A Comparative Essay

1433 words - 6 pages

After reading America’s Constitutional Soul, by Harvey C. Mansfield, Jr., and The True and Only Heaven, by Christopher Lasch, I came to the realization that while they have varying ideas on many topics, they have similar conservative views regarding citizenship and civil rights.

Specifically, Mansfield discusses his belief that people are best served through a

representative government and does not believe that all citizens should be allowed to rule directly (Mansfield 141). In this regard, Mansfield contends that people, in general, tend to be irrational and rely too much on feelings as opposed to reasoned conclusions (Mansfield 29-30). Therefore, if a true

form of ...view middle of the document...

This document requires that actions be formal. According to Mansfield, the United States Constitution is documented proof that citizens want self-government and that they have the ability, through formal processes set up by institutions, to rise above self-interest (Mansfield 151).

Similarly, Christopher Lasch seems to have the same doubts about citizens’ ability to

effectively decide on matters of importance. Through his discussions of Walter Lippman’s writings, “Public Opinion” and “The Phantom Public”, Lash appears to agree that the use of “self-governing” is not an effective form of Democracy (Lasch 364). Lasch goes on to further set forth that the old ideas of citizenship are out-dated and that, in fact, citizens can no longer be viewed as “omnicompetent” or as “jack of all trades” (Lasch 364).

Lasch and Mansfield both seem to doubt the abilities of the average citizens and do not believe that we should entrust them with decisions which affect the society. Lasch even goes so far as to say that the government needs to be, “carried on by officials who were expected to ‘conceive a common interest’ - guided by public opinion or expert knowledge” (Lasch 365). Lasch believed that because our society is set up as it is (i.e., vast division of labor and distribution of wealth and power), it can not reasonably be expected to be governed by majority vote of the entire population (all with varying views and self-interested expectations). In this respect, Mansfield and Lasch seem to agree that the powers of citizens, as a whole, should be limited in terms of their ability to actively

participate government.

Another area which Mansfield and Lasch seem to have similar opinions is that regarding civil rights. Mansfield goes into great detail regarding how our government, through its formalized Constitution, protects the distinction between a person’s rights and their abilities to exercise those rights. In doing this, the Constitution is needed to limit the scope of the exercising of our rights

(Mansfield 32). The underlying topic involved in the obtainment of rights and their exercise is “equality”. Mansfield believes that it is necessary for our democratic nation to always be striving towards equality. However, according to Mansfield, it should be realized by all representatives that equality is not a formalized guarantee (Mansfield 11-12).

In discussing civil rights, Mansfield does not go into great deal about civil rights by specifically referring to specific topics and events. Instead, he breaks this term down into two different ideas and discusses them in a definitive manner. Specifically, he sets forth that there are “natural” and civil rights. Natural rights are those rights that a civil society is founded on (i.e., life,

liberty and the pursuit of happiness). Civil rights, on the other hand, are the more specific and limited rights that are established in a civilized...

Other Papers Like A Comparative Essay

Comparative Essay

1351 words - 6 pages Comparative Essay Erika Shultz Professor Bradshaw Liberty University PHSC 210-A12 LUO August 12, 2013 Introduction We are aware that the universe exists, regardless; it is human nature to search for a deeper understanding. The controversial debate concerning the Big Bang Theory and a Six-Day Creation has been around for centuries. For years, thousands of people, including the “greatest minds in physics,” have pondered the beginning of

Comparative Essay

1294 words - 6 pages Comparative Essay: Original creation of the Earth PHSC 210, D03-LUO I. Introduction The old-Earth evolution and young-Earth creation debate has been one that has gone on for centuries. Each viewpoint seeks to give an answer to life’s most difficult questions or origins and how the Earth came to be what it resembles today. While the Young Earth viewpoint has remained constant and unchanged throughout the centuries the Old

Comparative Essay

2005 words - 9 pages Christy Penner Comparative essay The Americanization of Benjamin Franklin ( Wood,2004) and Abigail Adams (Holton, 2009) each depict historical figures before, during, and after the American revolution. Respectively, Woody Holton and Gordon S. Wood present unique aspects of Abigail Adams and Benjamin Franklin which highlight societal, institutional, and ideological changes brought about by the American revolution. Holton’s

Comparative Essay Of David

2508 words - 11 pages Compare of the Sculpture's of David Comparative Essay on David The biblical story of David and Goliath served as a great source of inspiration for many artists during the renaissance and Baroque era. The story of David embodied inner strength, power, a will to survive, a sense of triumph. Donatello, Verrocchio, Michelangelo and Bernini are artist who sought to bring to life this story through their

Comparative Analysis

818 words - 4 pages Comparative analysis In “Tip Jars and the New Economy” Dalton Conley claims that the economy needs to change instead of having people throw money into a tip jar. The author brings in outside sources and statistics along with his own experiences as support. Conley supports his claim by saying that, “you cannot order a coffee, buy a bagel, or pay for a photocopy without being asked to leave your change behind for ‘better service’ or

Comparative Essay: Christianity and Judaism

916 words - 4 pages Comparative Essay: Christianity and Judaism Christianity and Judaism are two widely known and practiced religions in the world. Though the two have multiple similarities, there are few differences that set the two apart. Their origins and beliefs are intertwined, and on a full scale, the religions are well developed and are vital to the religious follower’s walk with their deity. Judaism, the religion of the Jews, is far older than

Comparative Essay - One Punch Issue

1455 words - 6 pages One punch issue – comparative essay The recent focus on ‘one punch incidents’ in response to deaths on the streets of major cities, has prompted new laws controlling the behaviour of young revellers. Some commentators argue that the harsher penalties devised for these kinds of assaults, as well as the new lock out laws – was the only solution to the problem that threatens the reputation of Australian culture. Other more defensive voices

Comparative Crriminal Justice

1398 words - 6 pages Comparative Criminal Justice Essay 1 The goal of comparative studies is to extend a person’s knowledge of people and cultures beyond his or her own groups. Some comparative scholars have a better understanding of their own society and of ways that society might be improved. When thinking about research in comparative justice, there are two questions that we should ask ourselves; what is it that we want to compare? What are the

Romeo And Juliet Comparative

944 words - 4 pages Jade Tate Broadford secondary college Jade Tate Broadford secondary college Year Ten English Romeo and Juliet Comparative Essay Year Ten English Romeo and Juliet Comparative Essay Romeo and Juliet is one of Shakespeare’s most famous plays, known for its tragic storyline. There are many interpretations of Romeo and Juliet, one of the most widely recognised being Baz Luhrmann’s version. In comparing the Shakespearean Romeo and Juliet

Comparative Essay On Uninformitarianism And Catastophism

704 words - 3 pages Comparative Essay on Uniformitarianism and Catastrophism Dennis Jacobson L22609506 Professor Dr. Travis Bradshaw PHSC 210 Submitted December 10, 2012 Introduction The debate over Uniformitarianism and Catastrophism has been going on for decades. Uniformitariasm holds to the belief that certain processes that are happening today, have happened at the same rate in the past.(1


797 words - 4 pages The Plot of Amontillado In “The Cask of Amontillado”, Edgar Allan Poe builds a dark and eerie plot. Using strong diction and clear imagery, Poe develops a story of vengeance and rivalry. Like any plot, or the events of a story, Poe’s begins with an initial situation. In this particular story the initial situation is an insult followed by a vow for revenge. Fortunato and Montressor, the antagonist and protagonist, have known each other for

Related Essays

Characterization In Three Selected Works: A Comparative Essay

1995 words - 8 pages Characterization in Three Selected Works: A Comparative Essay In most pieces of fictional narrative or poetry characters are what drive the story. Characters reveal information, act out scenes and compel readers to keep turning pages with their ability to make an impression on the reader. Whether this impression is positive or negative well written characters connect the reader with the story in a way that is immersive. This essay will offer

Comparative Essay On "Great Expectations", "Romeo And Juliet", And "To Kill A Mocking Bird"

653 words - 3 pages "Great Expectations", "To Kill a Mocking Bird", and "Romeo and Juliet" are all very diverse pieces of literature. Each piece of literature is unique to one another, but they all share common characteristics and themes. All of the works include a key character that gains understanding of himself resulting from events in his life that caused confusions or prejudice.Pip, the main character of Great Expectations, learns a great amount resulting from

This Is A Comparative Essay Between Two Writters' Views On "The Lord Of The Rings: Return Of The King." While Both Critics Were Happy With The Outcome, One Was Far More Pleased Than The Other

535 words - 3 pages The two views, presented by Ty Burr and James Bernardinelli, on "The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King" are not radically different. The authors were both pleased with the movie, yet they held different appreciations and expectations. While James was more on the ecstatic side, Burr was left disappointed in a few areas.Both opinions could agree that the ending of the trilogy successfully met expectations provided by the two previous

Comparative Essay 867 Words

867 words - 4 pages Comparative Essay Classical Chinese and Ancient Egyptian cultures reveal the complexities of love through their works of literature, which involves the feminine chastity in a romantic plot. Throughout history, women set the role model for the appropriate engagement in premarital sexual behavior with men. In the Classical Chinese poem, “Zhongzi, Please,” we uncover a conservative female character who is afraid of society's criticisms if she is