12 Angry Men Critical Analysis Differences And Similarities Between The Book And The Movie

1116 words - 5 pages

In Twelve Angry Men, a boy is convicted of the murder of his father and 12 jurors are chosen to decide his fate. In the beginning, all of the evidence points to him being guilty. However, after a little bit of analysis of the evidence, there is some reasonable doubt. Slowly all of the Jurors accept the boy as innocent except for one very stubborn juror: Juror 3. The differences and similarities between the stage directions and the director’s shot selection in the film and in the text affect the reader’s interpretation of the final scene where Juror 3 says not guilty greatly.There are many similarities between the two versions. One similarity is how the jurors reacted to Juror ...view middle of the document...

He also thinks his opinion is more important than the others because he only stressed his opinion and not the others’. This detail alone suggests Juror 3 is hard to work with. The similarities brought out many good details in the story and the characters.There are also many differences between the text and film. One of them is how Juror 3 admits the boy is not guilty. In the play, all Reginald Rose wrote was that Juror 3 began to pound on the desk and seemed about to cry. He then said, “Not guilty.” The reader is left confused as to why Juror 3 just admitted to not guilty when he kept saying “guilty” throughout the play. The reader may think that Juror 3 felt overpowered by everyone and felt weak as opposed to 11 other people who had different viewpoints on the case. One may also think that Juror 3 got tired of the case and just wanted to leave. In the movie however, Juror 3 is shown ripping his son’s picture up with trembling hands and then crying. He also mentions how he worked his life out into his son, but for what? He got punched in the face and never saw his son again. From this small scene the reader can infer that Juror 3’s stubborn behavior was all caused by the grief of his son. It seemed as if Juror 3 realized that he shouldn’t punish the boy because of the memories he had of his son. Another difference is when Juror 3 is yelling at the others and angrily asking them how they can believe that the boy is innocent. The director does many choker shots of Juror 3 to show his facial expressions. His facial expressions express lots of anger towards the boy and the jurors. In the play there is no way to see the extent of the anger of the jurors because the play can only account for movements and tone of voice. In the movie Juror 3 just keeps saying not guilty without a valid reason until he talks...

Other Papers Like 12 Angry Men Critical Analysis - Differences And Similarities Between The Book And The Movie

Similarities and Differences Between Nyse and Nasdaq

715 words - 3 pages matching buyers and sellers together. A few of the similarities are that during trades, both exchanges use an electronic screen because of the fact they the screen based electronic stock exchanges. The Stock Exchange Commission synchronizes these two exchanges and joins in the activity of trading stock equities. As you can see, there are a number of similarities between the two exchanges however; there are also a number of

Similarities and Differences Between Bsn and Msn

521 words - 3 pages settings. Synergy with these Essentials, current and future healthcare reform legislation, and the action-oriented recommendations of the Initiative on the Future of Nursing (IOM, 2010) highlights the value and transforming potential of the nursing profession. Master’s education remains a critical component of the nursing education trajectory to prepare nurses who can address the gaps resulting from growing healthcare needs. Nurses who obtain the

12 Angry Men

811 words - 4 pages Elizabeth Herrera April 23, 2014 Comm 151 12 Angry Men: Communication Analysis In the film, 12 Angry Men, viewers come across a group of men who display the different communication dynamics – both the positive and negative sides. Chapter 7 encompasses the idea of Group and Team Communication Skills and how one should communicate effectively among others. To help better understand, 12 Angry Men is centered on a jury’s deliberation in a

12 Angry Men

1050 words - 5 pages 12 Angry Men Analysis In the movie “12 Angry Men” there is a young man on trial for murder. The year is 1957, so the jury consists of all white, middle class to upper class, middle aged and up men. Some of their occupations consist of architect, salesman, broker and a man in advertisement. Which if you know anything about a jury today it is completely different. You have many different people of all race, gender, and social class, within that

12 Angry Men Assignment

2041 words - 9 pages norms, social arrangement norms and resource allocation norms. (i) Performance norms: Performance norms is the indication of how hard the members of a group should work and what the expected level of output should be. When revising at the film; 12 Angry men, the performance norms was of significance throughout the entire movie. From the start, it was essential that the jurors perform in a certain way that a conclusion could be made without ruling

12 Angry Men

717 words - 3 pages 12 Angry Men Writing Assignment Final Exam Project Due: ________________________________________ (EDMODO) You will see a lot of psychological phenomena exhibited in the movie 12 Angry Men. Many of these phenomena are listed in the boxes on the next page. Your task for this assignment is to watch the movie, take note of these various psychological phenomena, and then write a cohesive 2-3 page paper discussing these themes. In writing your

12 Angry Men - 4618 words

4618 words - 19 pages the accused from being sent to the electric chair. Bibliography Orion-Nova Productions (Producer), & Lumet, S. (Director). (April 1957). 12 Angry Men [Motion picture]. USA: MGM. Lewicki, R. J., Saunders, D.M., & Barry, B. (2010). Effective Negotiating Techniques: From Selecting Strategies to Side-Stepping Impasses and Assumptions. Negotiation Readings, Exercises, and Cases, Sixth Edition, 1.5, 56-62. Lewicki, R. J., Saunders, D.M

12 Angry Men - 785 words

785 words - 4 pages The film 12 Angry Men depicts the challenge faced by a jury as they deliberate the charges brought against an 18 year old boy for the first degree murder of his father. Their task is to come to an impartial verdict, based on the testimony which was heard in court. The group went through the common stages of group development as presented in the text; forming, storming, norming, and performing (Robbins, & Judge, 2010) while personal prejudices

12 Angry Men - 5538 words

5538 words - 23 pages . J., Saunders, D. M., & Barry, B. (2010). Negotiation: Readings, exercises, and cases. New York: McGraw-Hill Irwin. Fonda, H. (Producer), & Lumet, S. (Director). (1957). 12 angry men [Motion picture]. United States of America: Orion-Nova Productions.

12 Angry Men Essay

1530 words - 7 pages The Final Verdict of 12 Angry Men On the average, about five parents are killed by their biological children in the United States every week. Matricide and patricide are both very rare events when considered in terms of the thousands of individuals arrested every year for murder. Killings of mothers and fathers each constitute about 1 percent of all homicides in the United States in which the victim-offender relationship is known. Did he do it

Differences Between Men And Women

648 words - 3 pages DRAFT Introduction: Have you ever thought that why people are different from each other? There are many differences such as intelligence, opinions, appearances, personalities which are the most basic one. Genders represent the differences and also similarities between men and women. Both sexes differ from each other greatly in some respect such as physical power, communication and also emotional needs. Body Paragraph: A) Topic Sentence

Related Essays

12 Angry Men Movie Analysis

805 words - 4 pages Twelve Angry Men Analysis BA 321 Reaching a unanimous vote, beyond a reasonable doubt, was a difficult task for the jurors represented in the film, 12 Angry Men. All but one were convinced the boy on trial was guilty of first degree murder based on eye witness testimony and circumstantial evidence. Uncomfortably hot and sweaty, one intent on getting to a ball game, eleven of the twelve jurors had no intention to stop and

Belonging; The Crucible And 12 Angry Men

1248 words - 5 pages Crucible” and Sidney Lumet’s movie take on Reginald Rose’s screenplay “12 Angry Men”. Likewise, a feeling of disconnectedness and disparity is explored as strong themes in both texts through the idea that individuals will adhere to their own moral bearings despite the pressure of majority’s, thus evicting themselves from gaining a sense of belonging. Both texts have guided the notion of belonging to depend upon ones morals. If an individual is

Consensus And 12 Angry Men Essay

885 words - 4 pages I recently watched a dramatic “case study” on group behavior and communication: the 1957 movie 12 Angry Men. The movie shows how one individual shaped and ultimately changed the direction of a group decision. The story goes that 12 jurors must reach a verdict that could require the death penalty for an 18-year-old defendant charged with stabbing his father to death. The jurors must reach consensus—the verdict must be unanimous. When they

12 Angry Men Film Analysis

548 words - 3 pages when Juror Three was the only one still voting guilty he gave in to the peer pressure and changed his vote. I believe that 12 Angry Men is an excellent movie to use when analyzing group communication and conflict, different communication climates, as well as the use of persuasive speaking.