A Constitutional Framework: The Relationship Of Supreme Power And Individual Rights In The Second Treatise

2115 words - 9 pages

A Constitutional Framework: The Relationship of Supreme Power and Individual Rights in the Second Treatise

The supremacy of legislative power is a deceptive phrase in the Second Treatise. If one were to follow Locke’s blueprint for the original formation of the commonwealth closely, it would become apparent that supreme power in political society rests with the people, not the legislature, because ultimately, there must be a constitution that is written by the people. In order to most clearly see this, a distinction must be drawn between the basic political society and the higher level institution of government, and the events that take place in each sphere must be differentiated. In ...view middle of the document...

These first positive laws do not have to be extensive or complex, but they must exist in some form, or how can men know, for example, to decide upon a government by majority rather than by unanimous approval? There is no natural law by which to make this choice. It may seem that, because the legislature is the supreme law-giving body, the legislative power precedes law in Locke’s pattern of commonwealth formation, but this is misleading.

In fact, Locke alludes several times to laws which precede the legislature itself, arguing that “the first and fundamental positive law of all commonwealths is the establishing of the legislative power…” (XI, 134). Once established, the legislative must not be allowed to exercise what Locke calls “arbitrary” power over the citizens, but this raises a problem of distinction—if the legislative has supreme power to make laws, which laws promulgated by a legislature are properly valid and which are arbitrary? There must be some pre-legislative standard set forth which can be used to distinguish between the two, and indeed, Locke implies the necessity of a constitution when he writes that, “Mankind will be in a far worse condition than in the state of nature, if they shall have…[a legislative] to force them to obey…the exorbitant decrees of their sudden thoughts…without having any measure set down which may guide and justify their actions” (XI, 137). The solution is “established and promulgated laws; that both the people…and the rulers too [will be] kept within their bounds” (XI, 137). Laws regulating the law-making powers of the rulers must by definition precede the establishment of the legislative, since to rely on the rulers themselves to establish guidelines limiting their own power is hardly different from expecting them to fairly and objectively be the judges of their own suits. After all, the very reason that Locke calls for a “measure…which may guide and justify” the laws which the legislative creates is because he assumes that, given the opportunity, it will cease to serve the interests of the people and begin to serve its own interests instead (XI, 137).

Thus, in order to satisfy Locke’s conditions for a just and legitimate government, it is necessary that something like a constitutional convention take place in that transition state between the initial entrance into political society and the establishment of the society’s government. Since the resulting constitution or common law ultimately restricts the power of the legislative, it is in fact the people who wrote it who have supreme power. It is power in this transition state that Locke refers to when he ambiguously argues that, “there remains still in the people a supreme power to remove or alter the legislative…” (XIII, 149). Once basic boundaries for the government are created, and a government is established by the majority according to these precepts, then the legislative takes over as the supreme power in the political society, though it is...

Other Papers Like A Constitutional Framework: The Relationship Of Supreme Power And Individual Rights In The Second Treatise

India - a Supreme Power Essay

2466 words - 10 pages .. • Answerer 5 I'm not sure about a "supreme power", but certainly a strong factor. They have a hard working, smart, technically oriented, generally british/english-speaking population all of which are very valuable in the U.S> However India itself has limited physical resources and political complexities in India and the larger area can make things quite difficult to have consistent & sustainable growth. • Answerer 6 Well if India

Power Of Supreme Court Essay

913 words - 4 pages evolved following the Marbury Vs Madison case and was not granted by the constitution. The Supreme Court therefore does not have the authority to carry out judicial review and become a quasi-legislative branch because the constitution granted this power to Congress. However, there are a number of reasons why the power of the supreme court can be justified in a democracy. Firstly, the supreme court helps protects the rights and liberties of the

“the Supreme Court and the Constitution”, Charles A. Bread

964 words - 4 pages opinions of great thinkers such as James Madison, Samuel Adams, Thomas Jefferson, Patrick Henry and many others. He do not agree that five men are elected for live and have the right of veto and can change the federal low against the public opinion. He also strongly underline that the Founding Fathers do not agree on giving such a power to the Supreme Court. Bread closely describe the Constitutional Convention and it outcomes. He pays

A Farewell to Arms Within the Critical Framework of Feminism and the Principles of Post Structuralism

3292 words - 14 pages within which it is produced and lives. Post-feminist structuralism seeks to examine the production of knowledge as it impacts on gender. The pervasiveness of male discourse is a particular target for post-structuralist feminism. What I hope to achieve is an analysis of the theory in relation to the character of Catherine Barkley and her romantic relationship with the novel’s narrator and protagonist Frederick Henry. For

Assess the Individual in a Health and Social Care Setting

1543 words - 7 pages SS5.1 1. Assess the Individual in a Health and Social Care Setting Systematic and sensitive assessment requires to prevent the waste of valuable resources, and could have a positive impact on the whole of the health and social care system for older people. These people using services are entitled to care and support that is safe and takes their needs. Assessment tools in my workplace are: 1. Waterlow score

The Long-Term Effects Of Globalization On The Enjoyment Of Individual Human Rights And On Social And Cultural Identities

1959 words - 8 pages rights, while the others believed that the concept itself not only enhance and liberate the full enjoyment of such basic rights of each individual but also mix and produce diversity of identities. Therefore, the following arguments of the essay will be structured in a way that would analyze both negative and positive positions of globalization that might affect society in a long run. The essay will start by stating that while global development

A Framework for Prudential Regulation and Supervision of the Financial Sector

5339 words - 22 pages shareholders agreed. Recent changes in the legislation have gone some way towards resolving the problem by giving the Minister of Finance the power to acquire shares of non-viable institutions. DEPOSIT INSURANCE Even if a country has highly competent supervisory authority and the best regulatory framework that human ingenuity can assure, it is still possible that financial institutions can fail. This is why a number of countries have

A Second Bite of the Apple

1231 words - 5 pages A Second Bite of the Apple Kimberly Richards Kaplan University Dual Sovereignty Doctrine “Dual sovereignty doctrine provides that when a defendant in a single act violates the “peace and dignity” of two sovereigns by breaking the laws of each, he has committed two distinct “offences” for double jeopardy purposes. In applying the doctrine, the crucial determination is whether the two entities that seek successively to prosecute a defendant

The Constitutional COnvention Of 1787

1276 words - 6 pages convention, clerk of the Supreme Court of New Jersey.Jonathan Dayton, son of a storekeeper in Elizabethtown, had served with distinction in the Revolution, and, at twenty-six, was the convention's youngest delegate. Pierce, an army comrade, said that Dayton had ``an impetuosity in his temper'' that was injurious to him, but that he also had an ``honest rectitude.''Alexander Martin, who headed the North Carolina delegation, had been a colonel in

The Importance of a Second Language

1590 words - 7 pages get older, the neurons in our brain harden and it becomes increasingly difficult to learn new things, such as a new language. Many tests and studies have supported this idea of brain plasticity and have shown how learning a second language exponentially easier in the early stages of life. As a college student knowing only English, I deeply regret not having the ability to speak another language. I took Spanish classes throughout middle and high

Relationship Between The Bible And Power And Politics

860 words - 4 pages ." (Organization and Management Theory: Conference Paper Abstract, 2003, pg77) So, a way to influence the power side of the board of directors is to appeal to what makes more finances without using current finances. If Abner were to convince the board of directors in today's workforce to end a merger or seize a hostile take over, he would probably have to do more than ignite the biblical senses of each individual. That Abner would need to show the

Related Essays

Rights, Freedoms And Responsibilities Of The Individual In Great Britain

2203 words - 9 pages Rights, Freedoms and Responsibilities of the Individual in Great Britain Contents ​Chapter 1 Historical Development of System of Human Rights in United ​Kingdom 1.1. Development of Human Rights in Kingdom of England from ​Manga Carta to Bill of Rights 1.2. Development of System of Human Rights in XVIII – XX ​Centuries References Historical Development of System of Human Rights in United ​Kingdom ​The origin of human rights law

Relationship Betweeen The Individual And The Community

2417 words - 10 pages . Therefore through the character of Silas Eliot represents the relationship between the individual and community in the novel Silas Marner. This is conveyed through the progression of Silas from being a solitary figure that becomes a core part of the community. This is through Silas weaving his web, catching people and drawing them closer to him and through him reaching into the community for help. Through the character of Dolly it is clearly

John Locke Second Treatise Of Civil Government

725 words - 3 pages branches are very similar to those outlined in the constitution. Locke believes that all people are born equally, and so although people in government technically have more power than the regular citizens, the citizens should have the power to remove them when they do not feel properly represented. The purpose of government is to protect the rights of citizens; therefore a government should never have arbitrary power over any of its citizens. He

The Second Amendment Of The Bill Of Rights

2465 words - 10 pages sense and to every useful purpose, a bill of rights." (as cited in Nardo, 2003, p. 55). In Federalist Paper Number 29, Hamilton addressed the issue of a militia and bearing arms as the Second Amendment would later define. Hamilton discussed the need for military regulation and organization:The power of regulating the militia, and of commanding its services in times of insurrection and invasion are natural incidents to the duties of superintending