A Letter From Prison Essay

1663 words - 7 pages

1. How serious were Stephen Richards’ actions? Why?
Stephen Richards’s actions were extremely serious; manipulating Computer Associates’ quarter end cutoff to align CA’s reported financial results with market expectations by violating the generally accepted accounting principles and their financial reporting responsibilities. According to the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Richards with other CA executives extended CA’s fiscal quarter, “ instructed and allowed subordinates to negotiate and obtain contracts after quarter end while knowing, or recklessly disregarding the fact that, CA would improperly recognize the revenue from those contracts, and failed to alert CA’s Finance or ...view middle of the document...

(NY) The goal of the 35-day month was to permit CA to report that it met or exceed its projected quarterly revenue and earnings when, in truth, it had not. (DOJ) Referring to the Scheme to Defraud, Richard instructed CA sales managers and salespeople to negotiate and finalize additional license agreements, which were backdated to cover the fact that the agreements had been finalized after the end of the fiscal quarter.
At the end, these actions led to “overly aggressive accounting practices” to boost CA’s reported earnings and the managerial use of discretion to greatly influence reported earnings was not only used by Richards’, but it had become a company-wide practice. As Mark K. Schonfeld, Director of the SEC’s Northeast Regional Office, said about CA’s fraud “Like a team that plays on after the final whistle has blown, Computer Associates kept scoring until it had all points needed to make every quarter look like a win.” (Wharton)
As the result, CA fraudulently recorded and reported in the earlier quarter revenue associated with the backdated agreements. Stephen Richard’s actions are notably serious because he had knowledge of the wrongdoings and he was in a position to report it, but he chose not to. Richards’ action together with other CA’s executives seriously victimized the shareholders as they suffered enormous losses once the practices were revealed. Therefore, “Richard was ordered to pay $29 million in restitution.” (Weidlich)
2. If Computer Associates achieved the same financial results through GAAP flexibility, does your answer to question 1 change?
No, with the flexibility of GAAP the risk of manipulation was that CA could have more likely made reporting mistake that would lead to legal problems and enormous losses. As long as the CA’s executives including Richards had the intention of wrongdoing actions they would cause massive losses to the shareholders of the company and to the SEC. Though such manipulations and fraud resulted CA to payback “$225 million for the purposes of compensating shareholders for losses arising out of the company’s criminal conduct.” (DOJ) Seeing that, the evidence and investigation on Computer Associates shows that the CA didn’t make false transaction and actual transaction and business deal had happened, but the problem of fraud was that CA’s executives were backdating the agreements in order to prematurely recognize revenue from contracts that had not yet been executed by both CA and its customers in violation of GAAP.
Under Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP), four conditions were required to be met in order for revenue associated with a software license agreement to be recognized: 1- persuasive evidence of an arrangement was required to have existed, 2- delivery of the licensed products was required to have occurred, 3- the license fee was required to have been fixed or determinable, 4- the collectability of the license fee was required to have been probable.
Computer Associate did...

Other Papers Like A Letter from Prison

Letter from a Birmingham Jail Essay

797 words - 4 pages Martin Luther King’s “Letter from Birmingham jail” is a mix of emotional passion and logical precision that seeks to achieve meaningful cause. The letter was a response to white clergy who were critical of his intention in Birmingham naming him an “outsider”. King’s response to critics through a letter explains his arguments vividly and effectively. King wrote the letter in a way that he agreed with his critics, nonetheless still using their

Letter from a Birmingham Jail Essay

868 words - 4 pages took place and caused an abundance of controversy.  A man known as Martin Luther King Jr. led these peaceful calls for change and during a march for desegregation on Good Friday, King was arrested and spent eight days in jail.  While confined King wrote a moving letter called, “Letter from Birmingham Jail” in response to another letter entitled, “A Call for Unity: A Letter From Eight White Clergymen”.  In the following essay I will be examining

Letter Home From a Soldier in Vietnam

1268 words - 6 pages Letter Home From a Soldier in Vietnam Dear Mom, I am doing great. Well…When I say great, I mean I'm as good as you can be over here. This place is like a giant valley of death, that's keeps getting filled with more dead American soldiers every day. We keep asking ourselves the question, why are we here? Why are we dying for a cause that's got nothing to do with us? We just don't see the point in us being

"Letter From A Birmingham Jail" - Passage Analysis Assignment

986 words - 4 pages On Good Friday in 1963, 53 blacks, led by Reverend Martin Luther King, Jr., marched into downtown Birmingham, Alabama, to protest the existing segregation laws. All were arrested. This caused the clergymen of this Southern town to compose a letter appealing to the black population to stop their demonstrations. In response to their letter, King wrote back in what would be titled "Letter From A Birmingham Jail". Especially prevalent in the letter

Scarlet Letter

544 words - 3 pages is shown by the way she handles the burden of the scralet letter. During The Scarlet Letter, Hester's character is presented as unselfish, loving, and strong.In the beginning of The Scarlet Letter, as Hester walks to the scaffold from the prison, she holds her head up high and remains in public view without shedding a tear. During Hester's public shame on the scaffold, the reader can see that Hester is a strong person. Hester's vigor in character

Scarlet Letter

805 words - 4 pages Richard Regulski Professor Colleen Field English 112 February 19, 2013 The Scarlet Letter Symbolism generally is the use of objects, people, or words to add deeper meaning to a story. Symbolism can also represent an underlying message that the story is trying to get across. When you think of "The Scarlet Letter" you automatically think of the letter "A" forced to be worn by Hester Pryne the adulterer, but it goes much deeper than that

Why the Mistreatment?

559 words - 3 pages sentence that can be extended if he's considered a threat. This sentence in itself I would call a grave injustice for the family, but even worse this mass murder thinks the conditions in which he lives under serving time at the Ila Prison are not suitable and unjust. I believe its pretty safe to say the parents of the children he murdered would believe there was a lot of unjust in what he did. October 15th 2012 Breivik wrote a 27-page letter addressed

Prisions

259 words - 2 pages system is the rapid boom in prison population. since 1960 the population in the prisons have grown from 9,000 inmates to over 50,000 inmates. Michigan on avergae keeps prisoners locked up a year longer than other states. Michigan also has more prisoners locked up past there proale date than other states do. What is being done about this promblem, well not alot. Governor Jennifer Grandholm of michigan had promised reform in the prison system

Individual Freedom: the Scarlett Letter

1208 words - 5 pages to carry her punishment in New England and not going back to England, where she could have lived a new life without feeling guilty. Furthermore, her self-determination gives her enough strength to use silence as a weapon, and thus not revealing who Pearl’s father is. Hester’s freedom progresses throughout the novel. It all begins after coming out from prison, when Hester wears a stunning embroidered A on her breast which symbolizes

Cold Blood- Barbara's Letter

588 words - 3 pages pointed out that she wasn’t too pleased with Perry’s actions, which had eventually ended him in prison. She was also aware that her criticism to him was going to result in resentment and actually thought of what could possibly happen “Not to hear from you at all or a letter telling me exactly what you think of me.” Barbara loved Perry dearly but was angry at him at the same time, and that was the driving force of this passionate letter. Again she

Kiet Runner

1092 words - 5 pages prison. However, when Andy escaped from prison, it finally gave Red hope, a push that once he gets out of jail he can live his rest of life sans any fear. Brook, who was the third member of the trio and the first among them to die within Shawshank, was an elder librarian; he had no hope whatsoever to possibly escape prison walls and even went as far as to killing fellow prisoner, Heywood, so he could lengthen his prison sentence. Andy managed

Related Essays

A Letter From Prison Essay

1166 words - 5 pages FOODCORP REFLECTION PAPER 1. INTRODUCTION In FoodCorp simulation, held on 22 nd of November, my position was VP Marketing Services and I worked under the head of SVP Service Group. Service group consisted of 4 people including one senior vice president and three vice presidents. As VP of Marketing Services, I was responsible for marketing communications in general. I also mention about organizational structure of FoodCorp to establish a

A Lesson From A Prison Visit

1093 words - 5 pages "A Lesson from a prison visit"We entered the building; my mother couldn't hold back her tears. All around me, the people there had grim expressions, an ominous feel in the air. Walking up the steps to a place, I would never see myself going, let alone visit a brother, my childhood friend. It was mid September, and I was visiting Sullivan, my childhood friend, at the South-Beach Prison. It was an experience that would forever change my outlook on

A Lesson From A Prison Visit

1093 words - 5 pages "A Lesson from a prison visit"We entered the building; my mother couldn't hold back her tears. All around me, the people there had grim expressions, an ominous feel in the air. Walking up the steps to a place, I would never see myself going, let alone visit a brother, my childhood friend. It was mid September, and I was visiting Sullivan, my childhood friend, at the South-Beach Prison. It was an experience that would forever change my outlook on

Letter From A Birmingham Jail Essay

846 words - 4 pages TUI University Lionel Martinez ENG 101 – English Composition 1 Dr. David Ojo Module 1 Case Assignment 1 June, 8 2012 While King's letter was set and written in the 1960's, it is still prevalent today. Martin Luther King was not only a civil rights activist for Blacks, but his logic and rhetoric is to be admired. I feel it is our duty not only to read King's letter, but to use it as an educational tool. The letter, by King, is