pages , Scientist were able to derive embryonic stem cells from mice. One of the biggest advancements in all stem cell research came in 1997 when a link between Leukemia and Haematopoietic cells was established, and in 1998, scientists at the University of Wisconsin, were the first to derive human embryonic stem cells. Although these discoveries and advancements are huge strides forward for the medical field, they remain highly controversial on

Stem Cell Research - 970 words

970 words - 4 pages of cell” (Pros and Cons…). One of the main debates is between stem cell research and religious views. Some religions such as branches Christianity believe that obtaining and using embryonic stem cells is a sin and should not be used for research or otherwise. Even though I identify as a Christian, I believe that stem cells should be utilized, as long as an egg is not fertilized only for the use of stem cells. One reason many people don’t

Stem Cell Research 13

1788 words - 8 pages ). The potential discovery of treatments for a variety of medical problems including organ and tissue regeneration, brain disease treatment, cell deficiency therapy, and blood disease treatment may be possible with further research. At the heart of the political debate of whether the federal government should sponsor and pay for the research is the cultural and political idea of when human life begins (“What are stem cells,” 2010). This question

Stem Cell Research - 997 words

997 words - 4 pages eligible for social security. The drain that such an occurrence would put on the economy is almost immeasurable. It would lead to a host of undesirable effects, most notably an inevitable tax increase to support all of the elderly who would depend on their monthly social security check as their only source of income. While the harvesting of embryonic stem cells should be out of the question, research on adult stem cells

Ethical Research Stem Cell

870 words - 4 pages Imagine a world without disease, or the need for transplants. Have you ever known someone who needed a new kidney, heart, or liver? How about someone with a rare blood type that desperately needed a transfusion after chemotherapy? These are all issue that could theoretically disappear through the use of stem cells. The pros of stem cell research outweigh the cons. So what exactly is a stem cell? A stem cell is a very versatile cell that

Stem Cell Research - 1603 words

1603 words - 7 pages research is the ethical dispute over the use of human embryos in research. In November of 1998, Dr. James A. Thompson discovered that human embryonic stem cells can theoretically differentiate into virtually any type of human cell, from blood cells to skin cells; thus offering great promise for new ways of treating disease (AAAS, n.d.). The opponents of human embryonic stem cell research believe that human life begins as soon as the egg is

Stem Cell Research Paper

1261 words - 6 pages , patients are injected with healthy stem cells from a donor in the hopes that they will replace the irregular cells and generate healthy leukocytes ( Many cases have turned out successful when all abnormal leukocytes are replaced with healthy stem cells, but they are still not FDA approved (9). The last type of stem cell known is the induced pluripotent stem cell. According Sarah Boseley, a health editor for The Guardian

Stem Cell Research - 1594 words

1594 words - 7 pages research. According to the Royal Society, no other country is pursuing stem cell research more aggressively and it is also fully funded by the Government (The Royal Society, 2007). In Europe, every country has specific ethics and laws about stem cell research. Belgium and the UK share a similar legal position, to study certain diseases and the creation of human embryos for the procurement of human embryonic stem cells, while Germany and Italy strictly

Related Essays

Stem Cell Research: What Is It? A Paper For A Communication And Gender Class, Overview Of Topic And Ethical Concerns

1448 words - 6 pages debilitating Alzheimer's disease (a degenerative brain disease that left him wasting away for over a decade). Many religious leaders and conservative politicians have denounced the research citing ethical reasonsand equating embryonic stem cell research with abortion and the murdering of human life in order to harvest its cells. Regardless of ethical issues, we have seen that there are promising alternatives to embryonic stem cell research. No one

A Conservative Argument Against Stem Cell Research

1201 words - 5 pages A Conservative Argument against Stem Cell Research For the past few years stem cell research has been a widely debated topic; however, former President Clinton?s stance?allowing federal money to be spent on tightly controlled stem cell research?lead to intense debates over federal funding for stem cell research. There are four ways of obtaining stem cells, which are taken from embryos that are approximately one week old. They are using

The Importance Of Stem Cell Research

2721 words - 11 pages repeatedly donating to stem cell research. Cells can be taken from umbilical cords as well, although this is not as controversial of a way to get stem cells since it is not altering a life, or a potential life. For most, the issue is determining when life begins. Does life begin at the moment of fertilization or when a baby exits the womb and appears in the real world? If one considers the moment an egg is fertilized and develops into a fetus

The Importance Of Stem Cell Research

1419 words - 6 pages tissue and can even grow new organs. Currently scientists are focusing on how to treat and even cure cancer, Parkinson’s, spinal cord injury, Alzheimer’s, burns, heart disease, diabetes, and arthritis, all by means of stem cell engineering. As these advances in stem cell research and engineering, coupled with moral obligation and legislative guidance continue we have the potential to treat, cure and for future generations make a lot of the diseases