A Flawed Justice System Essay

1224 words - 5 pages

Alejandro Delgado

Professor Wolf

British Literature

February 23, 2012

A Flawed Justice System

When a society has a problem and it needs to be dealt with in a fair manner, the society turns to its judicial system, which lays down the rules of how to go about the case and determine the punishment. There were many different societies that enforced a law system according to their needs and population, and this goes the same for the era. Ben Jonson and Jonathan Swift are two very popular and well respected authors of satire, who have made stories that made society question the judicial system that they carried. Ben Jonson satirizes the judicial system in his play Volpone, a ...view middle of the document...

For example, When Voltore speaks of Bonario in lines 80-90, he states that Bonario “dragged forth the aged gentleman, that had there lain bedrid three years and more, out of his innocent couch(p.1399)” which the avocatores find ridiculous but can find no proof against the statement. Corvino then speaks of his wife Celia, stating that she “is a whore of most hot exercise, more than a partridge, upon record—(p.1400)” and that she is “a creature of a most professed and prostituted lewdness(p.1401)”. It is clear that they are merely trying to ruin the reputation that Celia and Bonario have in order to win over the avocatores, which succeeded temporarily. The satire in this would be the way the court is carried, where the weak and innocent are only give a brief chance to defend themselves, but even then the people with power are the real decision makers. It is possible that Jonson has seen many cases such as these before, and felt a need to point out the flaws in the system when it comes to greed. In lines 50 through 60, the fourth avocatore is seen being slowly corrupted by the knowledge of Volpone’s “death” and considers marrying his daughter to the newly inherited Mosca(p.1424). While the avocatore is supposed to be fair and be protecting the innocent, he is mesmerized by the words of Mosca and how he is the heir to the grand fortune of Volpone, which shows how even the just can be corrupted if persuaded correctly. In a critical review by Thomas J. Schoenberg, it should be noted that Jonson gives Mosca and Volpone the ability to “weave the minds” of the characters who so desperately seek a position in the will, so powerful that the influence reaches to the authorities(Schoenberg).

Although portrayed differently, Jonathan Swift mocks the judicial system through a conversation that Gulliver and then King of Brobdingnag have. Throughout the conversation, Gulliver is speaking boastfully of England and all of it's greatness. Gulliver does so by stating that everything is to proportion back in England, and begins answering the questions the king of Brobdingnag had to ask. At the end of the explanation, the king of Brobdingnag belittles England, comparing the things that Gulliver said to the nature of insects. “These creatures have their titles and distinctions of honor; they contrive little nests and burrows, that they call houses and cities;(Gulliver's Travels p.2379).” Here the king is clearly mocking the way the society of England works, and how the people from England agree to certain customs which the king found ridiculous, and after some thought, as did Gulliver. Gulliver told the king of Brobdingnag about the highest court of Judicature, where there could be no appeal, the House of Commons, and the the Courts of Justice, which he...

Other Papers Like A Flawed Justice System

Capital Punishment, The Road To A Corrupt Criminal Justice System, Must Be Abolished For The Sake Of Society. The Death Penalty Is Unfair Towards Society Members, Such As Tax Payers, Innocent People,...

2653 words - 11 pages " (Commission of the Fair Administration of Justice, June 30, 2008). The Commission estimates the annual costs of the death penalty to be $137 million. California's death row of 670 inmates accounts for about $63.3 million. The average annual costs of a system that imposes lifetime sentencing in prison instead of capital punishment are $11.5 million. It is obvious that the costs to maintain a system with lifetime incarceration is much lower than

Theory of Justice Analysis

1243 words - 5 pages may strive to be a dominator when he grows up to gain control over life situations. This would be his ideal future but it would not be ideal for significant others in his life. These individuals may feel oppressed. In this aspect the Utilitarian view of justice flawed because human happiness is a desire and not a need, therefore, consensus is impossible. Modern Justice Definition The Criminal Justice System is composed of three parts: law

Juries as a Social Construction

525 words - 3 pages -white, there are many different ways to view a situation. Juries are selected to be a group of peers – this is what our justice system is based off of. If an objective peer would do the same thing in the same situation, perhaps you’ll be acquitted. However, the peer-based system is flawed. The first reason is because it can be hard to find a peer for some groups. The more educated a person is, the less likely it is that their jury will be

25 Entrepreneurship Lesson Learned

884 words - 4 pages way his argument as a whole lacks credibility. Step 4.2 II. Body Paragraph #2 A. Topic Sentence: Contradiction B. Evidence: Raped in prison C. Refute: contradicts himself D. Support: 1. Explain the horrors of prison a. Use example from movie 2. Prison is brutal 3. But people still commit crimes upon their release a. Jacoby states, prison not effective, “few believe justice system a success.” 4. Rape = Pain, Pain = Prisoners, and Prisoners

Cool Hand Luke: Failure To Communicate

3363 words - 14 pages Released in 1967, “Cool Hand Luke” continues to be one of the most popular movies in American history. (Belton, 2008) The movie starred famed actor Paul Newman and was based on the trials and tribulations occurring inside a Florida prison camp. One of the main reasons why Cool Hand Luke continues to be relevant today is due to its incisive observations regarding the criminal justice system. While the movie was released over forty years ago

Ethics And Leadership In Criminal Justice

953 words - 4 pages particular religion and the particular views of the individual. The divine command theory is highly controversial, mostly because of religious beliefs. Mutual advantage, philosophers have considered the possible that justice is at bottom of system rules that members of society follow for mutual advantage. Some maintain that justice as mutual advantage is a fatally flawed theory of justice because it's too exclusive. They argued that justice as a

Social Justice Essay

700 words - 3 pages Social Justice Essay Ashley Seeram Most will agree the public needs an educational system beneficial to all, but many people have different opinions on how this can be done and what a beneficial educational system is. There are groups that say division says privatize education, and another group of people who believe charter-schools are not the solution to this problem. Is it important to give the public an option to what they want or need

Justice System

1027 words - 5 pages local jurisdiction, for which there is no legally acceptable justification or excuse. There is no justifying or excusing these acts (Schmalleger, 2009, p. 7). Crimes definition plays a major role in determining which acts are criminal as well as the models that are presented. Government Structure The government is structured in such a way as to support the Criminal Justice System in America. The first part of that structure is the

Justice in Atonement and the Constant Gardener

1046 words - 5 pages their methods of maintaining this standard of injustice in efforts of self-preservation. This often results in the suffering of those carrying out their quest for justice. This idea, and the concept that the miscarriage of justice can have long lasting and far reaching effects which can never be fully redressed are thoroughly explored in both the film The Constant Gardener and Ian McEwan’s Atonement, through a range of literary devices and film

Inside The Field Of Criminal Justice

775 words - 4 pages name 11/4/15 Criminal Justice Research Paper Inside the field of Criminal Justice Criminal Justice paves the way for those who have a special interest in this particular field. Typically when people think about Criminal Justice they assume the field consist of the usual Police Officers and Detectives, but this is definitely not the case. There is no single criminal justice system in the United States but rather similar, individual systems

Innocence Lost - Researched Argument

2945 words - 12 pages long road ahead of us but I believe – and this paper will show – that changing the way juveniles are adjudicated in America is an important step in the right direction. The juvenile justice system was designed and implemented for juvenile offenders, and should be the only place that juveniles are adjudicated. Juvenile offenders should not be transferred to adult criminal court at any age, for any crime. To get a better understanding of

Related Essays

The Myth Of A Racist Criminal Justice System

581 words - 3 pages The Myth of a Racist Criminal Justice System By William Wilbanks The name of the book that I read was The Myth of a Racist Criminal Justice System by William Wilbanks and was published in 1987. It talks about the myths of having a racist criminal justice system. In this book the author does not believe that that the criminal justice system is racial but believes at times there is racial prejudice and discrimination within the

A Review Of The Literature: Plea Bargaining And Ethics In The Criminal Justice System

1939 words - 8 pages | A Review of the Literature: Plea Bargaining and Ethics in the Criminal Justice System | | | Plea bargaining is a significant portion of today’s criminal justice system. As Chief Justice Burger stated, “The disposition of criminal charges by agreement between the prosecutor and the accused, sometimes loosely called ‘plea bargaining,’ is an essential component of the administration of justice. Properly administered, it is to be

The Saga Of Gisli: A Critical View Of Scandinavian Justice System And Settler Mentality

1426 words - 6 pages In The Saga of Gisli, Gisli's outlawry and pursuit is a classic example of the tensions present in Medieval Scandinavian culture's policial and justice system. Several shifts occurred in the ninth century that changed early Scandinavian worldviews, including the influence of Christianity and resistance to nationalism . For example, the old ways insisted that vengeance on behalf of one's kin was expected and power was measured by the ability to

Ultimately, Actuarial Principles And Methods Are Incompatible With Aspirations Towards A Youth Justice System Which Is Rooted In The Complex Dynamics And Systemic Inequalities Which Characterise Many...

2006 words - 9 pages this essay an explanation will be given of what the risk factors are, what the RFPP is and how actuarial practices are based on this methodological approach. It concludes that a focus on actuarial principles in the current youth justice system works against the fundamental principles of individualization in the criminal justice system . Society has become increasingly concerned with risk and the management of it. It is defined as being an