This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

2nd Amendment Essay

2289 words - 10 pages

The Second Amendment

For many years there has been an ongoing debate over the Second Amendment and how it should be interpreted. The issue that is being debated is whether our government has the right to regulate guns. The answer of who has which rights lies within how one interprets the Second Amendment. With this being the case, one must also think about what circumstances the Framers were under when this Amendment was written. There are two major sides to this debate, one being the collective side, which feels that the right was given for collective purposes only. This side is in favor of having stricter gun control laws, as they feel that by having stricter laws the number of crimes ...view middle of the document...

These people argue that the Second Amendment was merely used to place the states’ organized military forces beyond the federal government’s power to be able to disarm them. This would guarantee that the states would always have sufficient force at their command to abolish federal restraints on their rights and to resist by arms if necessary. The Second Amendment was written shortly after the colonist had gained their freedom from Britain, and the reason for their gaining independence is that they were tired of living under British rule and especially under the leadership of King George the III. The gun control advocates argued that the Second Amendment grew out of the colonists" fear of standing armies and their belief that having militias that were composed of ordinary citizens was the surest way of maintaining their freedom (3).
The opposite side of this debate consists of those who claim that the amendment guarantees some sort of individual right to arms. This view comes from the literal wording of the Second Amendment, which states, "the right of the people to keep and bear arms, shall not be infringed." Along with this argument, the NRA and other groups in opposition of gun control argue that the first, fourth, ninth, and tenth amendments are all constructed to refer to the citizens as individuals and not as a collective state. These gun advocates feel that if one is to give a rational interpretation of the collective view to the constitution, then one would have to assume that the Framers referred to the individuals in the first, fourth, and ninth amendments; to the states in the second amendment, and then separated the states and the people in the tenth amendment, although they feel that this was inconsistent with the wording of the second amendment (5).
Proponents of strict gun control laws, including Handgun Control Inc., and Coalition to Stop Gun Violence argue that the Second Amendment guarantees a collective right rather than an individual right. When the occasion occurs that Americans find it necessary to band together to defend their rights, they are constitutionally guaranteed the right to own the firearms they need for that purpose. They advocate restrictions on some types of firearms by citing high numbers of gun-related deaths in the United States. These proponents argue that by making stricter gun laws this will in turn reduce the number to crimes that are committed with guns and would thus save lives. One of their supporting arguments is that each year in the United States, more than 35,000 people are killed by guns, which is a death rate that is much higher than any other nation. Attacks involving a gun are five times more likely to result in a death than in any similar attacks made with a knife. Also, in 1992 guns were the weapons used in approximately two-thirds of the murders of the United States (8). However, while gun control laws may decrease criminals access to guns, those same laws restrict law-abiding citizens.

Other Papers Like 2nd Amendment

Criminal Procedure Policy Essay

1120 words - 5 pages two years earlier, the Court had ruled in a case challenging a District of Columbia gun control regulation that the 2nd Amendment guaranteed an individual right to bear arms. The Court held that the 2nd Amendment right was thought by ratifiers of the 14th Amendment “among those fundamental rights necessary to our system of ordered liberty” and is therefore now a right fully enforceable against the state” ("The Issue: Does the Fourteenth Amendment

The Effect of Freedom Essay

1320 words - 6 pages The Effect of Freedom Kenneth N Geist HIS/301 Sept 19, 2011 University of Phoenix The Effect of Freedom The first Amendment, the first written text within the Constitution granting the right of freedom of speech, freedom of the press, to peacefully assemble, and to petition to the government for grievances. Though stated in simple terms, the views on them have been challenged on many occasions throughout U.S. history. Cases have been

The Right To Bear Arms A Constitutional Conflict

1968 words - 8 pages US v. Emerson. In DC v. Heller, the plaintiff argues that his Second Amendment rights were being violated because the District of Columbia prohibits the use of handguns. In Hellerm the court considered whether DC’s rules violate the 2nd Amendment of the United States Constitution. The court held that DC indeed violated the rights of the plaintiff. It does so by entirely banning the possession of a handgun, but also by making the attainability of

Modest Proposal: Right to Bear Arms

542 words - 3 pages Kendra Monteith B6 February 20, 2013 2nd Amendment and the Right to Bear Arms When people here about mass killings involving fire arms, they automatically think it’s the guns fault. As if the gun fired on its own. This makes people think that our right to own fire arms should be taken away. Take a second and think about this, who was holding the gun? The majority of mass killings are done by someone that has a mental illness. We

Appellate Brief - Legal

4026 words - 17 pages , 14 United States Court of Appeals Cases: Jeffries v. Harleston, 52 F.3d 9 (2nd Cir. 1995) ……………………………………….9, 10 Pappas v. Giuliani, 290 F.3d 143 (2nd Cir. 2002) …………………………………….9, 12 QUESTION PRESENTED 1. Under the First Amendment, is a blog created by a government employee, which contains matters of public concern and does not cause a disruption to the workplace

Gun Control

903 words - 4 pages our 2nd amendment will only make the people vulnerable to government power. James Q. Wilson a former teacher at Harvard University understands that taking guns away from the common people will only reduce the chance of surviving a possible attack of any sort of intruder.”Those that they cannot buy, they will steal or borrow”, Wilson talks about how whenever one tries to obtain a gun the legal way background checks occur as well as restricting

Gun Control

732 words - 3 pages shooting, steps are now being taken towards gun control. American is divided over the topic of gun control. Some people believe that we should ban assault weapons all together to help prevent massacres like these. On the other hand, some think that this is again out 2nd amendment right to bear arms. Some people think instead of banning weapons, we should increase school security with armed guards and increased safety and evacuation plans

Gun Control

2083 words - 9 pages protect the family. Thomas Jefferson had one of the great intellectual argument on gun control, he said Laws that prohibit the holding arms...deactivate merely those who are neither disposed nor resolute to commend crimes...Such laws create things poorer for the beaten and better for the .attacker. This is why we have a 2nd amendment that gives us the right to caring arms.The Second Amendment stated,' A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the

Gun Control - 1889 words

1889 words - 8 pages . comparing Germany with 31 guns per 100 people. And in addition to that the U.S. is ranking number one for private gun ownership, because of self-defense and our Constitution’s 2nd Amendment. “A well-regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms, shall not be infringed” (the Second Amendment Right to Bear Arms). The American people can argue that this goes hand and hand with

Gun Control - 978 words

978 words - 4 pages Problem-Solution Essay Syed Ahmed ENG111 Pete Baney March 29, 2013 In the 2nd amendment of the United States constitution it clearly says that the right to bear arms should not be infringed (US congress, 2nd amendment, 1791). This year one major topic that is being argued about is the right to bear arms and who should possess this right. When immigrants from far away lands

Gun Control - 919 words

919 words - 4 pages Michael Stone University of Phoenix Essentials of College Writing COMM/215 Maureen Chisholm September 14, 2014 Is Gun Control a Valid Argument America's founding fathers crafted the 2nd Amendment to protect its citizens from individual and collective threats both foreign and domestic. The individual citizens right to bear arms has been debated from the early 20th century to the present, both for and against. Although, the Supreme

Related Essays

Defendents Rights Essay

661 words - 3 pages in cases of incarceration and Smith states “the Scott committed a minor offense and did not have a right to counsel” (Smith, 2003, p.47). References Garcia, A. (1992). The Sixth Amendment in modern American jurisprudence a critical perspective. New York: Greenwood Press. Harr, J. S., & Hess, K. M. (2002). Constitutional law and the criminal justice system (2nd ed.). Belmont, CA: Wadsworth/Thomson Learning. Smith, C. E. (2003). Courts and trials: a reference handbook. Santa Barbara, Calif.: ABC-CLIO.

Gun Ownership Essay

1836 words - 8 pages , newspapers and even the internet, a lot of people have started thinking whether the U.S. Constitutions’ 2nd Amendment is restrictive enough or not. According to a case in the Supreme Court recently, there was an evaluation of the said Amendment and its context. A question needed answering which were whether there were any legitimate restrictions on gun ownership. According to the ruling of the Supreme Court, other Constitutional Amendments and

Uofp Essay

1368 words - 6 pages Arms, Militia and the Rights of the People Craig Parry, Jody Strickling, Quinton Farmer, Nathan Farmer, Robert Oldham University of Phoenix HIS/301 Instructor: William Gillespie June 29th, 2009 Arms, Militia and the Rights of the People “A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms shall not be infringed.”(2nd amendment, U.S Constitution) The framers of the

Shit Essay

992 words - 4 pages then take a step back and wonder if they really should risk their life in an attempt to extinguish the life of others. The ability to carry a firearm is not only a protector for you, but also a protector for those who are not carrying firearms around you. In the article, The Second Amendment is all For Gun Control, Adam Winkler writes to convince the readers that gun control has always been a part of the 2nd Amendment. The 2nd Amendment is about